Origin 315P or Cutlass Black :/

SOCIAL

So i'm torn between upgrading my 315P to a cutlass black or staying with the 315. I do have a dragonfly and the new cutlass can fit 1 in the back maybe 2?? So I dunnos what to do, help me guys what would you do and why?

Edit: You people love the cutlass black, but you guys aint swaying me atm

Posted Apr 27, 2017, 4:47 PM UTC · edited

962
dirkhardslab•

If the price isn't an issue the Cutlass would be an upgrade in every way.

19
TheLucarian315p & Cutlass Black•

Pretty much this, except style and speed of course ;)

5
dirkhardslab•

I would argue on which has better style good sir.

4
ViperT24Freelancer•

Wait until the 300 series rework before you make that call ;-)

6
TheLucarian315p & Cutlass Black•

So say we all.

5
youRFateVice Admiral•

Wait until the cutlass black is reworked...

5
TheJudge1979new user/low karma•

315P is more for exploration (little cargo). Cutlass Black has changed quite a bit and can be used for salvage, assault, multi-crew, etc. Right now the Cutlass black has more versatility but wont come with a dedicated exploration kit like the 315.

3
AtamissPirate•

I love the 315p!!!

Get the Cutlass... not even love can save the 315p from itself.

3
Mikeko28•

Genuinely lol'd

2
Star_PilgrimSpace Marshal •

Cutlass Black is the best bang for the buck you could ever get in SC to date.

2†
crimson_stallion•

One of the best value.

You could make a pretty big argument for the Avenger Stalker, Constellation Taurus and Freelancer DUR too.

1
Star_PilgrimSpace Marshal •

Remains to be seen.

The only best value in my eyes is Cutlass.

It has hell of a lot going for it for the price.

1
crimson_stallion•

How is the Cutlass Black better value then a Freelancer DUR though?

 

The Freelancer costs only about $25 more, and for that it offers a an arguably superior weapon loading (4x turreted S3s, vs Cutlass which can only take S2 guns if gimbaled), better max shielding (S5 vs S4), a better max powerplant size (S5 vs S4), a larger cargo hold (52 SCU vs 33 SCU), larger max engine size (S5 vs S4), and superior sensors. That's a hell of a lot of extra kit for $25. The only advantage I can see in the Cutlass Black is superior mobility and a tractor beam. The Cutlass Blue and Red have some advantages, but they also cost more.

 

Likewise, a Constellation Taurus is $50 more than a Cutlass and for that price gives you an 8x larger cargo area, superior weapon hardpoints (4x S5), superior quantum fuel range, stronger shields, stronger hull, superior shields, superior powerplant, and a cargo door big enough to hold an URSA with ease (maybe even two). Again, that's a lot for $50.

 

The Avenger can't touch the Cutlass on durability or firepower, but it's it offers most the Cutlass' functionality (prisoner cells, decent sized cargo hold, bed, etc) for 70% of the price - and that's assuming the Black doesn't increase in price once the update pass is complete...which all signs suggest it will. If you want to fly exclusively solo, then the Avenger is an amazing value ship.

 

Not saying these ships are BETTER value then the Cutlass Black, but they're right up there. Especially the Taurus and the DUR.

1
Star_PilgrimSpace Marshal •

Cutlass, for its money as a more rounded experience overall.

You can do some cargo, and fight to steal said cargo.

You can't do that in DUR, no matter what you try.

Cutlass has a nice balance between offensive capabilities and able to perform other tasks.

1
Seppieenew user/low karma•

Maybe the 300 rework (if confirmed) can make things more clear about the series. And if it's worth changing for a Cutlass. So it might be useful to wait a couple of weeks until more information is released. But then again, it can also be longer than months before CIG is releasing any info about that.. personally I have a Cutlass because I like the versatility and (multi-crew) size.

1
_myst•

300 series rework has been confirmed multiple times.

2
StuffMcStuffington•

Has there been mention of a possible 300 rework? Seriously that series is more than a bit lack luster at this point.

1
_myst•

This has been on CIG's radar for ages now. The 300 series is the oldest model in the game right now, they've confirmed they're gong to update it. People are a bit flustered because it's not currently on the Production Schedule, but we just had a CIG representative tell is it's still on.

3
SadSorbet•

if you want to transport cargo people or attack larger ships the cutlass is a good call

If you're planning to solo play, explore, scan etc the 315p is the better call

really the only thing to decide what ship you want is the vague descriptions of their role in universe... as everything is subject to change even those - the 315p and the rest of the 300 line up will likely change a lot when they eventually get a rework and we dont know how the cutlass is going to pan out from its rework properly.... the 315p might be able to haul a dragonfly after the rework and that would make the main reason to upgrade to a cutlass obsolete if you're after exploring.

personally im expecting the cutlass to be a much less agile medium ship hunter that'll need fighter escorts to protect itself effectively from light fighters... but we'll see.

