Advice for some painting issues I'm having

Getting back into the hobby after 15 years and never really was a good painter then, so I'm essentially starting fresh. I've been having a few issues recently and would appreciate some advice and tips from you seasoned painters.

  1. I'll often get tiny dots (maybe dried paint?) forming on the tip of my brush. I'm using Winsor & Newton Series 7 brushes and can tell they're much nicer than anything I've used before, so I'm pretty sure it's not the brush that's the problem. These little specks interrupt my detail work though as I'll be painting great with a fine tip on my brush and then these little debris dots form and start getting paint where I don't want it. Could this be from using too much paint on my brush possibly?

  2. This might figure in to my first issue as well, but I'm noticing my paint seems to be drying out pretty damn fast for my expectations. I'm using Citadel paints and I generally take two or three dabs from the pot and put it onto my ceramic dimple palette and then stick my brush tip barely in my water and then mix the water into what's on the palette. I'll start painting with it and before I can even base a single model I'll notice the paint stop flowing from my brush. Looking at the brush it still looks covered in paint, but it's dry to the touch. So I'll dip it back on the palette and continue painting. Sometimes I'll dip my brush in the paint on the palette and stall for like 20 or 30 seconds while I'm figuring out how I want to position myself and by the time I start putting brush to model, it's already dry. I can generally finish out basing a single model (maybe 10 to 15 minutes) and the paint on my ceramic palette is already dry. So I end up going back to the pot and slabbing down another brush or two on to the palette. Am I just taking too long? Do Citadel paints just dry out that fast? When I clean my palette after a painting session it seems like I'm scraping off a bunch of dried, wasted paint. Is that normal?

  3. In a lot of the video tutorials I watch I notice it's usually recommended to do two thin coats of things. In my recent experience, I don't need to do this. I guess it depends on the color, but I've used a few different colors to base different types of models and with the method I described above, I never need a second coat. I've tried doing a second coat just to see if it looks any different/better and it looks the same to me. And I don't think I'm using too much paint because the models don't look gloopy or anything and I can still see all the detail on the model perfectly. Maybe my coats aren't really thin enough. For specific colors, I've been priming with Imperial Primer from a pot (so I don't have to deal with going outside to prime as I don't have a great space) and some of the colors I've based over it have been Leadbelcher, Macragge Blue, Rhinox Hide and Abaddon Black though obviously I probably don't need multiple coats of black on black primer and the metallic Leadbelcher might not need it either. But Rhinox Hide and Macragge Blue?

My end results aren't too bad in my opinion for basic priming, basing, washing and some dry brushing, but I'd like to move on to some more advanced layering and edge highlighting and these things are really getting on my nerves.

Thanks in advance for reading all this and any advice you can give!

Posted Apr 19, 2017, 2:07 AM UTC

312
that_how_it_be•

u/Swooper86 pretty much nailed it already but I'll add my thoughts.

  1. You can use your finger nails to pick that little speck of dried paint off your brush and then usually resume painting again without revisiting the palette. If you lose the brush tip while doing so just careful reform it by touching the side of the bristles above where the paint is and you can nudge them back into a nice tip. I'm in So. California and have this problem frequently; or at least I did.

  2. When using a well palette I can get about 15 minutes of usage out of paint thinned with water to the consistency of skim milk. If I'm using a glaze it will last a bit longer. If I add a drop of drying retarder I can get a lot more life out of it. Retarder comes in two flavors: medium and additive. I prefer the additive because it doesn't change the viscosity or behavior of the paint very much but you have to use very, very little of it. I switched to a wet palette some time ago and because my painting area is otherwise cool and dark I can have paint sit for a few days and still be workable.

  3. Generally speaking if you're getting 100% coverage in a single coat your paint is probably too thick. Blacks, greys, earthy tones, most flesh tones, and darker greens, reds, and blues usually take two thin coats to get a decent coverage without obscuring detail. It's usually bright yellows, reds, and oranges where it starts to take many more layers.

