Eitrigg and his most recent appearance in Legion
Being one of my favourite Warcraft characters and my favourite orc by far, I couldn't dismiss his appearance in Legion. So far it seems really disappointing.
First of all, why does Eitrigg of all warriors is chosen to be among Valarjar? He hasn't participated in any significant battles since Argent Crusade's campaign in Northrend. While he led the assault on Blackrock orcs during Cataclysm, he didn't fight in person. He always showed himself more as a tactitian and advisor rather than flat-out warrior he is shown to be. Surely, there would be far more appealing combatants among Horde warriors to be considered "worthy" by Odyn.
Secondly, imagine this for a moment. Rename Eitrigg in warrior campaign to Another Orc Warrior. Now, would you be able to tell it's actually Eitrigg? No.
His best friend and blood brother died on Broken Shore. He doesn't even mention Tirion in any of his dialogues. He doesn't display any of Eitrigg's cautiousness, instead rushing in battle screaming "My axes thirst for blood". Besides he also appears to other players as "Warsong Warrior" leading me to believe that other NPC was supposed to be in his place.
All in all Eitrigg's appearance only gives me following thoughts. Blizzard realized how much they failed with Warrior's class hall and champions being only vrukyl (or iron dwarf), so they attempted to fix that by shoving a famous figure into their roster without any explanation whatsoever.
I really hope none of the class campaigns are canon, because if I read in the next novel how Eitrigg spent time among vrykul, I will definitely do something dire to my copy of "Of Blood and Honor".
EDIT: Marked as spoiler, in case some are still doing these quests.
Posted Apr 27, 2017, 1:50 PM UTC · edited
As a tactician, I can see how he'd still be a valuable asset to the Valarjar. Though I do agree with this personality change, I don't think the dialogue writers know who Eitrigg is.
Personality change is supposed to have some ground behind it, especially when it's this polar. Eitrigg here acts completely out of character. I would understand if, for example, somewhere during the questline he would explain to us that news of Tirion's death struck him deeply and he came to Broken Isles determined to drag as many demons as he can back to Twisting Nether.
But nope, he just suddenly lost his cool and became bloodthirsty for no apparent reason. Not to mention his unexplained connection to Skyhold since he never appeared there before.
Agreed. We've always complained that Blizzard doesn't involve enough fan favorite characters in the WoW story, but sometimes they seem to shoe-horn them in without enough lead-up as compensation now.