r/communism•
Fkkize

Shifting a societies baseline?

Leftist tactics seem very explicit and direct in stating their goals. What do you guys think of of subtley shifting the baselines in a society? Often I find liberals agreeing with me on far left talking points if I haven't used terms like "anarchism", "socialism" or "communism", whereas they like to go on the offensive (gommunizm killed 200 trillion people) when I do. At least it seems to have worked for the right wingers.

Posted Apr 10, 2017, 10:06 PM UTC

05
Zhang_Chunqiao•

What makes you think that hasn't been tried before in the past 200 years of socialist thought and praxis?

6
FkkizeOP•

If it has it wasn't very effective compared to what the right wing is doing.

1
simone_beauvoir•

This is called reformism and if you want proof of how it doesn't work, just look at the United States right now. After decades of work for the Civil Rights Movement, today we still have a massive prison industry that enslaves black Americans, schools and neighborhoods are still segregated by race, and various state governments pass laws that prevent black and hispanic folks from voting. Women overwhelmingly work jobs that are underpaid and undervalued, regardless of any "equal pay" legislation.

It doesn't matter that there are laws that say discrimination based on race or gender is illegal, it's still happening. Capitalism is the root of the problem and there will never be any major steps towards fixing inequality and discrimination as long as people have to beg bourgeois politicians for basic human rights. If we keep trying this route, we will continue to see the same kind of "progress" we've had in the last 200 years - empty legislation will be passed and corporations might make empty gestures about how forward thinking they are, but in reality oppressed people of ALL races and ALL genders will still see no real benefit.

However, this doesn't mean that you have to jump right into talking about how Stalin did nothing wrong, etc, when trying to discuss communism and anarchism with your friends. Most people know that corporations are shit, the government (and police) is shit, sweatshops are evil, our military spending is waaay too high, etc. Start from there, do your research and think about ways you can introduce communist ideas by talking to people about their worries and concerns.

2
FkkizeOP•

I am not talking about reformism. With shifting baselines I mean society changing without the people noticing. People react strongly to terms like communism and phrases like ACAB, turning some of them away. Basically your last paragraph. I was just wondering whether there can be more of that stuff. For example it is a stated strategy of some far right parties in europe to make specific calculated provocations, just to play them down afterwards. Thus bringing the discussion into the middle of society. I am not suggesting to publicly claim Stalin did nothing wrong and calling it a joke afterwards. I was just wondering whether you guys had any suggstions for similar methods.

0
simone_beauvoir•

I'm not quite sure I understand what you're asking. Do you mean gradually introducing communist/anarchist ideas to people?

I think this is the best way to introduce communism to friends who are liberals. Keep in mind that people who are less oppressed/exploited (i.e., petty bourgeois types) are going to be very very hard to convince and it's better to put effort into convincing people who are actually exploited - if someone benefits from capitalism, they're going to be biased towards ignoring its problems. Any working class person, regardless of race or gender or political orientation, is going to be aware of the ways that our economy is stacked against them.

If someone is uncomfortable with the idea of trashing police, then discuss issues that relate to them (e.g., being able to afford paying your bills). Why is it that their employer is allowed to take 70% or more of their wages every day as profit?

I don't use the same approach with everyone and the ideas you use to convince a particular person don't need to be strictly communist/anarchist, either. For example, I've been able to convince someone who was kind of racist and very very anti-government about police brutality towards black and hispanic folks, by discussing it as government overreach and using leftist libertarian ideas. If someone is a Bernie supporter, chances are they're already aware of lots of the contradictions in capitalism so you can talk about those and how capitalism is not going to fix them.

Basically just use the person's own reasoning to conclude that capitalism doesn't work (without mentioning communism/anarchism by name).

Also I think leftist folks need more of an online presence as far as spreading propaganda online, right now neo-nazis and fascists have us beat in that area. That's something I've been meaning to start working on...

Does this answer your question?

1