No matter what I do, Reds Mystery Part IV is stuck at 1 out of 2 wins vs Reds on All-Star.

I've probably beaten the Reds six times now. DD, Single Player, Play vs CPU. My first win counted, none after that are counting. I played on All-Star, tried Rookie, tried playing them in Conquest. Has this happened to anyone else? I'd really like All-Star Griffey to help with All-Star homers for the Conquest missions.