Unsure Why I'm Wrong (Robinson Annulation)

Studying for my exam tomorrow and all was going fine until I got to this question and I can't figure out why my answer's wrong.

http://imgur.com/a/RWcWC

Question 19.47 a, is there something I'm overlooking/misunderstanding? Not that I'd be surprised if I did, just unsure what exactly went wrong.

Posted Apr 23, 2017, 10:07 PM UTC

18
NeedMoreCoffee15•

In your fifth step you protonated the O-, which would not happen in basic solution. What would have a happened is a lone pair from the O- would have come back down to reform the double bond and kicked off the ethoxy group. Also, acidic workup would not have oxidized the ether on the adjacent carbon to a carboxylic acid like you have shown, at least according to my notes from class. Hope I helped a little bit!

3
EssMDeeOP•

I agree that the acid catalyzed hydrolysis of the ester makes no sense in hindsight, would only work with water, that was silly, but as far as protonating the O-, isn't that the usual mechanism of a Robinson annulation? Granted, the OH usually leaves when the second alpha hydrogen is eliminated, but in this case the ester's chain was the better leaving group, so it left instead.

I think you're right, though, as when I do the problem in that way I get the correct answer, my only concern is that I won't recognize something like that on an exam. Is it something as simple as the extra lone pair on the oxygen reforming the double bond and kicking off the ester chain because it's in base? And if that's the case, what does the acid do? Sorry to bombard you with questions, just slightly concerned about the exam. Thank you for your help!

2
NeedMoreCoffee15•

Actually I think it is that simple! I'm by no means an expert, but the general rule I follow is that if the oxygen can reform the double bond and kick something off, it will. I'm actually not sure what purpose the acid serves in this case, except maybe neutralizing the base, so if someone could enlighten us that would be great! Got that ACS exam coming up and all

2
EssMDeeOP•

Either way, thank you for the help, much appreciated! Good luck on your ACS endeavors, I know we're all dreading its approach.

2
liauyuancheng•

One tip is that you check for good leaving groups at this stage. If there is, you reform the C=O bond while kicking out the good leaving group. If there isn't, you then protonate the O- from H-Base and then E1cb occurs where OH- leaves to form a alpha, beta unsaturated carbonyl.

Also, the last compound you drew an enol, which will tautomerise to the ketone. And the ester will not change into carboyxlic acid as there isn't water and it is not under more vigorous conditions.

1
Tungsticacid•

It might be that the dicarbonyl has two acidic alpha protons and you deprotonated the other carbonyl alpha proton which would be less acidic, but I am unsure.

2
EssMDeeOP•

I was just following the generic mechanism for a Michael addition, I think it has something to do with the stability of a 6-membered ring being so favorable that its formation takes priority over removing the second acidic proton. Then again, I am just as unsure as you are.

2
2adn•

u\Tungsticacid is correct. Base will deprotonate the other acidic hydrogen on the malonate, and the reaction will stop there. The pKa of that hydrogen is about 11, so it is by far the most acidic hydrogen in the molecule. I don't see the reaction continuing to form the ring.

2