Dynamite_ShovelsLiverpool•

I remember Carvalho being monitored by clubs like Man United and such a while back, seems like on the face of it this would be a great signing for West Brom and a bit of a coup.

78
Stalin_Fergie_Mao•

Feels like a bullet dodged for the big clubs who were 'in for him'. Was supposed to be the next big thing in the centre of the park lol

22
MamaVahiruaOGC Nice•

Wasn't he deemed "too slow" with the ball? You should always look for stuff like that. We can all find a big central midfielder that dominates in a "smaller" league, but does he have it all for bigger clubs? Where does he pass the ball? How many touches? Body language? Etc.

And hell, just look at this, a defensive midfielder at minute 30 (!?) being 1-0 down. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d3YJUno_-Qo

55
NoOneMakesItOutAliveManchester United•

Wow that is incredible. So lazy.

42
wrythingNewcastle United•

Could have been carrying an injury

3
saint-simon97Sporting Clube de Portugal•

He doesn't need to be fast with the ball, he's basically an anchor that protects all the game behind Adrien and at the same time works as the first player who gets the ball to build our attacks.

Of course a player with his pace is more vulnerable to be caught on the break but he's intelligent and besides a few situations like the one in your video which isn't exactly common as much as some people try to make it so.

He has great vision and has improved his passing width since his first season. He'd be an asset for most sides but I hope he stays with us because there aren't many players like that in our reach we could replace him with.

20
MamaVahiruaOGC Nice•

"He doesn't need to be fast with the ball". Depends on which team you play for. I would say most of the biggest clubs needs a midfielder who doesn't take time with the ball.

13
VerrattiShmurdaParis Saint-Germain•

I saw sporting play against Porto in august and I was really impressed with Carvalho and Semedes. William Carvalho reminded me of Patrick Viera, he moved the ball quickly and passed well as an anchor DM.

just because he wasn't signed by arsenal or Man U doesnt mean he is a poor player. I think he is a very good midfielder who can still improve as well.

7
ForcadoUALGSporting Clube de Portugal•

Well, from someone that has been seeing every game of Carvalho for the past 4 years, he his a great defensive midfielder, fit to play in every league in Europe.

He has the vision, the passing, the energy and positioning needed to be a star in most of the teams playing regular CL football. If you hung yourself to express an evaluation of a player just with one play where he had a slow reaction, then you don't know the player at all. He has been amazing in every season, and being an important part of Portugal's Euro victory.

But hey, he had a bad moment in a game, so let's make an evaluation based on that moment, even if we don't know the player that well.

14
ThromboidAccrington Stanley•

We don't usually have the ball so that won't be a problem

11
dngrsFC Romania•

bet yaya toure is his idol

4
thespaceman01Sporting Clube de Portugal•

Thierry Henry is, that's why he wears the number 14.

6
MCbadboySporting Clube de Portugal•

Loads of rhetorical questions in the first paragraph, why don't you answer them yourself? Unless you're dishing out opinion without knowing what you're talking about

Making definitive judgement of a player's quality based on one 15 second clip, r/soccer at it's best

2
brainiac222Bayern München•

what happened to him?

1
saint-simon97Sporting Clube de Portugal•

Nothing. He's still quality

35
magnusmiguelBenfica•

In most games he has the pace of a snail. Also looks like he doesnt care much about playing well now. When he first appeared in the spotlight, he seemed to be the next big thing. Now i'm sure he wont. Is he a quality player? Sure. But is he worth 25M pounds? not at all. Danilo (porto) and Fejsa (benfica) are better than him, imo.

-4
Om_Nom_ZombieArsenal•

Iirc there were rumors we would have signed him in the summer of 15 if he hadn't gotten an injury in the summer.

2
Blubbey•

He signed a new contract with a ~50m euro release clause a couple of years ago

2
fisherpricemanManchester United•

I don't doubt Tony Pulis spends most of his free time watching big strong defensive midfielders.

63
saint-simon97Sporting Clube de Portugal•

William isn't going to join West Brom like

26
UpperGIbleedSporting Clube de Portugal•

We hope we sell him this summer, we need the money and he needs the challenge

5
saint-simon97Sporting Clube de Portugal•

We need him, unless we get a suitable replacement. I don't think many people understand what he gives to the team before he leaves

6
GongomBenfica•

Bring Elias back again

-1
Rojiblanc0Atlético Madrid•

Was Elias bad in Portugal?

