vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

I've had both the 2017 biore watery rich aqua essence and gel for a little over a month now. This post has my thoughts on the new sunscreens and how they compare with the 2015 versions. Here's a quick summary:

  • Neither reformulation is as pleasant as the 2015 version. Both the 2017 essence and gel are thicker, stickier, and take longer to dry compared to the 2015 version

  • I found the gel to be a particularly large down step. It feels like coagulated version of the 2015 gel with a white cast added

  • After using the essence for almost 4 weeks, I find that the differences bother me less and less. It's still a perfectly serviceable sunscreen and on my (dry) skin I find it rather mattifying and like that it is less shiny than the 2015 version

I also discuss various sunscreens (all Japanese, similarly priced, SPF 50+ PA++++, accessible without a forwarding service) I like better than the 2017 versions and think most people will too. Big shout out to Nivea sun protect plus milky essence, which IMO is the most underrated sunscreen out there.

47
Aquamaraqua•

The main feature for me that pulls me to the 2017 reformulation is that it is waterproof. Or so it claims to be. I am okay with thicker consistency as long as it can resist sweat. The Nivea sun milk for me has too many triggers, but just a few minutes ago I was willing to give it a shot until I pulled up a CosDNA page. Thank you for the reviews! I think I will purchase the Skin Aqua one.

16
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

It's not waterproof. It's water-resistant. The way I personally interpret water-resistant is I can wear it through a light drizzle, but if I'm going to be hanging out in a pool I'd still use a sunscreen specifically formulated for outdoor activity and water sports.

For me, the Biores aqua rich watery series is and remains a everyday use sunscreen, so while water and sweat resistance is a move in the right direction, I don't like that it comes at the cost of pleasantness of use.

30
Aquamaraqua•

Ah yes. My wording. I don't really do water based sports so I am okay with it being sebum and water resistant. And yeah I can see why... Thankfully there are some great options outside the reformulation.

8
Kattty5•

Which outdoor sunscreens are you using? I still can't find my HG :(

2
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

Sunbears Super Strong Plus and Sunplay Superblock are the ones I use for extended time outside or for sports. I also have Anessa Perfect UV Sunscreen Aqua Booster for surfing.

4
PoroSashimi•

I agree, alcohol and BHT? No thanks, lol.

0
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

All 4 Biores contain BHT as well.

3
PoroSashimi•

Which is why I don't use those, lol. I'm pretty sure the perfect milks don't have bht.

-2
ABirdOfParadise•

I'll base what sunscreen I use exactly the same way as I do the rest of my routine.

By how cool the packaging looks.

26
HadalqualitiesNW10|Acne/Pores|Oily|FR•

Half of my liking of my Etude House Sunprise! mild airy finish is that I so love saying "sunprise!" in a chirpy tone whenever I use it. (And it's great and matte, too.)

8
ceimi•

Wish I could do the same lol. :)

2
weekendlush•

😭 same! I'm lucky I have resistant skin so I can be shallow and look at pretty bottles lol

2
ABirdOfParadise•

Yeah Tactupump/Epiduo really made my skin have something like Wolverine's quick healing factor

2
KeriEatsSouls•

In my opinion, Kose Suncut sunscreen is far superior. No white cast and superior long-lasting sun protection = happy, non-lobster me. I used Biore for awhile because it's so well-loved on here but, despite slathering it on, Id always get sunburned. I have yet to get burned with the Kose one.

16
ludecknight•

What's your skin type, if you don't mind me asking?

2
KeriEatsSouls•

Usually dry but can be combination in the Summer. Im sure thats a very lacking description but I am not as well versed in the terminology as most people on the sub.

4
turtle91•

Which kose suncut are you using? Is it the one in yellow bottle?

1
KeriEatsSouls•

Mine is in a baby blue bottle. Lately they have Disney characters on them.

1
simushahin96•

Do you use the essence or the gel?

1
KeriEatsSouls•

I wasn't sure so I had to go look at the bottle lol the essence! Mine has a cute Winnie the Pooh and Piglet on it but I assume that's a limited design.

