Comparison of GOAT contender winrates during their period of dominance
I think winrates are very interesting to compare players from different era. But they have two big problems :
- It is not very meaningful for currently active players, because winrates usually go down at the very end of a player career.
- It actually punishes longevity : a late bloomer like Fed or a player that play very late like Connors can't be higher than someone like Borg that had a very short and dominant career.
I decided to compare the winrates of the best players in history during their period of dominance. A period of dominance is defined as such :
- It starts the first year that a player either reaches a GS finals, a WTF finals or ends in the top 4.
- It ends the last year that he finishes in the top 4.
For the Big 4, I consider that they are still in their period of dominance. Since it's not clear for Nadal (he has not finished in the top 4 since 2014) I put him twice, one that ends in 2014 and one extended that goes up to today. I didn't do the same for Federer since he's pretty much certain to finish in the top 4 in 2017 and his domination is pretty strong right now.
Here are the results (GS = Grand Slams, period duration includes 2017 for the big 4) :
| Player | Period (years) | First year | Wins | Losses | Winrate | GS wins | GS losses | GS winrate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Borg | 8 | 1974 | 565 | 72 | 88.7 | 131 | 13 | 91 |
| Federer | 15 | 2003 | 937 | 153 | 86 | 288 | 37 | 88.6 |
| Lendl | 12 | 1980 | 910 | 148 | 86 | 201 | 34 | 85.5 |
| Nadal (short) | 10 | 2005 | 661 | 111 | 85.6 | 181 | 21 | 89.6 |
| Connors | 15 | 1973 | 1049 | 177 | 85.6 | 204 | 33 | 86.1 |
| McEnroe | 12 | 1978 | 751 | 133 | 85 | 134 | 25 | 84.3 |
| Djokovic | 11 | 2007 | 709 | 126 | 84.9 | 215 | 29 | 88.1 |
| Nadal (extended) | 13 | 2005 | 777 | 149 | 83.9 | 203 | 28 | 87.9 |
| Murray | 10 | 2008 | 545 | 128 | 81 | 165 | 33 | 83.3 |
| Sampras | 11 | 1990 | 672 | 160 | 80.8 | 175 | 26 | 87.1 |
###Analysis
- It's pretty impressive how much ahead Borg is. But he stopped his career very early, and there is no doubt that he would have been in the top 4 much longer if he had kept playing. On his last real year on the tour (1981) he reached 3 GS finals and won one. Connors probably wouldn't have won any GS in 1982-1983 (he won 3) if Borg had been playing. So overall, it's difficult to compare with the other. But it is pretty clear to me that if Borg played more Slams he would have been a serious contender for Federer as most GS titles. He only participated in 27 Slams in his career, that one less than Federer number of GS finals...
- Among the players with more than 10 years of dominance, it's pretty close between Lendl, Federer, Connors, Nadal, McEnroe and Djoko around 85-86% (so pretty much everyone). Actually Lendl is 0.04% above Federer but he can reach him by winning Miami. When it comes to Grand Slams, the big 3 is above the pack, and Nadal is actually above Fed when only taking is consideration the shorter period.
- Sampras is pretty low in overall winrate, but his GS winrate is more than decent. It confirms the idea that there was no real dominance in the 90's but Sampras had the mental strength to give his best during the main tournaments. It is even clearer when we see that he won the US Open in 2002, way past his period of dominance (ended in 2000).
- Despite being a relatively late bloomer, Federer has the longest period of dominance with Connors. Let's hope it keeps going :D (no bias here)
- As expected, Murray is behind everyone but not as much as I thought. His winrate is pretty decent and he really suffered from playing against 3 of the very best players in history.
###Comparisons with Federer over similar periods
Nadal (10 years) and Borg (8) have had far shorter periods of dominance than Federer (15), so it becomes difficult to compare them. Let's see how Fed fares if we 'cut' his period after 8 and 10 years. I also added Djokovic impressive domination from 2011 to 2016.
| Player | Period (years) | First year | Wins | Losses | Winrate | GS wins | GS losses | GS winrate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Borg | 8 | 1974 | 565 | 72 | 88.7 | 131 | 13 | 91 |
| Federer 03-10 | 8 | 2003 | 585 | 81 | 87.9 | 182 | 16 | 91.9 |
| Nadal 05-14 | 10 | 2005 | 661 | 111 | 85.6 | 181 | 21 | 89.6 |
| Federer 03-12 | 10 | 2003 | 720 | 105 | 87.3 | 221 | 23 | 90.6 |
| Djokovic 11-16 | 6 | 2011 | 427 | 50 | 89.5 | 143 | 13 | 91.7 |
| Federer 04-09 | 6 | 2004 | 442 | 51 | 89.7 | 149 | 10 | 93.7 |
While Borg remains on top of the overall winrate, Fed is unbeatable on GS winrate over similar periods of time. It's also interesting to see that he has in 8 years as many wins in slams as Nadal in 10 years. Federer didn't miss a single slam in 16 consecutive years while Rafa missed 5 in 10 years and Borg missed 8 in 8 years.
Obviously, such comparisons have flaws and don't recognize some great achievements like Connors US semi-finals in 1991 or Sampras US Open win in 2002 when they were clearly past their peak period. Also we'll see how long the big 4 will manage to keep their undisputed domination.
Posted Mar 28, 2017, 12:23 PM UTC