Report by former WSIB CEO says Auto Insurance is Broken
thestar.com/business/2017/04/18/ontarios-auto...Posted Apr 19, 2017, 12:51 PM UTC
Posted Apr 19, 2017, 12:51 PM UTC
Not seeing a Toronto angle in this story. Provincial law is generally discussed over on r/Ontario
Good findings, and basically summarized here:
While Ontario’s benefits, taking into account both the no-fault and tort portions are, on the whole, fair, they are not being fairly delivered. The main cause is that the system does not promote a timely, conflict-free means of deciding what care is needed and providing it to accident victims. The system allows participants to work at cross purposes to its original goals:
Insurers do not aim to provide care to their customers rather they focus on controlling costs.
Accident victims may seek to maximize their entitlement rather than address their need.
Lawyers working on contingency fees work to boost the value of claims.
Providers are paid on volume of treatments, not results.
The insurance companies have invested too much time, money and effort now in enriching the lives of experts, that they have forgotten to care about there customers. This is due to fraud. Instead of looking at the cost/benefit ratio, they aim to mitigate the fraudulent behaviour, but it's clearly not working based on this report findings.
In terms of having it government owned, we are already seeing governments drop there assets to private companies because they could not manage it efficiently or they need the cash. In the insurance world, companies are already beginning to consolidate to maximize profits and reduce expenses. I believe right now as it is, you cannot "outsource" insurance advisors in Canada due to legislation (though correct me if I'm wrong here)/plus it would be a complete nightmare to try and have someone from overseas understanding the rules, regulations, claims process etc.
The wave of new technology (Lemonade in the USA, and Sonnet in Canada) is changing that model to have customers do everything digitally. In regards to Sonnet, they are owned by Economical insurance. Economical is already in the process of demutualization by the end of 2017 I believe, so what happens is after 2 years it is ripe for the picking. So, I can see either Aviva or Intact taking over its business, unless Economic/Sonnet can be self-sufficient on its own to cover losses.
Fifth, the auto insurance industry is likely to undergo major changes over the next ten years as innovation and competition from non-traditional sources come into the picture. The current regime of heavy regulation and price controls is poorly suited to adapt to the future. More open systems should be explored including changes to allow insurers to introduce new consumer products and to compete more freely on price and service in the marketplace.
Eventually everything will be automated, from your car to the "smart home."
I have some thoughts about the report having worked in the rehab industry for a few years.
This report very accurately identifies many flaws in the no-fault side of our auto insurance system. Blame cannot be just on insurers, cannot be just on lawyers, cannot just be on legislators. Everyone has contributed to this disaster.
We pay some of the highest premiums in the world - but that is old news. They cut our benefits in half, while the premiums continue to go up...but that is also old news.
Despite valid objections to the system we have, I take issue with many of the recommendations. The first is that Marshall wants to model a benefit system similar to WSIB.
I wish to point out now that there are issues on this point with the credibility of the writer. The WSIB, the organization that Mr. Marshall was responsible for before being charged with commissioning this report, is currently the subject of a class action lawsuit that was just certified. The lawsuit alleges at paragraph 8 that WSIB policy makers committed the tort of misfeasance in public office, breached its duty to act in good faith and was negligent. Apparently, over the course of the investigation, the lawyers got production of internal documents from WSIB that outlined a specific course of conduct that was designed to have people give up on their claims due to frustration with the process. They did this by instructing their file reviewers to initially deny and make people fight for their claims.
While none of this has been proved in court, the Court of appeal noted that there is at least some basis in fact for concluding that WSIB acted with malice or bad faith towards its claimants.
Issue 2:
On its face, this seems like a reasonable recommendation. However, for those of us who have worked in the industry, we remember what these centres turned into before they were abolished in the early 2000s. Specific centres, used to be called "designated assessment centres" became known for being plaintiff friendly, or defendant friendly and they because biased, partisan and ultimately, not trustworthy.
I just have a hard time taking any hard policy change recommendations for someone who was responsible for such a dysfunctional and unfair system with WSIB