1
CASchoepsFreelancer•

I love the Cutlass, but the 300 series is a nice thing too, especially if they one day get reworked to the state the 85X is right now. Due to this I have both at the moment. The Cutlass to earn money (as a hauler with teeth or gunship/pirate vessel, I haven't decided yet) and the 315p to have fun and explore when I feel like it.

If you have the money I recommend getting a Cutlass temporarily to try it. This should give you some impression whether the ship is for you or not.

Unless you absolutely say "no" to the Cutlass then melt the Cutlass and rebuy the 315p (if it is a standalone - careful with melting packages). Then buy a $10 Gladius to Cutlass upgrade (or two). This ensures that you can try the reworked Cutlass for $100 even if the price rises by upgrading or buying a Gladius and upgrading it. Thus you have all your options open and do not have to pay more for the reworked ship.

If you need credits in the meantime you can always melt the upgrades, they don't lose their value after all.

1
CaptainTwoBinesRear Admiral•

Cutlass Black, especially since it's likely to rise in price soon due to the rework for 3.0, get it now and you'll essentially earn free melting credit for a potential later date.

Edit: Earn free CCU value as opposed to melting credit.

1
retroretinaHigh Admiral•

What do you think you'll lose out on if you upgrade the 315? Seems like you'll end up with much more versatility by grabbing grabbing the black.

0
SilkyZCommander•

Do it if you want the Cutlass and plan on doing anything else other then looking pretty while exploring.

0
Sohrab_Jamshid•

Since you have the dragonfly, I'd say go with the Cutlass so you can bring it with you. We don't know much about changing loadouts from combat to exploration, but I think it's probably safe to assume that the Cutlass will be able to do some exploration. The Red is supposed to have a better sensor suite than the black for search and rescue, so maybe go with the Red?

0
Pattern_Is_MovementColonel•

Cutlass will have bigger running costs, but not much more. Partly because you really should have a player or NPC crew with you. In practice I think the Cutlass will be a fantastic do everything ship. A daily ship that you can afford to fly around and let the situation guide you. The Cutlass in theory should be able to be kitted out for exploration and anything else you can think of.

0
Bonus_Bang•

Wait 30 days, then get a 600 series concept.

0
CheekypilotAggressor•

I am very biased against Origin...mostly because I really dislike the 300 series. Just doesn't do it for me. I also really dig the Cutlass looks and design, especially the new rework art!

All that said, I think that if I could only have 1 ship, it would be the Cutlass. I currently have an ever-shifting mess of ships, but the Cutlass is almost always part of that mess!

0
FriendCalledFiveExplorer•

If you want to do exploration like the 315p and be able to carry the DF then a Freelancer DUR might be a better option.

0
SirDingleberries•

If you don't mind waiting a while longer, wait out the 300 series rework. The current state of that line of ships is poor to say the least, so it's pretty hard to judge how they'll compare to other ships post-rework.

0
mrpanicyColonel•

If you have the money the Black offers you more versatility.

I don't care for it, as the Drake ships really aren't my style, but it is looking to be a pretty versatile ship.

0
EboKnightExplorer•

I was in the same situation (DUR/315/dragonfly pack) and opted to upgrade the 315 to a Cutlass Black. My understanding is that the Cutlass will be losing some agility and will not play well against fighters, the 315 is supposed to be moderate at 1v1 fighting. I wasn't super impressed with it, I also don't do a ton of PVP.

If you're in the same situation, you could always upgrade to the Cutlass then upgrade the DUR to something that can fight better. $0 swap to a hornet/350r. I just all around like the Cutlass more than the Freelancer at the moment. And exploration is so far off, I'll probably swap my fleet around a bit when Jump points are a thing. I'm leaning towards getting do a small DUR upgrade to the MAX (for extra cargo running) or prospector (since mining will be available next after 3.0 and it would open up another career path).

0
CondingsOPFreelancer•

I'm liking what your saying ill be taking this into consideration

1
poorsquinkyFreelancer•

If I was replacing a 315P I would choose a Freelancer DUR over a Cutlass Black because the DUR is another exploration ship. It also has more cargo space and bigger guns (fewer though, but big == fun for me).

If the choice is simply between the 315P and the Cutlass, I'd choose the Cutlass because you're going to have an actually useful ship sooner (the 300 series rework will MAYBE start around the end of 2017), and there's more room for cargo and to take friends around.

I think it depends on what you're after and when you want it.

0
CondingsOPFreelancer•

I think it depends on what you're after and when you want it.

pretty much this (and there's more room for cargo and to take friends around.)

And I might just do what you said and get the freelancer for the extra cargo space / multicrew and the room to fir the dragonfly BUT I do love my 315.

2
poorsquinkyFreelancer•

I love mine too. And I know I'll be kicking myself for getting rid of it once the rework finally lands.

1
Oneros_Armakat•

I would go for the Black, and never look Back ^^.

0