Pathological_RJArkham Horror LCG•

This is still my favorite review of KDM

I've heard great things about this new hamburger restaurant in town. Not a lot of people have gone to it yet, since it's very expensive and hard to get a seat, but everyone who has gone says it's unusually good. The big day arrives and I finally get a place in line to order. When I place my order for a hamburger and fries, the employee informs me I can't technically order a hamburger and fries, however, if the person next in line is willing to order a double order, I could have half of his order and I would just pay him part of the money. Seems a bit odd to me, but whatever, I'm willing to experience it the way it was intended. However, at this point, another employee emerges and starts arguing with the first one, explaining that yes, since this is a Friday, I am allowed to order a hamburger and fries but only if I use the special Deluxe menu that was located in a different room. I ask the staff why they didn't just put the two menus in the same room and I'm met with quizzical looks and insistence that it's much better this way because it appears more "grand". Eventually, my order is placed. The staff appears to be taking a very long time to get everything ready, but the food does arrive. And indeed, everything looks stunning. I dive in and start eating. For the most part it seems to be a typical hamburger and fries, but the fries are much too big to fit in their container and tend to spill out all over the table. The hamburger also comes with five parts to its bun, instead of the usual two. There's some meat in there that's actually very tasty, but it's hard to get to because of the massive (albeit, impressive) bun. In particular, there's one bite of the hamburger that tastes remarkably, impressively good. I believe it's that part of the burger where the special sauce and pickle intersected in just the right way. Unfortunately, that moment passes quickly, and I continue on with the rest of the meal. I'm eating and eating, but the fries are just so huge I finally get tired of eating them and give up. Curiously, even though I've apparently eaten a lot, it doesn't feel like I'm getting very full and start to wonder if I missed some of the food inside the elaborate containers. Eventually, I conclude that I haven't and give up. Finally I'm ready to go and need to clear my tray and garbage. I head over to the garbage can, which is absolutely overflowing with trash. I ask the staff why don't they empty their garbage. They tell me they can't empty it today because it is indeed a Friday and the garbage is emptied twice on a Monday, but not at all on any other day of the week. However, they helpfully suggest I cram all the garbage into my pockets and carry it home with me, because that's what most of their customers do. I leave the restaurant, intrigued, but confused. I take one final look back over my shoulder, admiring the glistening facade and gorgeous signage suggesting wonders within. I head back to my car, but remember I had to park it two lots over because the lot at the restaurant only had enough space for 3.5 cars. I often think about returning in the future, but decide I'd probably be better off just going somewhere that feels less like work. And that's what playing Kingdom Death: Monster feels like to me. Glic2003

7
Snugrilla•

Hah! That was mine; thanks for posting it.

6
Pathological_RJArkham Horror LCG•

It's genius, found it in the ratings section on BGG. Gave me a good laugh!

3
RatherEatBaconEldritch Horror•

Uh, I read this and thought it was what OP was referring to.

So queue up the very confused look on my face when below they talk about feminism, and I'm thinking, "I only recall hamburgers and trash . . ."

2
takeicOPKingdom Death Monster•

Definitely not a game for everyone!

1
Pathological_RJArkham Horror LCG•

Definitely not, which is fine! I backed the 1.5 KS, and am looking forward to getting it, just found this review when I was looking at BGG ratings and found it hilarious.

2
panwuan•

Sadly as those who the author mentions while addressing the women empowerment or lack off, most wont take the time to read it fully. Its such an archivemnt for boardgames that has such haters its appalling.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

-11
UwasaWaya•

No need for that, now.

5
philequalMOD•

Removed. Please be civil.

2
TomPalmer1979Zombicide•

I hardly think that was uncivil, it was a simple question. Was not meant to be dickish, but I can see how it'd be read that way. But hey, you're the mod. Your decision.

-3
tgcleric•

Woah... that part on the feminism of the game was something else. Not even saying I agree or disagree fully on it... just that...

ya. That was a weird read.

1†
Bierzgal"Once a cylon, always a cylon."•

Yeah, I think so too. I'm actually a bit scared if I should comment on this review in full honesty (Delicate topic on the Internet? Count me out). The reviewer seems to be very sensitive when it comes to her gender. Some of the points seemed forced and/or unnecessary in this review. I also disliked how she was a bit spiteful when she adressed something she disagrees with.

6
CrimsonPlato•

I think people get sick of games being targetted for moral inquisitions - it puts you on the defensive quite often and you can get to the point where you're too ready to jump into an argument over a small comment on the internet, for sure. Over at r/kingdomdeath we've had a number of threads about how some members are far too serious and defensive when discussing the game - and it's because they're used to feeling attacked over it, which is actually pretty sad. People shouldn't feel a need to be defensive over a game imo.

Especially since KDM cops it a lot for non-game elements I think lots of KDM fans get a bit tired of rebutting people who don't understand what is and isn't a part of the game. It's really a "if you're going to rag on the game at least research it enough to do so" kind of thing.

