2 stocks vs 3 stocks

Smash 4

I don't see this discussed very much any more, and frankly I just don't see why this got swept under the rug.

This game has evolved A LOT since the 2 stock rule was implemented. New characters like Bayonetta that can literally steal your stock at 0%, gimping methods/offstage play improving dramatically, the banning of Duck Hunt to prevent time out issues as well as the plethora of upsets that always happen (Civil War was insane). Its just not the slow game it used to be.

People said a big reason Duck Hunt was banned was that they didn't want timeouts on the big stage at EVO. Would it really be much better if someone SD's and the opponent proceeds to play super safe and maintain their lead (I think this is more likely than a timeout btw)? I don't think people want to watch that either.

I think that variability can be hype, but when ALL you have is variability it suggests the game is not consistent. Losing a stock from an SD might as well be the whole match in some scenarios, you're pretty much guaranteed to lose that game if you do and that can easily put you on tilt for no reason. A common argument against 3 stock is that it will take more time to finish a tourney, but if you only have to play 2 games instead of 3 then it will indeed end quicker. I noticed that there are a lot more 2-0s at Melee locals than at Smash 4 locals, where (at least at my locals), 2-1 is actually more common than 2-0.

I don't even know where or how this change would be implemented, but it seems to be more common in Europe, and I would really like to see it at least tested here.

EDIT: Multiple people saying sets would be too long. Can someone please link me to a 2/3 set that was really 20 minutes? I essentially never see matches like this and people in this thread acting like its commonplace.

Posted Mar 30, 2017, 6:03 PM UTC · edited

117
Tablecork•

The sets can already run to 20 minutes with passive play. Last time I watched a 3 stock tournament every set took forever. My favourite part of watching smash is how fast paced it is and how quickly the sets can move

20
dakattack101OP•

Sets actually cannot last 20 minutes with the current 2 out of 3 ruleset. 6*3 = 18 minutes, plus 30 minutes for coaching between sets is at most 19 minutes if every game is a time out.

If you have a problem watching a 3/5 set that goes for longer than 20 minutes, then you wouldn't watch any top matches in Smash 4 or in Melee, regardless of passive/defensive play.

-8
Tablecork•

Well I was speaking about 2 out of 3, of course I don't mind long sets for top 16 or top 8. What I was referring too was total video length on YouTube, I've seen videos that were 19 or 20 minutes between like a sonic or sheik.

In General, numbers aside, I find three stocks just too long. In the words of esam, two stocks is "comfy."

9
dakattack101OP•

Honestly don't see why I'm being downvoted.

Your argument is that some (very few) matches go on too long, but provide no real evidence or back it up other than saying Sheik or Sonic, but the best Sheik and Sonic players that are known or that I know don't usually lead to time outs. You just provide your anecdotal evidence from ESAM, and I completely disagree because I feel extremely uncomfortable the entire game.

In Smash 64 or Melee, I feel like I can take risks and still be rewarded because I have enough stocks to take those risks. In this game, I feel like I can't take risks at all because I may lose my stock and that is essentially the entire game. Thus 2 stock really encourages passive play, not 3 stock.

-6
Tablecork•

Okay so you're right, those sets I was talking about were best of fives. However, my point still stands, as a spectator I would rather the shorter sets.

I think there's two different ways you can look at this. As a player I know what you mean, I have a habit of sding, and the comeback potential afterwards is very low. But for me to watch top 32, I have to spend basically my entire day watching. Usually I have to watch it over several days

I think the general opinion is that 2 stocks is fine, especially with how recovering in smash 4 is much easier than in melee.

5
Absolutely_Not_Zeromy mom never bought me melee•

Don't SD.

8
DangerAwarMelee Falcon, because I like losing with style•

I vastly prefer 3 stocks but logistically it's a pain so I can understand the reluctance

Smash 4 is a lot slower than Melee and even matches that aren't campy still often take 4 or 5 minutes, so across hundreds of sets it can add hours to a tourney

In particular it could severely hurt tourneys that have multiple smash games which would just be problematic - you can't have one ruleset for 4 only and another for combination tourneys

That said I think 2 stocks is such a dumb number. It feels wrong. 3-5 feels like what smash "should" be based on my gut. Can't really explain it.

6
Captainl53•

I think a big thing is the fact the characters may determine the pace at times. For example, a ZSS vs Fox round could end in like 1-2 minutes becuase both characters are meant to be aggressive. On the other hand, a Villager vs Rosalina match could take as long as 4-5 minutes because Rosalina is super defensive and deals with Villager's projectiles very well.

5
TeamDogfightknuck knuck it's cuckles•

2-stock might as well just be 1-stock in a game where Rage exists.

I have been in favor of a 3-stock, 8-minute meta since the beginning.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DJCzerny•

Part of the issues is the characters being played. Sure if the vast majority of popular characters were fast-fallers or heavies then 3 stock would probably be the best for viewers and players. But when we still have a significant amount of campy/slow character matchups, it's not feasible to play 3 stock where so many matches would last too long.

1
hezzer3#FreeTheMiis•

We had a Bo5 3 stock grand finals that went to game 10 and lasted over an hour. Each game went to 7-8 minutes long and there were no timeouts. IIRC the vid is 1 h 20 mins long, and it was exhausting to watch and commentate. So they can go on too long, especially with careful low-level play

1
dakattack101OP•

link?

1
hezzer3#FreeTheMiis•

Just had a look and my memory had failed me, the set was only an hour long. Ignore the ghetto commentary and playing Lmao

https://youtu.be/9XccFH5roMY

1
Myst_R•

My question about this topic is : "is there a way to PROVE that upsets happen more often in 2 stocks than in 3 stocks ?"

Despite the consistance a competitive system leads to, since competitors are human beings, there will always be upsets.

Mathematically, we know that the 2 stocks format is proven to offer more flexibility in the organisation of a tournament than the 3 stocks one. Plus, it allows to propose Bo5 earlier in the bracket as the games are quicker.

So my point is, if the 3 stocks format doesn't give any real advantage on the 2 stocks one, we should keep 2 stocks. However, if 3 stocks comes to be proven more significant in terms of results (meaning it gives less opportunities to upsets for example) so the question of the format must be reconsidered.

P.S.: Even if Civil War was full of upsets, I really need a way to conclude that the 2 stocks format was actually the cause of these upsets

1