CMV: The Will does not exist as a singular entity

It is typical to believe that each person has 1 Will, has 1 set of beliefs, has 1 Consciousness which drives their actions.

However, it is readily apparent that this view is false.

Addiction: A person can truly believe that they want to quit X. They can seek help, they can seek guidance and want desperately to quit X, yet fail. Their body may perform actions (X) which they don't want to perform.

Cognitive Dissonance - People can be of two minds on 1 subject. Someone can earnestly support 1 thing, yet also actively undermine it. They may believe X is moral, but in action do the opposite.

Ego Depletion - This is the concept that Will is a limited resource. That once your Will is depleted, you have substantially less conscious control over your impulses than you would otherwise. If true, what does this mean? This implies that one's impulses towards actions are separate from one's ability to suppress those impulses, which implies at least 2 Wills.

Freud - taken at face value this implies 3 wills, id, ego, superego. We have impulses, we have moral constraints, and we have an arbiter between them. But this means that we are of three minds about all our decisions.

System 1 System 2 - System 1 is the automatic quick thinking system, System 2 is the slower, logical system. While system 2 can occasionally restrain and control system 1, most of the time, system 1 runs our lives.

Neuroscience - our brains process information in parellel - there isn't 1 long circuit which connects our entire brain - there are many separate circuits each with different functions. In aggregate, these circuits may yield contradictory outcomes in seemingly similar circumstances, because different circuits "took the lead" as it were.

Urges - in its most basic form - as humans we have urges, yet we also have the ability to repress those urges and not act on them. Which of these is the singular Will - the initial urges - or our ability to repress them? As soon as you acknowledge a distinction between our urges and our ability to not act on them, you have acknowledged 2 Wills.

While I'm sure everyone here finds at least 1 of the above opinions objectionable, I also believe that everyone here will find at least 1 of those opinions to be roughly correct. While we can all disagree on WHY the concept of a singular will is wrong, I think we can all agree that there is at least 1 strong reason to disbelieve in a singular will.

How to CMV- find a way to demonstrate that addicts act of 1 mind or demonstrate that urges and the ability to suppress urges, which can and often fails, fits within a singular will and doesn't necessitate a second will.

Edit: Not 100% sure this will clarify my views, but this comic does touch on the general ideas I am attempting to argue. This comic is not my own, I found it via a Google search, if someone knows the original author, I am more than happy to credit them.

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/87/4e/4e/874e4e8af2159a841fe4fa343a43b5cb.jpg


This is a footnote from the CMV moderators. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views**! Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!

Posted May 8, 2017, 4:21 PM UTC · edited

114
Loading comments…