I'm curious how much will the BGG rating change when the game is delivered to the masses..
Just found out it's down from 9.0 to 8.9.
Posted Apr 21, 2017, 11:35 AM UTC
Just found out it's down from 9.0 to 8.9.
Posted Apr 21, 2017, 11:35 AM UTC
I don't think that it will drop that much and even if it does it truly doesn't matter. The aesthetic and price of the game bring in a lot of haters, but there is no denying that KD:M has already claimed its place in the history of boards games.
Right now in what many people claim to be the golden age of tabletop gaming we are seeing plenty of new game mechanics and designs. But, none of the other games have done what Kingdom Death has done.
Even if at times the mechanics of the game can feel unbalanced and too much like rng based simulation... the game has taken what makes board games unique from video games and craked it up to 11. The components are insanely high quality and may be expensive, but that is because they can be. The game may require an unreasonable number of play sessions and hours to actually finish a campaign, yet it embraces this. The game is less forgiving than Dark Souls and can make you question if you're actually having fun while watching your hours of character development get ripped away from you... But unlike a video game where you might rage quit and smash a keyboard, the fact that KD:M is a tabletop game allows you to take the horror and build real relationships with the people around you.
People are realizing that tabletop games allow for a much more human form of interaction that video games still cannot achieve and KD:M's success is the result of this. Even if the rating drops over time as people begin to pick apart mechanics and find issues with the game, there is no denying that the game has already become legendary.
Well said!
Doesn't matter, really. You want a real rating? KS1.0 brought in $2mil and change, KS1.5 brought in $12mil and change.
That's the only numerical metric that can be measured without any bias. Close to 20k people think the game and its ancillary content is worth the purchase, no matter how they choose to justify their purchase.
Numerical rankings are always biased and untrustworthy.
Honestly find BGG a worthless site, I sometimes use it to see photos of games that's it... but I also prefer to just watch videos
Yup. Fuckawful site design, and filled with metacritic style circle jerk. Hard pass for me.
From what I recall, in 1.5 there is a new mechanic that allows some experience/skill to pass on from characters through a kind of retirement. It adds a press your luck element as opposed to the current, press until you die. Might mitigate some of the frustration at losing everything from a bad die roll (which will still happen all the time).
I think you are describing Philosophies of Death which comes in the gamblers box.
Honestly if its rating did come down a bit it might have a bit more legitimacy. Ratings higher than 8.6 or so on BGG are automatically a bit suspect.
Obviously we don't want it to drop to 6.5 but anywhere in the 8s is pretty good.
BGG ratings are filled with shills (both for and against), haters, fanboys, those who ignore the descriptions of how the ratings are to be assigned and people who are incapable of analytical criticism.
I take them as seriously as I take the concept of playing a banana survivor.
So we can all have a chuckle however, enjoy the 1 rating comments.
https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/55690/kingdom-death-monster/ratings?rated=1&comment=1&pageid=1&rating=1
I can't hate people who do this, they are far to ridiculous and clownish for that.
Here are the 2s
https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/55690/kingdom-death-monster/ratings?rated=1&pageid=1&rating=2
I must say the big long one in the 2 ratings raises some good points that I do agree with. Though his group is also really bad at the combat in the game, like really bad - I find it amusing that he is complaining about the lack of strategy and meaningful choices where the evidence shows that because of poor strategy/tactics and choices his group was getting decimated. XD
It is your duty now to make a build for a Banana Survivor and have him beat the Watcher alone. Post on youtube so we can watch!
Best 1-Star:
Yeah a game where men and women are statistically, psychologically and sociologically identical - where women can go out and hunt as effectively as men and where intercourse only occurs between two consenting partners under the heading 'intimacy' is so misogynistic that I can't stand it.
I'm not saying the setting as a whole doesn't include some questionable elements, but KD:Monster excludes those. Many people cannot compartmentalize. I blame the Wet Nurse.
The Wet Nurse is still seriously one of my favorite designs. She's disturbing, creepy, and unsettling, and (like every other design in KD) everything in her design has a purpose.
So. ...r/kingdomdeath?
To be fair, most of the against contain themselves within r/boardgames