BeefkiOP•

Looks like nobody has to worry about WindowsS threatening anything.

9
davim00•

I know, right? My how things have changed. Once Microsoft got in trouble for "forcing" people to use the browser that came with Windows, making it an integral part of the OS. Now their doing it again, except for real this time, and I don't really think anybody is going to care.

3
jonathan2260•

It's not like they are the only ones now. Google Chrome itself only offers one choice of browser (yeah I know the browser is the OS). This Windows S is supposed to compete with Chromebooks so unlike in the days where everything was running on top of Windows, Microsoft now has competition they can't just muscle over with their OS.

2
lovelybac0n•

Except MS themselves, and schoolchildrens ability to find anything. DDG FTW!!

1
earlof711•

How is this not Windows RT 2.0? Same lack of software. Same niche market. Same race-to-the-bottom for a company whose focus is enterprise. I don't get the Microsoft internal research that suggests this will be a hit.

4
thorgrotle•

Well, normal people will gooble it up, they don't give a shit. On a lot of levels Windows 10S will actually solve a lot of problems for normal people: No more crapware(appart from stuff in app store). I could see, this to be a good move, most smaller businesses whould improve of lean running machines. But will they meet people's demands in Microsoft store.. Man, we in this reddit is NOT the target.

2
iBurley•

I agree, if they get enough software in that Windows 10 "App Store" I think this could be a good move for most people. The real problem I see is that regular people still use printers and plug their digital camera in with USB instead of using a card reader. Those people will need drivers, and I don't know if that "App Store" is set up to deal with that right now.

There's also the fear that they can corner the market by who they allow in. You'll never see Steam in there I'm sure. Not only would MS rather people bought games through the Xbox app, but I'm sure there's probably some sort of monetization cut in it for them that Valve wouldn't go for. Not sure how that would work for a free program that just has paid content inside though.

I guess we'll see. At the end of the day it's shipping on one device, and they're letting people who buy that one device upgrade to a standard version for like $50, so I doubt anybody really cares. Seems like them testing the waters more than anything.

2
veritanudaDeviantDebian•

Well, normal people will gooble it up, they don't give a shit.

Not true, I have had quite few clients who have called me up asking why they were using a different browser. Upon investigation all of them had downloaded some addon plugin whatever they changed their default home page away from Google Search.

Needless to say it was a (relatively) simple fix but I told them if happens again not to panic and follow the steps I showed them to reset their browser preferences.

You'd be surprised how much joe public buys into market branding. They even go so far as saying "I'll google that, thanks"

So yeah, if MS are really being hard-nosed about it, they are gonna lose. Doesn't matter how 'good' their service is. It just won't be the same as Google's.

2
BeefkiOP•

Really? I feel like it will backfire on the commonfolk for many of the same reasons WinRT did.

ChromeOS is doing as well as it is for a couple reasons. First is that they got the right price point, which it seems Microsoft is trying to compete with. Second, people went into ChromeOS without expectations, and that's where Microsoft failed by calling this "Windows". Normals don't know that they're running Windows, but they know what Windows looks like and there's the expectation that things work a certain way.

I admit I don't know much about the Windows Store, how easy will it be to get OSS on there? How about changing maintainers? It sounds like the Windows Store approach could lead to the chicken and egg paradox, why should devs spend time for a small niche and why would the niche grow when software availablity is poor? Further proprietary software has little reason to end up there as the appstore market is essentially non-viable as a business model. The cheap upgrade to a "real" OS isn't much of a selling point either, considering the limited hardware WindowsS is intended for.

I honestly think the only real hope MS has with this is indoctrination of students into their ecosystem. I ultimately don't see that as a huge issue either, since Microsoft has less chance at it than Google due largely in part to Microsoft not be "cool" (as someone else stated) and lacking any real privacy improvments since they've gotten into gobbling up every morsel of user data too.

As time goes on, the long-standing modus operandi of Microsoft is eroding, they can't come into a market after the market has proven itself and throw money until they win anymore. You have to oblitherate your opposition with a substantially better product or resign yourself to making the product that your piece of the pie can sustain.

2
palasso•

That's exactly the type of control both Google and Valve were afraid Microsoft will do. Google made android, Valve SteamOS, both linux-based. The stricter Microsoft gets the higher the motivation for the other companies to invest in linux.

2
lykwydchykyn•

I'm betting this will fail for one reason: They called it Windows.

You call it Windows, and people immediately have expectations. They expect it'll run office, or photoshop, or that piece of random software they bought 13 years ago and still use daily. They'll think it's just another "Windows laptop" that they can set up just like their old Windows laptop.

Same reason Web appliances failed in the late 90's, and netbooks failed in the mid-00's: The consumer did not understand the product and felt cheated.

If they called it "SurfaceOS", or "BingOS", or just about anything to make it clear that this is a very different thing from "Windows" (even though it technically is), people would accept it.

2
SatisfyMyMind•

well they surely won't be able to pull that off in Europe

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BrowserChoice.eu

1
jmabbz•

I only care because my kids are likely to end up using this or chromebooks.

1
computerfr33k•

Why is this windows article in the Linux action show subreddit? This has nothing to do with Linux.

-1
BeefkiOP•

It was talked about in recent episodes and is about an area where Linux currently dominates (even if only tenuously via ChromeOS)

3
earlof711•

Maybe because it's a targeted attack in a market dominated by Linux-based devices.

3
waspentalive•

If I know myself but not my enemy, he will win the battle and the war. - Sun Two probably.

3
glink86•

so we are not supposed to look outside of the Linux world?

we are talking about an OS but not supposed to look at the OS landscape? how are we supposed to grow if we are not aware of what is going on next to us?

this kind of bubble is dumb.

I wont say let EVERYTHING be posted here, but not complain from time to time to see the movements of other OS's, as well as their announcements, and in this case, something that can actually benefit Linux...

2