I've had to do a lot of edge highlighting recently and between a wet palette and some Liquitex Drying Retarder (additive) it's been a lot smoother. What I do is put a tiny droplet of retarder on my palette and then add a few drops of my highlight color to it and stir with the back of my brush (and wipe it off with paper towel). Then I put the first one or two millimeters of the brush tip into the paint and on a clean area of the palette brush it around to transfer that paint up a few more mms into the brush; in other words I load the first one or two mms and then diffuse it further into the brush on a clean section of palette. Then I paint a test stroke on a fingernail and if it's coming off too watery (usually the case) I dab it against paper towel to take out some of the excess. Then I test on my fingernail again and when I'm getting a nice clean line of paint I take it to the model for the edge highlights. I can repeat this a handful of times before paint starts to dry in the brush and I have to clean it off in my water and start anew. This is a stark contrast to before I had the additive and paint (thinned or not) would dry out in seconds on my brush.

3
SpringwoodSlasherOP•

Yeah, usually I do pick it off with my finger nails, but it seems to form again pretty quickly so I find myself having to do it often and it interrupts the flow of my painting. I'm hoping the advice I got on thinning out my paint will help with it not happening so often.

Thanks for the advice on the additive as well. I think my current plan is moving to a flat palette (cause I can pick one up today), thinning my paint more, ordering a wet palette and trying that, and then I'll look at messing with the additive.

Right now I definitely don't need multiple coats with the current thickness of my paint, so it does sound like I need to thin it more. It's weird though cause every time I see people talking about their paint being too thick it also goes along with looking bad and details being obscured, but I don't find that happening in my case. I might be thinning it enough so that doesn't happen, but not thin enough to help with the other issues I'm having. So I might be riding that line and just need a tad bit more water mixed in. Gonna give it a try tonight.

Thanks for the detailed breakdown of how you use the additive and find the right consistency. I find a lot of tutorials and videos don't really go into that much detail on it. They just say "add a drop of water" and leave it at that which isn't terribly helpful.

1
rayscarnage•

Don't buy a wet palette... Make one with an old Tupperware, some wax paper and a sponge or just some scottowels. Mine is homemade and it cost less than 1$ ( I used a container from boston pizza that reseals).

the retarder is amazing especially if you want to move to wet blending and glazing and all.

For thinning you can look at some gunk recipe on the net ( usually distilled water (2$ at a drug store for 4L). Some flowaid and a retarder.

2
SpringwoodSlasherOP•

Just looked up some videos and yeah, it seems pretty easy to make a wet palette. I've got some tupperware containers laying around. Will pick up some wax paper and try it with paper towels tonight. Thanks!

Should I still add water to thin the paint on the palette or will the wetness of the palette usually take care of it on its own?

1
rayscarnage•

I still add a few drops of my ''gunk'' to the paint on the wet palet. I just bought around 100 paint dropper bottles on amazon to prethin all my stuff but with a kid and being on the verge of becoming a singledad with full costudy... Let's just say that my time is really short right now. I use student grade acrylic art paint (liquitex basics) and they need a lot of thinning since they are really thick (toothpast thick). For the few pots of citadelle I have I still thin them but way less. You'll have to test for yourself.

2
that_how_it_be•

I have some additional feedback based on your response.

The main advantages to thin paint are:

  • Doesn't obscure details
  • Easy to build transitions up with thin layers
  • Easy to fix a mistake (because it won't be that noticeable or you can wipe it off while it's still wet)

How do you thin acrylics? Well with mediums or with water. Mediums are better a keeping the paint behaving like paint in regards to flow and surface tension, but they can have unintended side effects like glossiness. If you add too much water to paint it will eventually turn into a glaze (which you can also do with mediums) but the main point is too much water completely breaks the surface tension properties of the paint. The point is if you're not making a glaze then there's only so much water you can add to the paint and have it still behave like paint.

If you're already having problems with the paint drying quickly it's likely because the water is evaporating too fast. Adding more water won't necessarily help with that. Why? Because there's an optimal amount of moisture / water you can pack into your brush and have it behave like paint. Adding more water doesn't change that optimal mount you can load the brush with but it does change the amount of pigment that will be present.

So what does this mean for you? It means that without an additive techniques like two brush blending and even feathering will be difficult to achieve because as soon as you lay the paint to the model it's probably already drying around the edges and will leave coffee stains if you try and move it around. Experimenting with additives or pre-wetting the surface of the model might give better results for those techniques; so could adding a humidifier (something I know some people do but that I have not done personally).

