Question about First Sale Doctrine

Question

I am planning on making keg tap handles from beer cans that I have either purchased or are sent to me from other people that have purchased the beer. Would this be protected under the First Sale Doctrine, or would I need to seek permission from the breweries themselves in order to do so?

EDIT: I'm in the US

Posted May 2, 2017, 4:12 AM UTC · edited

13
pythonpoole•

If you're just using it is a material to manufacture a new (and different) product, it shouldn't be an issue.

However, if the original branding is visible in such a way that it may look like your product is manufactured or licensed by that company, then you can run into trademark issues. This may also present a problem if you are attempting to use the company's brand to market your product.

For instance, it would be considered trademark infringement to market your product as "Heineken Keg Tap Handles". However, if you use strictly factual and descriptive language, then you may be able to avoid legal trouble (such as in "Custom Keg Tap Handles Made From Heineken Beer Cans" with an appropriate disclaimer clarifying that you have no official affiliation or connection with Heineken). Having said that, the only way to ensure you don't run into legal problems is to completely avoid any use of the original company's branding/trademarks.

2
cloudymind87OP•

Thanks for the reply! My plan is to have people send me cans of their favorite beer that they would like to have made into a tap handle. I would make it and send it back to them. I wouldn't be marketing it as "X Brewing Co. Tap Handles" though. I'm not sure exactly how to market it, but it won't be specific to any brewery or label, nor using any brands to advertise for them. I'll be taking money to cover materials, shipping and the time it takes to make them.

1
pythonpoole•

Interesting business plan. I don't really see any issue with this, particularly when the customer is providing the material and you are not using anyone else's trademarks to promote your product.

This seems to be a similar business model to companies that let you ship materials/products to them and then they apply custom skins, decorations, etching, etc. (as requested) and ship the materials/products back (something like this).

1