3
simushahin96•

Ahh nice to know! I'll be ordering the gel soon :)

2
jenniemad•

Is it fairly water resistant? Where I live turns into a swamp in summer with super high humidity. I've been researching new sunscreens because neither the biore or shiseido senka can withstand the humidity indoors, let alone outside.

1
KeriEatsSouls•

It holds up pretty well in my experience. I live in Okinawa Japan and it's super humid here almost all the time (like 80+% humidity) and hot af. I sweat like a crazy person in summers here but I don't get sunburned. :)

2
jenniemad•

Awesome! And our summers can get up to 90-100% humidity so I feel your pain. At least Oki has some gorgeous beaches, or that's what I've heard from friends stationed there.

1
KeriEatsSouls•

The beaches here are pretty but not great for walking on the sand for the most part (mostly sharp coral and shells and stuff). :D It sounds like we live in similar climates, in which case I think the sunscreen should work for you similarly (although I'm sure it's possible differences in skin type or body chemistry or who knows could make things work differently from person to person).

2
umeshusawa•

Thanks for the review! In addition to the Nivea Sun Protect Plus Milky Essence, which your review says is waterproof, I also see on Amazon (Japan) the Waterproof UV Milk. Have you tried that by any chance? Thanks!

7
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

I haven't! Nivea was one year late to the PA++++ party (they went PA++++ in 2016, Biore did it in 2015) so I've only really recently started paying attention to their sunscreens. The Waterproof UV Milk sounds really promising though. Definitely adding to my list!

3
umeshusawa•

Thanks! I'll be sure to give both a try then. I love the finish of the Biore Bright Milk but find it so drying, so I'm trying to find something else that will fit the bill.

1
goofygooberrock•

I have! It's definitely an outdoor sport sunscreen, quite heavy duty. It stung my face too. Something like Menturm Sunbears Super Strong Plus might be a less drying dupe of bright milk?

2
umeshusawa•

Ouch, sorry to hear it stung your face! Do you like the Sunbears? I'm using Menturm The Sun Essence but it's got such a shiny finish and doesn't have much staying power...

1
goofygooberrock•

I LOVE Sunbears! It has a great finish and the packaging is super cute hehe. I think Menturm the Sun and Menturm Sunbears are totally different lines. That's a shame you didn't have good luck with the Essence, I've just bought the Menturm The Sun UV Watery Milk but haven't tried it. There aren't many reviews around for those products!

(PS I should have said YMMV with the Nivea sports milk, a lot of products sting my face but may not irritate another person with less sensitive skin. But it's definitely heavy duty.)

2
borzoisoverflowers•

I loved the chicken nuggets comparison. Struggled not to laugh and trigger a coughing fit. Darn flu. Thanks for the review! I've been shopping for sunscreens so this is perfect timing.

6
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

I might have been eating them while writing this LOL. Glad you enjoyed it and feel better!

5
GalyndeanNW15|Acne|Dry/Normal|US•

It made me nostalgic for the old french fry oil.

What I wouldn't give for McD's french fries fried in beef tallow.

5
pinkvoltageNW10|Aging/Pores|Dehydrated|US•

I never got to experience this but I wish I had. :(

1
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

Same! Especially considering how delicious McDonalds fries still are. I can't even imagine what they tasted like with tallow

1
retrotechlogos•

Thanks for the review!

P.S. for anyone considering doing a review of the new gold=packaging Skin Aqua Super UV Moisture Milk I would forever be in your debt if you did :).

6
apidae92•

I didnt know the sun bears were a sports sunscreen.I love those little things! I still notice I tan with them on my shoulders, though. (And I apply so much and reapply so often :( texas sun is too much! ) thanks for the reviews!!

5
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

I used to favor Western sunscreens for sports because they feels more substantial so I kind of subconsciously assumed they work better, but at some point a year (maybe 2 years?) back I applied sun bears to one arm and skinceuticals sport uv defense on the other, and the skinceuticals melted off while the sun bears didn't budge. After that, I was pretty sold on its water/sweat resistance!

7
apidae92•

That makes me feel so much better, since it's so cheap and I've been so worried about using USA sunscreen and noticing I'm tanning and old acne marks on my shoulders are coming back. Thanks for the reply!!

