vavuchekKyle Lowry•

I think Fangraphs bases this heavily on FIP

13
cbarone1•

This also takes into account not just the starters, but the rotational depth. That is an area in which we are extremely lacking.

10
atomicbonerthrust•

Exactly. The Jays have two guys who FIP overlooks (Marco and Happ) and also don't have anything past their first five, so this ranking makes sense.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
raybond007BUNCHA BANGERS•

Stroman is also under-valued by FIP due to relatively low K% but incredibly high GB%

1
BasedPython#🍆•

His FIP is still under his ERA, so not by much.

3
Ferivich•

Which is common as it's more indicative of future performance.

2
haliveraOP•

To an extent, it's a better indicator of future performance than ERA, but it is also faulty in that certain pitchers out perform, or under perform their FIP every year. We have a lot of those. Sanchez, Happ, and Estrada all fall into that category, which makes our pitching look a lot worse than it really is. On the other hand, Pineda on the Yankees always underperforms extremely compared to his ERA, which is why the Yankees are in the top 15.

You would think that FanGraphs, knowing this is the case, would make some adjustments when writing their projections because otherwise all the list really is, is a list ordered by a knowingly flawed metric.

3
allirowThis ban has been brought to you by Kitchen Aid™•

fWAR primarily uses FIP, bWAR primarily uses ERA.

The Jays have a lot of FIP breaking pitchers, it's not unexpected.

0
will2099•

It's not totally unfair. I mean they are just projections in the end.

In any given year a team should expect ~30 starts to be taken by a "sixth" starter. So almost like a full starter's workload.

In 2016 the Jays were remarkably healthy/lucky in this regard. The only needed 10 starts from this "sixth" starter which turned out to be Liriano (8) and Hutchinson (2), who could be argued were #5b and 5c in a six man rotation anyway.

In 2015, that collectively sixth starter was a shitfest combination of Felix Doubront, Jeff Francis, Scott Copeland, Matt Boyd...probably worse that I can't remember right now. We needed to add a #1 starter in Price and get Stroman back for a few great starts to even just make the playoffs.

In 2017, this sixth starter is currently projected to be...Casey Lawrence and Mat Latos. So yeah, that's not good. The minute any of our top five has to miss any time, it's right to replacement level or lower.

7
haliveraOP•

The minute any of our top five has to miss any time, it's right to replacement level or lower.

This is the case for every team other than a few lucky ones. Look through the list and there are maybe a couple with a legit 6th starter. A team would never spend much money on a player that is essentially an injury replacement when every team has other holes. In addition, no valuable pitcher wants to be stuck as a long reliever/in AAA as a 6th starter waiting for an injury or for someone to suck.

I mean by definition a 6th starter is a replacement. They are the definition of replacement level.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
haliveraOP•

That's not really true. Look at the teams who made the playoffs in the AL last year. Red Sox had depth in pitching, but the Indians, Rangers and Orioles didn't. It's helpful yet, but most teams don't have true SP depth.

There just literally aren't enough good pitchers for more than a few teams to have good 6th starters.

And 1 WAR isn't replacement level. WAR literally stands for Wins Above Replacement. That is, wins over that which a replacement level player would get.

Also the problem is that the projections undervalue our SPs. We do have great starting 5, but they don't see them like that. They see them as a pretty average top 5.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Stinky_DungBeatleThee Ultra Rogers Shill•

Our rotation isn't the flashiest due to all the BS advanced metrics but in the end the outcome will probably be the same and it will be one of the better if not the best of the AL.

3
JAYRM21•

Yeah, I get that this is based on mathematical projections (which almost always take the under) and not opinion, but it still annoys me.

They legitimately have a top 5 rotation in baseball, fangraphs should at least acknowledge the strong likelihood of them outperforming the projections.

3
TheArgsenal•

They ranked us at 25 last year, so take their projections with a grain of salt.

3
ZebramouseGET UP BALL...GONE!•

Bullshit.

2
sigbox#LetsRise 🙌•

Gibbon's thoughts on this:

Gibby: "Fangraphs, what's that?

Reporter: "An advanced stats website."

Gibby: "Well there you go."

2
1slinkydink1•

I thought that this was a joke. lolo amazing

1
luckysharms93Doc•

FIP is a joke.

1
Myerz99•

Shit article from a guy who has no understanding of what makes Happ and Estrada great.

1