Christians saying "I don't treat gay people any differently" and personal experience

Often in discussions on this sub surrounding homosexuality/homophobia, I'll inevitably hear someone say that while they're not gay affirming, they don't treat gay people any differently. This is usually to defend themselves from accusations of homophobia or to support the assertion that one's personal beliefs don't contribute to an atmosphere of oppression for LGBT people.

To me, this sentiment reminds me of the "love the sinner, hate the sin" controversy: it sounds nice in theory, but it doesn't work in practice.

I wanted to share my story of how non-affirming Christians reacted when I came out (and in comparison to my affirming Christian friends). Obviously, this is just one story, but I imagine many of us have had similar experiences.

I grew up in the Evangelical church (SBC). Virtually all of my friends I made at church, and I was there 3-4 times a week growing up. My parents were in leadership (I couldn't have asked for better parents). I sang in the choir, and I played in the youth band throughout middle and high school and then in the college band thereafter. My friends were good. They were superlatively nice. We loved each other, and we were so close.

I came out as gay to them all towards the end of college. I had a serious boyfriend. And everything changed.

Homosexuality was virtually never mentioned. My pastor did a Romans sermon series, and the point of Rom. 2 is that homosexuality isn't worse than any other sin. Sounds not bad, right?

The first thing that happened was I was uninvited from being recognized in the event for graduates. Not "because I was gay," but because I was told it'd be better if I kept a lower profile. I can't lie: that was embarrassing. Then, I wasn't invited back to play in the band, despite talk of me being tapped for the Sunday morning big leagues. (As a shyer person, those relationships were kind of a social lifeline.)

In fact, all talk about me stopped. At least all talk that I could hear. Invites started to disappear. Eventually we stopped hanging out at all. Interactions started seeming artificial and aloof. My parents revealed the myriad discussions occurring about me behind the scenes -- but not a single one of those people talked to me face-to-face. There was gossip on gossip on gossip, and that hurt. (If being gay -- and note: nobody knew if I was having sex or not -- wasn't worse than other sins, wouldn't plenty of other "scandals" arise in a megachurch of thousands?)

When I brought my bf to the Christmas musical at my mother's request, you could feel the awkwardness of people around me. I could notice when people came up to shake my hand the hesitant glance at him before walking away. Other peers' relationship milestones were being celebrated: engagements, weddings, babies. Not a single one ever asked how my bf was doing. Not even after we got engaged. You don't have to approve of my relationship to simply ask how he's doing; it's simple courtesy. With my family, when I brought him and the things we did together up -- normal ass conversation in any context -- faces would go blank, and the topic would be quickly shifted away. My life is unfit for public discussion.

This may seem small, but Facebook tells you a lot about people. The milestones I discussed above are shared and "liked," and commented on and "reacted to." Unless you're gay. Dozens of church folk liking a photo with my family then zero likening a photo with my fiancé or about my engagement or about my wedding is palpable. One of the things I've come to appreciate are those one or two loner kids from long ago at church liking one of those statuses. It's the little things.

The cumulative effect of these things hurts. I ultimately left that church. There was nothing for me there. I don't think anybody did anything spitefully or maliciously. I honestly think the situation arose out of awkwardness and continual second guessing of how to treat me. And I think that's a fruit of non-affirming theology.

It's that thought of "what do I say" when you meet my bf, that inevitably shows up on your face. It's your subconsciously moving the conversation away from or never bringing up my life to avoid awkwardness. It's that second guessing "maybe I shouldn't 'like' this photo cuz it might look like I'm endorsing sin." It's your silence in the face of my most important life events.

Yes, that feels ostracizing. Yes, I don't want to be a dirty secret or covered-up scandal. Yes, I'd prefer to spend time with affirming Christians who celebrate when I celebrate and cry when I cry. That's where I feel the love of Christ.

(And I expect some of you will just call me out for whining. I already get it. You don't have to repeat it below.)

Posted May 4, 2017, 3:14 PM UTC · locked

338314
Loading comments…