CMV: The word transgender is misused more often than used correctly.
Themes of sex, gender, gender identity, and transgenderism are common both here, but also throughout the modern world. While there is some confusion around terms such a sex, gender, and gender identity, I believe the most misunderstood word of the bunch is transgender.
So very quickly, let's review some definitions:
-
Sex - biology (chromosomes, primary sexual organs, hormones, secondary sexual characteristics, etc.)
-
Gender - those aspects of personality which society has tethered to a particular sex (pink vs blue, trucks vs dolls, doctors vs nurses, etc.). Since society can change its mind about which characteristics go with which gender, that is why gender is often accused of being a social construct.
-
Transgender - someone whose sex and gender do not match. Someone whose biology does not match societies expectations for them. Someone who is biologically male, but enjoys pink dresses and dislikes beer and football would be transgender. Tomboys are transgender.
However, it is also common to have this definition of Transgender
- Transgender - someone who is not comfortable with the biological sex nature has assigned to them. Someone who is transgender and biologically male, desires female biological features (vagina, breasts).
In this way, the word transgender has come to refer to people whose gender doesn't align with their sex, and also has come to refer to people whose sex doesn't align with their desired sex.
However, there is another word - Transsexual - which has the exact same meaning as #4 (being physically uncomfortable with one's own biological sex).
My argument is essentially that people have taken to using the word transgendered when they mean transsexual. This in turn is causing confusion in regards to the conversation about gender/LGBT that is currently occurring.
How to change my view:
-
Demonstrate that at least one of my definitions is wrong.
-
Demonstrate that lumping transsexuals under the label of transgender does not substantially muddy the waters.
Edit: I feel that comments are focusing on point 1- that my definitions are wrong (usually arguing that they are old or archaic), but haven't really touched on point 2- that the conversation about the trans community is muddled, largely because many terms (which I grant isn't limited to transgender or transsexual) are ambiguous or subsume other categories. I suppose I would like a few attempts at addressing this - that the conversation concerning the trans community would be substantially clearer and more focused if we used words with more affixed definitions and didn't subsume each other.
This is a footnote from the CMV moderators. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views**! Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!
Posted Mar 29, 2017, 5:01 PM UTC · edited