CMV: Trans Men/Women Are Experiencing a Form of Mental Illness

[∆(s) from OP]

Let me lead with me stating that this is in no way meant to be derogatory or "trans-phobic". I don't believe that a mental illness necessarily has to carry any sort of social stigma and several illnesses or disorders are already generally accepted in society without excessive judgement (Depression, ADD, etc).

So moving on, I believe that at a very basic level, believing that you are a gender that differs from your physical biology constitutes a common form of Delusional Disorder. This disorder is defined as "unshakable beliefs in something untrue or not based on reality". Believing that you are a man, woman, or anything else when it is clear from your physiology that you are not seems to me to be an example of this behavior.

I believe that allowing people who are suffering from a mental disorder to change their bodies to suit their delusions is irresponsible and wrong. If I asked a doctor to amputate the lower half of my left leg because I'm certain that I was born to be a pirate they surely would turn me away.

Psychiatric counseling and care should be the first response to individuals suffering from any mental illness.

EDIT: So I'm getting a lot of responses to my statement about gender reassignment being irresponsible. I just wanted to say that if there truly is no other option then people should be allowed to do whatever will keep them happy. However that doesn't mean that psychiatric help isn't a valuable first step.

I also just wanted to re-emphasize that I have absolutely nothing against trans individuals. At the risk of sounding cliche, I have friends who are trans that I love dearly. I intended this to be a discussion of gender and mental illness without any stigmas attached. I'm deeply sorry if this thread has offended anyone in any way.

If you are trans, then do what you need to to be happy. Your happiness is more important than the opinions of people on the internet

Posted May 1, 2017, 8:14 PM UTC · edited

881
Loading comments…