Plus there are plenty of fans who don't buy the sexualised pinups - and in fact plan to re-sell them if they get them as bonuses in the KS.

4
flyliceplickFeminine board games.•

Misogyny: A Mistaken Belief Held by the Ignorant.

If you do feel a need to respond, keep it respectful and avoid escalating thank you.

2
CrimsonPlato•

Sounds a bit defensive, doesn't it?

2
tgcleric•

Games are far from the first or latest to be "targeted" for moral inquisitions. Movies, books, art of any sort is going to a target for differing opinions, and will often be a lightning rod for controversy.

But, the certain members gaming group (obviously a vocal minority) respond so defensively, childishly, and ignorantly. Which is disappointing cause I grew up wanting games to be treated as art. And in doing so, you have to be open to criticism.

I mean, hip-hop albums are still targeted at every release. Just this year Passengers was blasted (rightfully) for its romantic marketing of what was problematic story.

Ultimately, I wish people would respond with the less defensive and more mature "ya, it may be problematic, but I enjoy it, and am aware of it". That's OKAY!

I love eminem. Some of his stuff (well... all of it in some way) is brilliant. And gives you insight into a twisted mind that is about as far away from my own as possible. But some of it is just gross misogynist. Okay. I can enjoy it and still accept it. I can say I love Taken even with its racism and out-dated Briar Rose fear of your daughter losing their virginity? Why, cause the movie kicks ass. I'm aware of this issues, but can still enjoy it.

I can love Conan the Boardgame and acknowledge its essentially a male power fantasy. Well, I'm a guy. And sometimes I want to indulge in that. But in doing so, I don't have to pretend its not a bit sexist.

I think people who are defensive about this stuff, would actually find most people are, even "crusaders" are incredibly understanding about this and just want the problematic elements to be acknowledged.

I can think a mcdonalds Big Mac is unhealthy and a big pile of immoral corporate grey meat... but still enjoy it..

1
CrimsonPlato•

Do you consider sexism to be harmful to women?

1
tgcleric•

I know those people well. They act "polite" and "intellectual" but are actually acting neither. It was passive aggressive to the point of aggressive and had no support or reason beyond that 3 women think so.

Anyways. In terms of the review of the game, I am excited to get my copy.

1
CrimsonPlato•

This is probably one of the greatest write-ups I've seen for KDM. It really does capture the pros and cons (primarily: random rocks falling), while discussing some of the more misleading complaints about the game. It's important because while I of course want people to experience the game - I don't want people to jump on board without knowing about the game's weaknesses. It's a lot of money to waste if you can't stand a bit of randomness, for example.

One thing I'd add to the "Mysogyny or lack thereof" section is that also, the number of badass women you may stumble upon (depending on randomness/expansions) is pretty high. You're far more likely to come across a badass woman wearing full armour than a similar man, from my experience. The gender equality in fighting strength/prowess isn't just gameplay - it's a tangible part of the lore. The women in KDM are badass as fuck.

1
BelaKunnZpocalypse•

I feel bad for the people who jumped on the hype train for the Twin Satan level dropping over a grand and then hates randomness. That's where the cult of the new will bite you. My girlfriend was commenting about how she's never seen me do so much research and get so interested and invested in a game before. She also told me how much she disliked the pinups. The male pinups did not make it better to her. Female being equal in the game is a positive to me.

1
CrimsonPlato•

Oh yeah - I totally expect some serious complaints when everything gets delivered. Not a good game to buy on a whim at all.

1
WeaverAishiteruze•

Great write-up. Although I don't think the rocks falling is such a bad thing. Something I love in KD:M, which I don't love in other "punishing" games, is you'll do badly and just have to keep going; hey, might even swing around.

The feminism is a good point. I understand that a lot of people don't like nudity, but not everyone thinks its bad, or associates it with being hindering to feminism. The majority of KD:M fans are also for gender equality. They're just not for censorship. (At least, that's my POV.)

1
CrimsonPlato•

I personally dislike the rocks falling from a "wasted opportunity" kind of POV. As the review says, the standout for the game is the combat and the monsters, and so while I might not mind a survivor dying randomly, I'd much prefer it to be during an intense combat.

During the Hunt is imo the worst because not only does it lead to an unsatisfying death, you also lose a player during the combat. Settlement events can be fine to die in (as long as you don't get repeat Plagues or anything) because at least no-one has to sit out of the showdown, etc.

1
defdragoKingdom Death: Monster•

I actually agree with this. I don't mind the one shot kills or the ground opening up walking back into town. We ignored quite a few hunt phase deaths just to be able to keep going and not restart our settlement

1
flyliceplickFeminine board games.•

Kingdom Death is an important moment in the history of board gaming and to try and claim otherwise is only going to result in you looking either ignorant, foolish or both.

'Article' written by anonymous coward crashes, burns.

-9
koreanpenguinConcordia•

I imagine this game will be remembered for the huge amount of money it raised on Kickstarter, and the obscene miniatures, not the "significance of its theme".

6
takeicOPKingdom Death Monster•

What do you mean?

2