What's the logic behind the level expansion mechanic?

Discussion

I just got the upgrade for the first world and it makes that level seem way better, but I'm really confused as to why that mechanic exists at all. Surely it just means that your first impression of each level will be incomplete and underwhelming?

I guess you could say it's to make levels simpler when you first visit them, but it was confusing to explore areas and reach the "end" of platforming challenges without realising they're incomplete.

Posted Apr 22, 2017, 1:30 PM UTC

612
MacAttack2015•

I think for kids playing it gives them the option to get to the end quicker if they don't want to dedicate themselves to the whole experience or are frustrated with a level initially, but yeah. I don't think it is that well-executed either. For me it would make sense if the expansions were broken up piece-wise to give a greater impression of progression. Like in Tribalstack Tropics, the first expansion could have been the area to the right with Shovel Knight, the second Rampo, and the third the giant monument, but instead it is all unlocked at once and can feel confusing and underwhelming at the same time (personally).

7
DoctorHeckle•

I'd be fine with "one big chunk" expansions if they added a more distinct variation on the world's theme that was distinctly segregated from the base level.

I think the best example of this would be how world 2 expanded. The Icymetric Palace is a truly different experience from the rest of the level, and doesn't make the rest of the level feel empty or incomplete without it.

4
ForstrideBig Daddy Funk•

I think their original goal was to make it so people didn't feel too overwhelmed with such a large level at first...Except the un-expanded levels are very large as it is...

I definitely think the mechanic was pointless, and I really hope it doesn't return in future games.

7
DexiroOP•

Yeah the smaller version was still really large and complex, and it was confusing to keep hitting dead ends. If you're going to cut chunks out of a level it should be really obvious where the missing pieces are.

Overall I'm finding the levels and hub world to just be overly large and confusing. Almost like they were worried about making the levels too simple, but simple doesn't mean it's not interesting to explore.

2
davidreding•

My thinking is that it allows players to get familiar with the basics of the world, then they already have a feel for the level when the world is expanded.

3
BlackDeath3•

I may be in the minority, but I appreciated the sense of progression I got from expanding a world. Granted, I always had a ton of pagies so it was always an option pretty much immediately, but I like the idea, even if it's a bit pointless.

3
JohanSkullcrusher•

The idea was there were some Banjo-Kazooie and Banjo-Tooie players who didn't want to 100% the world and just wanted enough to move on to the next zone. If you were a player like that, you could 100% the smaller zone and then move on to the next.

1
thephantompeen•

Marketing gimmick.

1
powerff•

It reminds me of jet force jemini which had the same mechanic. It's level expansion was more of the level expanding because of going with another character though not really expanding because of upgrading the level. I think since yooka provides that nostalgia from the time of big hit games this might be a throw to those games as well

1
Kamitue•

To be honest, Tropics was the only world I ever played without expanding it first. Every other tome i expanded before I even entered the world. So honestly I really don't know what was the point.

I think what this mechanic was added for the people who bounce between the worlds more often or tried to rapidly unlock all the worlds so that the old worlds few unique when they return.

1
AdeonWriter•

Bigger worlds was a Kickstarter stretch goal.

That's the logic.

1
themagicone222•

It's how the game distances itself from being a 100% clone of mario 64/banjo kazooie. While Banjo tooie had interconnected worlds, making it a metroidvania (something I hope to see return), this game allows you to expand worlds.

0