Atheists are more intelligent, according to a study of 63 papers
[removed]
Posted May 14, 2017, 9:07 PM UTC
[removed]
Posted May 14, 2017, 9:07 PM UTC
Lets be fair. Its not that we don't believe, it's just that deathbed conversions (to religions that absolves all your prior sins) is just the best way to game the system. Take that, God!
Lol
Lol
The low intelligence of your response has placed you on a list. Please report to the nearest Center for the Improvement of Society immediately.
This is an automated response. If you wish to appeal this decision, please report to the nearest Center for the Improvement of Society immediately.
I'm so sorry. Would it help if I wore a fedora? I reckon I.Q increases tenfold with a fedora and by typing passive aggressive comments on Reddit such as:
"sigh... religion....."
"you may believe in a sky daddy but i don't. that makes me super rational, like 100% of the time."
Skims through the first chapter of The God Delusion ->>"I read books of SCIENCE, not books of fiction like the Bible haha"
Your reply has been noted.
Please report to the nearest Center for the Improvement of Society so that your case may be properly and impartially evaluated.
Will do, Grand Inquisitor.
For the Glory of Bill Nye the Science Guy!
[deleted]
Nah I haven't read it. I read actual engineering textbooks as a part of my study, thus leading to me to neglect filling my head with useless garbage. One in this position must be very picky about what he/she decides to read; the God Delusion is very low in my list.
Do genius always respond with an equation?
There seem to be some major exceptions to the rule though and I suggest that those should be studied to figure out if "atheism" is the main determining factor here. For example, Freeman Dyson is Catholic if I remember correctly, but I doubt that he would be considered terribly religious.
The issue may be less about God or no God and more about how realistic someone's metaphysical beliefs are. It may also have more to do with reliance on faith vs logical reasoning in problem situations, and this may not correlate perfectly with theism since someone could have faith in some simpleminded idea or leader which is then applied to inappropriate situations.
"It's not entirely clear why non-religious people are more intelligent"
Excuse me?
Sincere adherence to religious beliefs is indicative of a lowered intellectual standard for truth. Plain and simple.
It's also important to distinguish between religiosity and spirituality. One who believes in an abstract higher power (like Spinoza's notion of God, not the God of Abrahamic religions) does not have explicit proof for this claim, but at the same time provides a hypothesis for that which science cannot yet totally account for instead of undulging themselves in an oh-so-conveniant fairy tale.
Societies need to balance tolerance of those with differing views against maintaining a standard of intellectual rigor worthy of the 21st century and the scientific method which has led us here.
As a matter of principle, religious people must have equal rights, but their beliefs must and should be scrutinized so that public discourse can be dedicated to matters of actual importance such as climate change and the sustainability of life on this planet.
In catering to and accomodating for religious groups, unwarranted legitimacy is granted to outdated belief systems and as a result, society's intellectual standard is effectively lowered. Public discourse suffers and focus is taken away from real, pressing issues.
We should not be ashamed to hope that organized religion (not personal spirituality) be a relic of the past because intellectually speaking, it is.
As a matter of principle, religious people must have equal rights, but their beliefs must and should be scrutinized so that public discourse can be dedicated to matters of actual importance such as climate change and the sustainability of life on this planet.
Don't forget eugenics. It worked out so well the last time.
To be fair having discussions about eugenics would be a step forward from trying to convince people that their religious prophet did not in fact split the seas, turn water into wine or ride a winged horse up to heaven.
I simply wish for all religious beliefs and stories to be contextualized in the same way that egyptian, nordic or greek mythology is studied today.
Was China's one child policy eugenics? Given our environmental footprint and the current population growth we must consider drastic action, or climate change and scarcity of resources will probably lead to humanity's demise.
Oh wait. Isn't that what a large portion of humanity is hoping for? The armageddon, end times or judgement day, however you want to call it. Yet more proof that sincere belief in myths is destructive.
Thanks for allowing me to expand on my thoughts.
Now you have some great ideas, but you are going to need a lot of weapons and armies to pull it off. Keep in mind however, that historically it is the Intellectuals that get rounded up and killed first, and It is the genocidal maniacs that end up heading the committees.
We should not be ashamed to hope that organized religion (not personal spirituality) be a relic of the pas
This isn't really possible without playing semantic games with the definition of religion. We're always going to have organized ideologies even if we don't use the term "religion" to describe them. It would be best not to fall into a semantic trap based on an overly arbitrary and restricted definition of the term religion.
When you hope for "organized religion" to go away, what exactly is it that you hope will go away? Tradition? Doesn't seem likely. Irrationality? Doesn't seem likely. Hierarchy replaced with pure self-organization? Also doesn't seem likely. Mysticism? Possibly but again people may fall into the trap of mysticism by engaging in it without calling it mysticism.
Let's not get too self righteous because of this. Intelligence is just one of many qualities a person can have. I've met dumb atheists and smart believers.
[deleted]
That's part of the problem with these things. Our definition of intelligence could be too arbitrary, limited, and to some extent too specific to cultural values (such as engineering and technology being considered more important than philosophy and language).
One area that seems to be hard to test on paper is social intelligence which could be defined as one's ability to understand what others are thinking/feeling or predict how they would think/feel in a given situation. Then on top of that there would be variation in how intelligent someone was in understanding not only people from the same social environment but people who are enculturated/acculturated differently or even non-human species like animals.
Even things like the ability to reproduce music on a musical instrument by ear or learn dance moves by watching involve some sort of intelligence but aren't usually tested.
I want to respond to your comment with due respect and care. You're right about people having more to them than their intelligence but I hope you spoke that in this context and meant that there's more to improving one's thinking skills than intelligence. Personally, all I know is that we improve our cognitive processes when we work on them.
I wanted to address your account of a subjective experience of having met dumb atheists and smart believers. If intelligence tests were our perceptions of people, our personal standards inspired by cringe, blunders our crush made, the standards of the society, unresolved insecurities of the members of r/iamverysmart...next to a thousand variables such as someone's mood, their day, them not having stepped upon an indispensible piece of knowledge,,,,,if they were measures of intelligence...then there's be no iq tests, which are the only scientifically accurate method of measuring intelligence, and even that when administered in a certain form..To just make a rough estimate of people's ability to memorize and learn, they are grinded into schools for decades and then tested unfairly.
Furthermore, the ratio of "dumb atheists" and "smart believers" must match the figures in studies, which makes this statement useless. However, there's an implication that you've found, more or less, equal values of them, a claim so grand that it would require you to hire a few thousand specialists in their field to prove, because it is quite against what we have been proved so far. Not that I went through the literature.
Being dumb or smart is not a universal quality that applies to everything someone does in their life. We also cannot deny being emotionally attached to deeply held beliefs. We all have blind spots in our own logic and thoughts. It is thetefore important to have respectful discussions in a dialectical manner rather than get locked into a debating mentality where we may feel we must not concede anything.
A believer being (rightly) labelled as smart for, let's say, programming skill, doesn't change the fact that their religious beliefs lack proof.
PREACH.
[deleted]
I've been hot in Alaska and cold in Texas, the outliers don't change the trend.
Yep.