Ruling Question: Rachel's Smile

I understand that there are 2 points during the turn when produced will is reset, the unrest phase and end phase of a turn. My question: Is there a moment when Rachel's Smile can be used after your opponent unrests all of their stones but before they actually leave the part of the phase where any produced will be reset? Is there a chase to untapping that doesn't result in everything untapping again? Will my opponent always have the option to rest all of his stones in response to Rachel's Smile and produce enough will to put out resonators or use spells to destroy my resonators?

Posted May 10, 2017, 9:56 PM UTC

35
StormyWaters2021•

All produced will goes away just before recovering stones, so you can't use it to stop them from playing things on their turn. Yes, they can always rest things in response to it, no matter when you cast it, and there is no point on their turn that it can stop them from using it during their turn.

1
Srlqulongtard•

no, at the point that they recover their stones, they keep all mana they float. it seems like you want some kind of law of silence type of thing where your opponent can't play cards for the turn.

1
Usht•

The correct time to play it is at the start of the opponent's main phase after they recover. However, they can rest their stones in response to grab all the will they'll need for the turn, so what the card is good for is stopping you from being attacked and to make sure your opponent can't interact with you on your turn.

1
TruebacchussOP•

If that is the case wouldn't the best time to play it be at the very end of the turn? Once they have played all of the resonators they are going to play. This will ensure that everything they have is tapped allowing you to get through all of your attacks without worry of them blocking or casting any kind of counterspells.

It being an ancient magic, seems like it would be a great combo card in an alhamat angels deck. If you dropped the Celestial Wing Seraph, searched Lucifer, and had any form of board state going into turn 5 then you can use the counters for Rachel's Smile and hopefully swing for game.

Honestly, It's probably a dead draw most of the time. It just seems like if you're using it to make sure you aren't being attacked that Amaratsu's Foresight is a much better play.

1
Usht•

Good question, the reason why end of turn isn't necessarily the best time to play it is because your opponent might have resonators he or she will be attacking with. So in that case, you want to make sure to rest the resonators as well to not take too much damage.

And yeah, it is a dead draw a lot of the time but it has niche uses since it makes sure the opponent isn't holding up cancel spells, for example, when you do something big, like an awakened Rise from the Depths. Generally though, most lists have gone looking for more efficient ways of dealing with that, such as use discard to preemptively get rid of possible stops in the plan.

1