Questions about the game, current state etc

[Help]

Hello everyone! I became aware of this game a few days ago and have since played the one hour trial on Xbox. I find the atmosphere incredibly captivating so far but one hour doesn't really give a decently sized impression as there's no time to explore a little and get a feel for it. I thought I'd come here with some questions before deciding to buy or not. This game looks really amazing and promising, but I've been burned before.

  1. Xbox or pc? Obviously PC has greater potential with hardware but the Xbox version felt good to me too, and I'm stuck with laptop for now. Decent specs but heat is a major issue. How's release schedules? I've seen console versions of other games being several weeks or even months behind PC for some other titles. That's my major concern here.

  2. Longevity and story. How's the replay value? Procedurally generated means new map each time but story elements and triggers are present either way. Witcher is a static world and has plenty of replay value. I also read somewhere that the story isn't finished, is this correct? It's not a problem if it isn't, but if nothing new has been added for a long time that might be a red flag.

  3. Gameplay. Crafting and survival are fine, I've plenty of experience there. How's the balance though? Food too hard or too easy to manage? Fighting is always kiting but how's the variation, do they all rush straight at you or are there varying behaviours?

That's it for now, hope you're all staying away from that Joy :) Seriously, that prologue was chilling

Posted May 2, 2017, 5:24 PM UTC

411
CompulsionGamesGame Developer•

Hey guys - just popping in to say if anyone else has comments on this, we'd love to hear them! Very helpful for us to assess what we're doing well, and what we can improve on.

Hi OP! Just passing through. Nothing to see here...

7
ElmbergOP•

It's so great when devs poke around community areas and say hi! Shows that you care, and that is incredibly important in my opinion. Thanks for making this game, I've played a few more hours now and it gives me just the right kind of chills. I did find a sleeping guy floating a few metres away from his intended bed ;)

2
CompulsionGamesGame Developer•

"Sorry honey, I was just too high to join you," said the citizen of Wellington Wells, unaware of the depth of her pun.

6
octopus__•

you've gotten a lot of good answers already, but i figured i'd chime in too because i love this game and some of your points haven't been entirely addressed yet

1.) i play PC. an advantage is updates seem to come faster to the PC. i have a GT 730 graphics card and a i5 processer on medium-ish settings with absolutely no problems at all. i have no experience playing on an xbox so i can't really comment on the comparison between the two.

2.) i agree with everyone else that there is plenty of replay value here. i have well over 200 hours between july when i purchased and now. in regards to story, theres not really any scripted, liner sequences like the prologue in game currently, although thats coming (current estimates are maybe the end of this year for a 1.0 release). HOWEVER there is a lot more story in game then people give it credit for if you're willing to look for it. the side quests, in-game written lore, phone booth conversations, dialogue the AI says, etc. all shapes the world really, really well. it's subtle and a lot of people just don't seem to care about reading the text documents found in game but i would highly recommend it!

3.) so theres 3 gameplay modes--one that essentially eliminates the hunger/thirst/sleep mechanics, a middle road mode, and a hard mode with more aggressive needs and AI. between the three, i feel that most people can find one more or another that they enjoy. . i've been playing on the medium level and hardest level difficultly and it's felt perfectly balanced to me. i bitched about certain items being lacking at first, but they're just hidden in specific places that take time to find. a lot of it just depends on how throughly you search and how much time and effort you're willing to put into lootingfighting is actually really intersting because the AI seems to respond differently depending on the island you're located on in game. for example, on the first islands where nobody is on joy, they are passive but will chase you forever if you piss them off. on the joy islands, the AI is really aggressive if you behave even slightly off, but they abandon the chase very quickly (because joy makes you forget). i've heard from the devs that AI is going to undergo a major change soon, so take that with a grain of salt, but one of my favorite challenges in game was learning how different people will behave in different places.

overall, i really really recommend this game in it's current state as long as you understand and are okay with the scripted prologue-like sequences being mostly absent for now. for some people that's a deal breaker. but if you like survival games and want to learn about the world through more subtle story telling, i really really really really recommend it.

3
amydonnelly13•
  1. Xbox forever.

  2. The replay value is indescribable. I'm constantly starting new save files, replaying, everything. Already it's such a vast, incredible world with so much to do you'll accidentally use up most of your day without realizing it.

  3. Everything is perfectly balanced. Food and hunger go down often enough to be challenging, but not enough to make it unplayable. Food that isn't rotten is difficult enough to find, but not so difficult that you can't eat. And water pumps are found in many various locations :)

I'm incredibly bias because I love this game so much, even when it's not finished yet. You'd be missing out if you didn't continue playing :)

Also yeah, that prologue gave me chills.

2
ElmbergOP•

Thanks for the thoughts, that sounds exactly like I was hoping this would be!

3
SP5021•
  1. Xbox is fine, that's what I play this game on. It is behind PC by a few weeks IIRC but I personally don't care about that fact.

  2. The game has come a long way since I bought it almost a year ago. There are many more quests available now than before, said quests glitch far less frequently than before, and the game is immersive enough that it has good replay value.

  3. Gameplay wise, I'd say the game is fine. Hunger and Thirst were kinda bad in the beginning but now its better, as long as you forage semi-frequently you should be good. NPC variety in combat is also good, though it could use some improvement in variety.

2
ElmbergOP•

Thanks for the insight, it's much appreciated

1
amydonnelly13•

Also, in terms of updates, the game JUST got a huge one, I think the biggest one yet.

1
Amoxii•

Hi OP!

  1. PC here, it's what I'm used to and prefer. Also, I make a copy of the map on a different monitor to help me remember the areas that I have already looted.

  2. Very replay-able. Even the entrance to the different islands change, causing different quests to generate for those entrances. Now that they have the new play-type feature, it's even more replay-able.

  3. Quite balanced. I do think health depletes more than usual, but crafting healing balms is easy. Not hard to find edible berries, and looting gets you a couple of heartier food items.

Have​ fun!

1
ElmbergOP•

How you play on PC is how I would like my setup to be. Sadly, like I said, I'm stuck with a laptop for now. Some day... Thanks for the input! Always appreciated!

1