You might be able to pull off wet blending because it is usually accomplished with larger quantities of paint and with less dilution so it tends to dry a little slower.

If you've watched any of Ben Komet's painting videos you will see his loaded brush blending and you might achieve some results with that.

What you can do if your paint dries very rapidly, which is what I've done a lot of with good results, is fast layering. Most people complain that layering takes a long time because each layer has to be dry. Well in my climate I can put down a thin layer on a surface and it will be dry in 6 or 8 seconds later; so by alternating between two of three areas on the model (or different models) the layering goes pretty quickly. If you thin the layers down to being a glaze then you can get very nice gradual transitions between colors between 6 to 12 layers, which seems like a lot until you realize they're drying very fast and each successive layer is smaller in surface area.

In regards to a wet palette it's true that you can use paper towel and tupperware to make one. However I prefer the one that I bought specifically as a wet palette because the lid is tight fitting, the container is shallow with a flat bottom (most tupperware is not both of those things, and more importantly it is completely opaque and allows no light into it when closed. I like the sponge that it came with because I'm not then using excessive amounts of paper towels. And I found for hobby paints that parchment paper from the grocery store works better than the palette paper it came with. Parchment paper has a tendency to curl up; I put a small makeup sponge on each corner of mine and it keeps them down. And do not mistake wax paper for parchment paper.

1
SpringwoodSlasherOP•

Thanks for the detailed response. I do think I can use a little more water at least as my paint with the small bit of water I currently add doesn't seem to be anywhere near approaching glaze level. I do have some Citadel glaze pots so that's what I'm familiar with as being "glaze level". I wouldn't call my current paint thick, but I wouldn't call it thin either - I thought it seemed perfect, but I definitely don't need multiple coats of anything so apparently that's still too thick based on what people are saying.

I don't understand what two brush blending or wet blending is and am only vaguely familiar with feathering so I don't have much context for what you're saying about those. I haven't seen Ben Komet's painting videos, but I'll give them a search and see what I can learn.

I haven't really done any advanced layering yet (aside from the standard layers of primer, base, wash and dry) so I'm not really sure how fast layering would work comparatively, but I'll definitely keep it in mind as I start to do more of the advanced layering.

On the wet palette, that is my main concern about the DIY method - the tupperware containers seem pretty deep, though I've seen tutorials of people stacking multiple sponges so the paper part is at the top of the container. I'll probably give the DIY method a go, but I might still pick up a wet palette off Amazon cause they're only like $10 to $15. Not like it's gonna break my bank.

Thanks again!

1
Swooper86•
  1. That's paint drying out on your brush. Not sure what to tell you here, except "keep it wet". Usually I'm dipping into the palette roughly every 5-20 seconds while painting - less when painting details, more when basecoating.

  2. Firstly, you're definitely not thinning your paint enough. If you "barely stick [your] brush tip into water...", you're not using enough water and your paint is too thick.

Secondly, it's normal that a glob of paint on a ceramic palette dries up in 10-15 minutes. You can definitely do something about that, though - using a wet palette is a popular option, drying retarder is another. A wet palette will also help with keeping your paint the right consistency.

  1. This is because you're not thinning your paint adequately.
2
SpringwoodSlasherOP•

Thanks for the great advice. It's weird going off of video tutorials cause it doesn't seem like people mix all that much water into their paint. I'll experiment with adding more water when I do my painting this evening.

The wet palette seems like a good idea. I'm not that happy with my ceramic dimple palette and was thinking about getting a flat palette anyway. It's hard for me to get a good idea of how much paint is there and how thin or thick it is when it's down in a recess like that. I think a flat palette would help me with that.

Thanks again!

2
SpringwoodSlasherOP•

An update for anyone still following -

I didn't get a chance to throw a wet palette together, but I did switch to a flat palette and tried adding more water and it worked wonders. The paint didn't dry out as fast. I only got one little paint speck on the end of my brush in the two hours I painted. The paint wasn't so thin/wet that it was dripping off or anything, but I ended up needing three coats to get perfect coverage. Two was almost perfect, but there were still some spots here and there that needed more. It went so much further on my brush and I didn't waste nearly as much paint as before. I'm definitely happy with the changes I've made.

Thanks again for all the great advice everyone.

2