1
stufstufNW45|Oily|UK•

God's above. I knew it had a white cast, damnit. How frustrating, I'll have to stock up on the 2015 gel.

5
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

It does fade and on my face (which is slightly paler than my arm) it's less obvious, but it never fully fades and life's too short to worry about white casts, you know?

4
pizzafries0NC37|Pores|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

people have different skin tones so it's not so easy for everyone to just let a white cast fly by. it can be make or break.

11
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

I phrased that poorly. What I meant is life is too short to bother with sunscreens with a white cast. I fall in the category of people who can't get away with using white cast sunscreens.

15
stufstufNW45|Oily|UK•

I liked it, and my mom liked it because on our NC/NW 45 skin it had no real whitcast on us. If it does, then it's pretty much worthless to us :(

10
iHugDomo•

I need to stock up too! Do you know any sites that have the old formulation for a decent price?

1
Blue_Tomat0•

One question though. The biore suncreen is one of the more popular ones out there. Would anyone know why they changed the formula, and is there a price increase? I'm worried that we'll be paying more for less product :(

5
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

Japanese skin care products are commonly reformulated every couple of years. Happens with cleansing oils a lot too, for instance.

5
RonrinesuN10-15|Dullness|Normal/Dry|FR•

I'm really tempted to try the new versions but I have such a big sunscreen stock atm and that would be absolutely unreasonable. Bioré Watery Essence and Gel are my lazy and winter days sunscreens but I would absolutely not recommend them for harsh summers and for long exposures.

5
softasapandaNW10|Aging/Pores|Combo|DE•

Whyyy Biore? I only just started wearing the 2015 Essence a few weeks ago, and love it so much that I ordered 4 more tubes after reading this and a few other comparisons. It's the only sunscreen I have ever enjoyed putting on.

4
tokyoacid•

You summed up my feelings for McNuggets. I miss the dark meat ones so bad :(

4
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

RIGHT?? I had to google when they made the switch, which made me feel very old, and also very sad that 14 years later I'm still a little hung up about it LOL

4
SapphireCherry•

A bit disappointed that the new versions didn't turn out to be as good as the old

3
mrshobutt•

I was never a huge fan of the Biore sunscreens, guess I can continue skipping them.
Interesting that the Nivea Milky Essence is one of the sunscreens pilling the least for you, it pilled so much for me, I wanted to throw it against a wall.

3
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

That's so strange! It's one of the few sunscreens I have that I can buff a liquid foundation over and not worry about bits of sunscreen balling up. Do you have any sunscreens you love?

4
mrshobutt•

My skincare is slightly different now than it was last year, I might just try it again. Can't resist the sunscreens :D
I really loved the Biore Milk (completely forgot about that now that it's cold and the poor guy is stuck in the fridge XD), Menturm the sun UV Watery Milk and the Mujirushi Sun Lotion. They're all more or less mattifying, light and perfect for my skin in humid Japanese summer.

1
kiwi_butt•

This is a great review. The Nivea Milky Essence used to be my HG but now I find it too drying and I burned pretty badly while using it once. The other sunscreens you mentioned seem very promising, I'll try some of these next.

3
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

Ugh that's disappointing! I'll make a mental note not to use it for too long outdoors.

3
siassias•

The style and presentation of this review is excellent! Thank you for writing it and sharing.

3
dearhan•

The 2017 biore is the very first one I've tried and I really enjoy it. But after reading some of the reviews, it makes me wonder what I'm missing out on with the previous formulation lol. I'll have to look into the Nivea one though!

3
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

It's still good, and I appreciate the reduction in shininess, but it's just not as instantly drying as the old version. If you like it though, keep using it!

3
dearhan•

Lol yes! I will definitely keep using it. I purchased 3 of the essence and the gel to share with family hehe

2
myfirstloveisfoodNC20|Acne/Pigmentation|Combo|US•

Ugh I thought it was my imagination that my 2017 Biore felt stickier than my previous repurchases.

2
cilucia•

Great post! I'll need to do some research once I finish up my tube and a half of the old essence sunscreens :)

1
crotchblinder•

Thanks for this review!

1