r/MemeEconomy•
FattM

Alex Jones, and what actually makes a 'number one meme': A discussion

As recently discussed on r/nottheonion, professional... person Alex Jones has described himself as a 'number one meme'.

I believe that we, as an industry, should seek to define this term before it becomes as 'Bestseller' is to the book industry, that being completely meaningless and absolutely everywhere.

Should a 'number one meme' be the meme with the highest trade volume, or the one with the fastest growth? Should it have to keep that title for a period of time? Should it be awarded after a certain volume of trades?

TL;DR: What makes a meme earn the 'number one' title?

Posted Apr 21, 2017, 8:46 PM UTC

26130
wmegenney•

Number one memes are much like music ... they define a period of time. For example

Overly Attached Girlfriend from 2010

the Grumpy Cat meme from 2012

Doge of 2013

Pepe meme from 2016

Memes are a part of a cultural time period and the only fair way to call a meme number one is to also signify the year.

Memes are born and then experience a period of exponential viralness, Peak and then decent.

The greater the peak of popularity, the range and reach of the meme, and the slower the decent are all factors into deciding what is the number one meme.

Memes should be catagorized by year as well since its not fair to say that PEPE is more popular than Grumpy cat today, when in its hay day Grumpy cat could be argued to be more popular than PEPE when one compares peak popularity.

Either way. Number one should be

  • By Year
  • Reach
  • Peak Popularity
  • Rate of decent towards unpopularity
178
djnap•

Doge is approaching 4 years since its peak? Damn, I think I still got some in my portfolio. Any advice?

67
cold_on_the_cob•

https://xkcd.com/286/

Prime selling time is a thing of the past for doge. But since you've already taken the loss, I say don't sell. Hold onto them. Nostalgia is the opiate of the masses, and if you have the patience for the long game, the value will skyrocket again in a few years.

92
xkcd_transcriber•

Image

Mobile

Title: All Your Base

Title-text: The AYB retro-return-date (Zero Wing Zero Hour) should be around AD 2021.

Comic Explanation

Stats: This comic has been referenced 72 times, representing 0.0462% of referenced xkcds.


^xkcd.com ^| ^xkcd sub ^| ^Problems/Bugs? ^| ^Statistics ^| ^Stop Replying ^| ^Delete

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
LeMoos•

Sell and cut your losses. It's only going down from here.

11
OurBladesAreSharpp•

I think Pepe has delivered us into the golden age of memes.

22
TitaniumDragon•

Nah, the golden age of memes was the era of All Your Base and We Are The Space Robots and The Ultimate Showdown (of Ultimate Destiny).

We're in the silver age now.

28
BigFatNo•

Do you mean to tell me the We Are Number One is part of the Silver Age? I've seen people get loaded off that song! Grandayy has his entire fortune off the back of it! And what about the pepes? They stepped outside of regular meme boundaries and into deep, very deep normie territory. They even made the news at one point, that's how far it went. And whether we like it or not, normies make up a huge part of the meme market. They're an important audience group.

All Your Base, O RLY, Ceiling Cat etc were part of a phenomenon in its kids' shoes. It was obscure, laughing stock/creepiness for normies and therefore not really an economic golden age.

This is serious, fleeting, and tricky business, friend. Don't let sentiments and nostaligia guide you from sensible decisions. They will only rob your pockets empty.

10
TrumpertB•

O RLY?

9
kidkordova•

Memes didnt even have the reach they have nowadays

3
DrGrinch•

What about Ate My Balls?

1

The most objective way would be to run an integral on the google trends or KYM graph, and compare it to a standard. The standard should increase steadily over time in proportion to the total number of internet users on earth, so that we can correct for more sparsely populated "old internet".

My vote is for "google", I think the fraction of people googling google has been constant for at least ten years now.

2
jankorinkema•

I think it should be by year because some gain a lot of popularity in a short time and lose it again really quickly. Remember howbowdah girl? Neither do i.

1
Harald122016 Amateur Memer of the Year•

imo the only way a meme can qualify as number one, is if it can chase a superhero on the run.

75

A number 1 meme is not a laughing matter. Upvoted.

25
empw•

'Number One Meme' should be the longest lasting meme that can bring dankness for multiple months.

22
TheDarkCrusader_•

I mean harambe lasted for months even after people hated it. Maybe not the longest lasting meme but a meme that makes someone laugh every time they see it no matter the era.

9
empw•

But it lasted. Harambe was a top meme. Dare I say, maybe even THE Number One Meme.

2
AGodzGamerz•

Pepes?

3
UserNameSnapsInTwo•

Lazy town memes in general seem to pop up time and time again. Good long-term investment.

2

Alex Jones is just trying to steal Robbie Rotten's rightful title. Do not lend any credence to his false claims.

22
3
AchillesDevNASDANQ CEO•

A meme is defined by its spread - a mindvirus if you will (the classic cyberpunk book Snow Crash examines this in-depth, and I think it's a must for any memevestor looking to have a deeper than surface-level knowledge of memes). This is what we try to provide a number for at NASDANQ - the spread and usage of a meme over time, which for very long-lasting memes ebbs and flows, but for most it peaks then declines to some steady-state level. To be a top meme, one would have to have a huge amount of usage that's sustained over time, such that we need a maximum value of spread crossed with the amount of time it's at that level. An AUC of the meme would be useful here.

5
scabbagool•

A good analogy would be that each meme represents a rollercoaster. What's the best part of a rollercoaster? In my subjective opinion, the highest speed is the most exhilarating part. With that in mind, I would say the number one meme is that which has the fastest growth. However, similar to how a rollercoaster can only reach the top speed at a certain point, reaching the high status of number one memehood will be a short-lived experience for the meme. The reward after a large volume of trades will be a continuous process of trading. Yet just like rollercoasters, unless well taken care of or innovated upon, memes will be replaced by the next number one meme.

3
iamrealz•

Hey that's my comment! I like most of the comments already here. There are definitely different ways to measure meme performance, but I can't think of a single one that would put Jones on top.

3
FattMOP•

You're not wrong, thanks for the inspiration your dankness

2
number_one_meme•

"Number one meme" is now a top meme. You are all missing the forest for the trees.

2
TotesMessenger•

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

^(If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)

1
delicious_dioxin•

Integrate popularity over time. Done.

1