r/TagProIRL•
-Time-

What criteria determine whether you upvote or downvote on reddit?

Question of the Day

Do you never vote? Do you upvote anything that makes you smile? Do you only upvote occasionally? Do you downvote people you don't like? Do you downvote a lot?

No judgment, I'm genuinely curious to understand everyone's voting patterns, so honesty would be cool even if you downvote everything.

Posted May 5, 2017, 11:21 AM UTC

719
TagProNoah_Noah•

Laugh = Upvote

Learn something new = upvote

Adds something to the discussion = upvote

Cites sources = upvote

Misses the point of the thread/subreddit = downvote

Makes a dumb joke in a serious thread = downvote

Is unnecessarily mean = downvote

Says something objectively false = downvote

13
-Time-OPツ Tsu•

That all seems fair.

How often would you say you vote? Like what percentage of comments you read?

3
TagProNoah_Noah•

Not often. Like 5%.

3
kstarr12nipplefart•

Usually if someone replies to my comment I'll upvote it.

4
PIZZAspartan442PIZZAspartan•

test

9
PIZZAspartan442PIZZAspartan•

lol nice

8
-Time-OPツ Tsu•

Test

5
psychfan5•

Even if I think bagged milk is stupid?

2†
-Time-OPツ Tsu•

Around the rest of reddit I only vote on probably about 1% of the posts/comments I read. I'll vote on anything I have a strong reaction to, i.e. if I laughed I'll upvote or if I'm particularly offended by someone's stupidity I'll downvote. I honestly pay pretty much zero attention to reddiquette when downvoting. If I disagree with something strongly enough I'll often downvote.

I'm more generous with votes on subs I'm active in. I upvote more in TagProirl, for example. I'd say anywhere upwards of 25-50%, and nearly 90% of posts.

I think I'm pretty good at not downvoting and upvoting people because of who they are, but judging posts and comments on their merit alone.

I guess that's about it. I just think the anonymous voting system is interesting and I'd love to hear others' motivations.

Edit: oh I forgot. I downvote anyone who makes truly egregious grammar mistakes. "alot", using "it's" as a possessive (LS and Berlin Ball do that one), "u" for "you", stuff like that.

3
_q42_q42 | MA•

I do pretty much the same as you, although I try to save downvoting for when people are being complete idiots or being mean. I definitely vote more in certain subs than others - I'll only upvote rarely in, say, r/ssbm but I'll upvote most of the content in r/MLTP. And I always upvote posts that take some amount of effort to make (previews, analyses) and discussion threads.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
bigswingin69•

Purely based on whether or not it will make an impact on that person if you downvote them. If their post is at 100% or you can put their comment at a 0 then it is a downvote in my book. Or if you can upvote a comment that makes someone look stupider, but only some of the time because other people do it for you!!!

0†
psychfan5•

I like this idea. Your comment was at +2, so I downvoted so someone can down vote to get you to zero so someone can be a hero and upvote!

11
bigswingin69•

There seems to be a few people doing that and I love it!

6
psychfan5•

What do you do when the villains overpower the heroes?

1
bigswingin69•

Well tell me how you feel now that your bagged milk comment went down to -2 and now back to 1. Makes you think somebody cares about you right?

1
-Time-OPツ Tsu•

So your voting patterns are based on what you feel will most strongly impact someone on a personal level? Even if negatively. Interesting.

6
bigswingin69•

But if you think about it, someone else will come make that 0 into a 1 and then that person will be happy! I'm just promoting the happiness half the time.

-1†
-Time-OPツ Tsu•

Ah, the misunderstood villain. Playing the bad guy so another can play the hero and attain glory. What selfless devotion you possess for the betterment of mankind!

10
PIZZAspartan442PIZZAspartan•

and this is why we can't have nice things

2