3
CheeseMakerThingWest Bromwich Albion•

Gibson and Carvalho? We surely don't have that much to spend.

11
theenigmacodeLiverpool•

Surely the £100m from Madrid for McAuley will be reinvented into the squad

71
CheeseMakerThingWest Bromwich Albion•

Only £100 million?

11
ryanpcharlton17England•

Sad state of affairs mate. Big teams can just bend you over and steal legends for peanuts.

17
GOATOwensArsenal•

If West Brom get Carvalho it'll be great steal like when Southampton got Wanyama from Celtic.

Also your team is on the top half of the table, now's the time to spend and push for a FA Cup or League cup win to get into Europe.

11
CheeseMakerThingWest Bromwich Albion•

I want us to kick on, it's just that I don't get how we have over £40 million to spend on two players. Not to mention the other money we need to bolster the problem areas. If we get Carvalho I'd be ecstatic.

8
rollsreus1990•

it's just that I don't get how we have over £40 million to spend on two players

TV money, Berahino money?

1
theburrow11•

Lol, West Brom will never make it into Europe. Be real.

-21
CheeseMakerThingWest Bromwich Albion•

In the last decade, Leicester, Southampton and Wigan have played in Europe and League 1. Even the likes of Birmingham City, Stoke and West Ham who we've won more trophies and spent more time in the top flight than have played in Europe.

19
theburrow11•

A Tony Pulis side won't make top 7 and won't win a cup. 2011 was the closest he'll get.

1
ConcreteJoeMK Dons•

I mean, they could do it via the cup, but I do agree with you. The top six all have better squads with more money to spend, and if any club is breaking that top six, I sense it being Everton. Plus, a lot of West Brom's better players don't have age on their side.

5
Darko_A_S_MBosnia-Herzegovina•

7 are getting into Europe this season, could be the same next season too

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
t44sMiddlesbrough•

No offence, but I'd be very unhappy to see Gibson join a club like West Brom. I could understand him wanting to join, say, Chelsea...but if he leaves for a mid-table PL club rather than staying here for one more season in a bid to win promotion at the first attempt, then I'd be gutted.

Downside of us going down this season is that Gibson's valuation will drop. Some of the newspapers had him at £35m during the January window. I can see us flogging him for £15m this summer :(

4
HHHRomaDevil•

Even in January I don't think anyone's paying anywhere near 35m for Ben Gibson

8
CheeseMakerThingWest Bromwich Albion•

No offence taken, same thing happened to us with Gera and Greening, and even the likes of Billy Jones and Peter Odemwingie pushing moves to worse teams. I know the feeling. It just says in the article that he's a target.

1
ThromboidAccrington Stanley•

Have you not seen how much Lai is worth? He's got money coming out of cockhole

1
CheeseMakerThingWest Bromwich Albion•

I know, over £4 billion. That doesn't mean that he is going to bankroll us, I was under the impression he wanted slow progress. Plus we have FFP restrictions to adhere to.

1
levifreshPeterborough United•

Pulis has always been clever in the transfer market. He's really great at picking up good players who aren't quite good enough for their clubs anymore and making marquee signings like this to enhance squad depth.

5
yeksnylLeeds United•

I was more impressed by the Danilo chap at Porto on the rare occasions I've seen him

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
thespaceman01Sporting Clube de Portugal•

Just as A Bola links him with Juve and City

He will 90% leave this summer and his change of agent is an indicative of that. He won the Euro as a starter and is playing pretty well lately, was our MoTM in the game against Benfica along with Coates IMO. Created 2/3 chances for Gelson to get an assist, too bad Gelson's last decision is still lackluster.

4
sillysauagesWest Bromwich Albion•

shame we didn't get him before, would be a great signing but i feel that will push Yacob further down the pecking line, maybe a swap deal could be on the cards.

3
ThromboidAccrington Stanley•

No

We're not fucking losing Yacob for anyone

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
t44sMiddlesbrough•

Great signing if they get him. Weren't Arsenal linked with him for a year or two?

1
MalevolentAmmoManchester City•

Recently signed with Guadiola's brother as his agent. He's been linked with a handful of clubs.

1
ZachMichManchester United•

We were linked with him as well

1
casuallywillStoke City•

Tony Pulis and lots of money is not a good combination

1
PapaLazarowlSheffield Wednesday•

Not if you're Simon Jordan

1