What's anarchism's stance on clothing?

Is clothing inherently oppressive? Should nudism be encouraged? Obviously, no one has to consent to being a nudist. If there were no laws, how do think we should go about clothing, given that some are radically opposed to public nudity?

Posted Apr 20, 2017, 2:03 AM UTC

322
WarthogRoadkil•

We have a stance on clothing?

25
red_nuts•

I'm ambivalent about clothing. But pockets are damn useful.

13
necrodisiac•

Mandatory nudity or beatings will ensue.

In all honestly people would just do what they want. In practise, the community would decide whether nudity is allowed.

13
Fkkize•

Anarcho-nudism!

5
mazer_rack_em•

Automatically Overwritten - organize your workplace and seize the means of production

13
tpedes•

"Who cares if you're so poor
You can't afford to buy a pair of
Mod-a-go-go stretch elastic pants?
There will come a time when you
Can even take your clothes off when you dance."
--Frank Zappa

Seriously, where and how clothing is made is a problem, but clothes themselves provide protection, make statements, and act as a canvas. Some communities may want everyone to be naked, other communities might revive the Mao suit. I would guess that if you're in one community and visit the other, you would modify your dress during your visit in order not to give offense. Why do otherwise?

6
anarchoasian•

. Some communities may want everyone to be naked, other communities might revive the Mao suit.

Fuck that shit. We are anarchists, we don't support city states even under the guise of "community."

4
tpedes•

Your "we" is community as well, and since you (in the plural) don't support a specific idea, then might not some other plural (they) refuse to support a different one? And all that without a city-state in sight!

1
anarchoasian•

Being nude shouldn't be offensive. Period. Communities don't get to regulate an individual's actions if they don't hurt anyone.

1
tpedes•

So, communities get to regulate others' thinking ("You shouldn't be offended!") but not their actions. Moreover, communities don't get to define themselves in ways that hurt no one if those ways violate what someone else thinks is proper. \s

That's a long way of saying "don't should on me." Nevertheless, I do think that "offense" is a problem in the initial statement, and I agree that naked people shouldn't be offensive. Likewise, I am uncomfortable with being publicly nude, and I have always chosen to remain clothed in places that are clothing-optional without anyone being offended.

So, I definitely would modify my initial, sloppy statement to a much more thoughtful "some communities may prefer" instead of saying that they "may want," which implies a level of coercion I didn't intend. I do think the result would be pretty pedestrian: people visiting nude communities who are uncomfortable with nudity would wear clothing, those normally nude might wear minimal clothing or ask if anyone minded their nudity when visiting clothed communities, and a big mixed range in between.

Oh, and clothes are protection from more than cold. As a veteran of several clothing-optional gatherings, I saw and heard about what can happen when normally covered body parts get exposed to the bright summer sun all day, as well as to the occasional patch of poison ivy.

1
GriimFandango•

Isn't that Minarchism in a sense?

1
kyousaya4life•

I don't know what I'm talking about but I always thought minarchism was like "anarcho"-capitalism with a government just to enforce the NAP or something?

2
tpedes•

Not in any sense I recognize.

1
M0SH-P1tlord•

I like wearing socks.

5
forstudentpower•

Nudists have traveled in anarchist circles for a very long time. The wiki page on Anarcho-naturism has some interesting (and, honestly, hilarious) examples, including 1930s Spain and the CNT!

I've lived in lots of places where for most of the year clothing isn't oppressive, it's downright necessary. There aren't many nudists in northern Maine, for example.

5
hereticscum•

As a swede I agree, you do NOT want to be nude 90% of the year.

3
Robert_Jarman•

Except in the saunas. Wait, that's Finland.

3
midnite-tequila•

S&M gear will be mandatory every second Friday. You can just imagine what the punishment for non-compliance will be...

5
AnarchoHeathen•

Be comfortable?

3
kerne1_pan1c•

Nudism in Canada may end in a frosty death.

3
drh1138•

Clothes are a spook.

1
Atlantisspy•

Social norms. Same reason people don't often run around nude today, despite it being protected in many places as "free speech"

1