Anyone have suggestions for lumbar/SI joint pain?

I'll try to keep this short. Army Vet, herniated discs L3-S1, with spinal stenosis and osteoarthritis in the same area. Docs call this the trifecta. The spinal canal that houses the nerves is being encroached on. In addition, my hips never went back to their original position after I had kids, so they're not in place, and are often shifted.

So far I have tried: 8 rounds of PT, chiro (which made it worse), acupuncture, dry needling, traction, torodol shots, cortisone shots, yoga, pilates, lumbar and hip support belts, a TENS unit, and of course the normal courses of steroids, NSAIDs, nerve blocking meds (gabapentin), and narcotics. Nothing helps. Even the narcotics don't touch the pain anymore, as I've been on and off them the last 13 years. On a daily basis, my pain is an 8. A good day is a 5, and a bad day I can't get out of bed.

I get care from the VA, so I am weary of letting them perform surgery, especially since they can't decide on a diagnosis or root of the pain. They tell me it could be one of many things causing the specific pain I feel.

I want to try RFA, but they're not sure that will help at this point. What can I try next? A block? I'm only 32 and I have young kids. I don't want to chance surgery if there is something less invasive I could try first. But, I know I'm only a few years away from disability if I can't find a way to relieve the pain.

Someone please give me suggestions. Google is not helping.

Posted Apr 27, 2017, 6:31 PM UTC

414
Bystry_Kozak•

Spinal Cord Stimulator may be an option. May want to google it to see if it is something you are interested in. You can do a trial before committing. Not sure you are a candidate but should ask your Doctor

3
PissedOffVetLadyOP•

That looks interesting, especially since I used to get relief from the TENS unit. Its still more invasive than I'd like, but def worth asking about.

I had a private neurosurgeon want to do a microdiscectomy, but I was only 29 at that point, and didn't have any help for those 6-8 weeks that I would have expected to be off my feet, so on.

I have a VA appt coming up, so I will talk to my doc about this. Thanks so much!

2
Old-Goat•

Trifecta is right. With osteo there are usually issues with the quality of the bones and they don't hold screws very well so even fusion which is probably an eventuality should be approached cautiously. A surgical intervention with microdiscectomy that might help, I'd maybe consider that while it might be helpful, rather than wait on further deterioration. You might at least buy yourself a pain lessened period. Pain free is always too much to ask for. We use or backs for too much stuff. They can medicate you in to a stupor to relieve your pain but that's no quality of life.

Is your pain mostly in the back or is it you SI/hip area? Did any of the treatments help at all? My SI joints are slightly arthritic and they had one hell of a time getting close with a block. They got "close as they could" with lousy results. Well not lousy, but it definitely went in to the waste of time category. They have so many different types of injections, each spot is a specific kind of block as is each approach they take towards the target, but the juice they use is pretty much the same stuff, a steroid anti inflammatory, maybe with a bit of local anesthetic mixed in for flavor. Sometimes they may even throw in a dash of muscle relaxant. If you're gonna try more injections maybe they should mix up the ingredients a bit and see if the results improve. They are beginning to use some different ideas in their injections, like PRP (platelet rich plasma) and stem cells but all that is still considered "experimental" and its not cheap but they are options. I just don't know if they will be useful to you, so I'm going to let your own research guide you and see if anything grabs you as an alternative. My doc wasn't specific or I don't recall which type of arthritis PRP was helpful with but he's getting good results. They are also doing some treatments with low level lasers but I'm not real familiar with it. Doubt the VA is up on any of this cutting edge stuff, but you never know. I am sure its all outrageously expensive so you may want to check out the Clinicaltrials.gov website and see if someone is doing this kind of work in your area.

Above all of this don't neglect your mind while you search for an answer to the problems of your body. Stress and depression are so common with difficult pain, they almost always join the party. They feed off each other, pain makes the stress and depression deeper and depression and anxiety crank up the pain a level or 2. You have to treat both aspects of pain. The mental part can sneak up on you, so try to keep it in mind. Good luck, I hope you get some answers soon.

1
PissedOffVetLadyOP•

All wonderful points. I'm actually bipolar, so I have to work extra hard to keep in good spirits, or else its not a fun day for anyone involved.

Its mostly lower back, like 4-6 fingers above the butt crack. The hip and SI joints are just too flexible, so sometimes I feel like a barbie doll when you pop their legs out of socket. I actually have almost done that. My PT said that is why I'm always in so much pain and I'm always so tight, because my muscles are fighting so hard to keep my bones in place. Muscle relaxants are no bueno for me for this exact reason. If I take them, the muscles relax, and my bones do whatever the hell they want.

I'd probably be down for the micro IF it wasn't the VA doing it. I have to see my doc, and I'm going to discuss my options, but it is so difficult to get anything done. You see primary, which takes months (Made the appt in Feb, get to see him in mid-June), and they're just a generalist. So then they put in the referral, which takes a month +, someone calls you, set an appt for 4+ months out, 2 hour drive for consultation, another 4 months for follow up...see where I'm going??

These are good talking points tho to see if they're messing with any of this. Thanks so much!

1
fitzbar•

Sorry about the bipolar. I have and had MDD (major depressive disorder) way before my back problems so it's really hard to motivate myself to stop lying down all the time, because that's not obviously not good for the physical situation I'm in right now. (I also believe my years of staying in bed and "checking out" are a contributing factor to the pain I'm in now)

1
PissedOffVetLadyOP•

I know that feeling. I binge watch a lot of Netflix. It's hard for me to get motivated. The pain wakes me up at night, which makes me exhausted during the day, so doing the things I have to do is impossible, forget what I'd like to do.

2
BionicWoahMan•

I'm so sorry :(. I don't really have any advice but I just wanted to let you know that you aren't alone. I have similar conditions and I've had the surgeries . I definitely understand that you want to feel comfortable with the surgeon . My dad is a vet and has had multiple surgeries . He's disabled though so I guess he may have Medicaid . We all had champva growing up . He got a choice somewhat where he insisted that a neurosurgeon assist in the surgery . Do they give you any leeway on asking for outside consultations or assistance ?

1
neoqrtx•

I've had mixed results with RFA. I had my first one around 2002 and it basically cured my low/mid back pain permanently, and gave me a couple years of significantly reduced SI pain. A couple years later the SI pain came back, but 2-3 repeat RFA's over ~10 years only gave middling help until the one i had in 2014 or 2015, which helped again tremendously. Recently the pain seems to be increasing again, or I've had a temporary flare up at least. If it continues I'll definitely try another one.

1
neoqrtx•

Addendum: I've never got a firm diagnosis either (other than just nerve damage), but don't let that stop you. And physical therapy is worse than useless, swimming has helped me though.

1
uffdagalEDS3•

RFA can definitely help. Any way to see doc outside VA? You need good Orthopedic Spine Surgeon or Neurosurgeon.

1
PissedOffVetLadyOP•

Yea, I could probably finagle something, but if the VA doc won't put in the consult, I'm SOL. I don't have insurance other than the VA right now, so I'd have to wait.

1
Percosnacs•

A shit ton of oxycodone and methadone.

1
hedrict•

X2 on the spinal cord stimulator. Check out the one by Medtronics which is the only one approved for full body mri's. they work by flooding your painful areas with a tingling (white noise) that confuses the pain signal. While not 100% pain relief, it is MUCH better relief than any medication I've tried

1
PissedOffVetLadyOP•

Thanks! I'm familiar with the process, as I've used the TENS unit for like, 7 years now. Its really the only thing that gives me some sort of relief. I'm waiting to see my VA doc, but my intake appt isnt til June.

1