Carrera-Smoak Unorthodox Platoon?
Yes, I know Smoak plays 1B, and Carrera plays LF. Yes I know Justin Smoak is a Switch Hitter. But, consider this:
For his career, Carrera has been a much better hitter against Lefties (98 wRC+) than against Righties (78 wRC+). Conversely, Justin Smoak is a much better hitter (100 wRC+) when he bats left against righties, than from the other side (83 wRC+). Both of the guys have a fairly substantial difference in production over a significant sample size, so it's unlikely that changes this season.
I know it isn't the typical platoon, but playing Carrera in LF and Pearce at 1B against Lefties, and Smoak at 1B, Pearce at LF against Righties, should actually give us pretty good production about the spot that should be our hole.
Posted Apr 3, 2017, 3:52 PM UTC
Pearce has never stayed healthy enough to play a full season every day. That's why I thought it was stupid to release Upton, who could have played LF with Smoak at 1B vs lefties and Coghlan/Pearce vs righties. Keeps Pearce the hell away from the OF where he'll get hurt
I suspect it won't matter. Upton fucking sucks anyway.
We're all going to forget about him within a couple weeks unless there's a major OF injury.
Upton is likely no better than Ceciliani at this point anyhow.
Upton still had a 107 wRC+ vs lefties w/ us and that was a huge decline over his 143 w/ San Diego. That's way better than Zeke and if regresses to his career averages even remotely, he'd be by far our best platoon option. If he and Coghlan hit at their career averages, we'd have a 115 wRC+ hitter in LF with good defence and good speed, and if Upton hit like he did with SD and Coghlan like he did in 2015, it'd be like a 140 wRC+ player. That's like having an Edwin in LF.
Pearce will be an interesting test case for the high performance team... He's never played a full season, but he's never had this level of conditioning coaching.
He claims he's never trained like this, and feels the best he's ever felt (tempering this with the fact that every player always claims their in the best shape of their career every spring).