r/playrust•
dalco

Is PUBG doing "Rust" better than Rust?

Question

PUBG is the arena shooter developed by Brendan Greene, the same mind behind the ARMA game mode and H1Z1's use of battleground. And I think that by looking at what PUBG does right, we can see where Rust has gone off the rails (in my opinion) in its development.

There are a lot of similarities in Rust and PUBG, but for conversation's sake I want to focus on a major differentiating factor between the two games: Base building.

In typical survival games like Rust, base building facilitate's survival by granting protection from the elements, a place to gather resources, and a haven to "tech up." PUBG eliminates this system altogether and focuses specifically on PvP. Rust subverts this system by allowing other players to raid your base and implementing sleepers, which ultimately means that a base = / = safety.

The end result of both these approaches is that mechanics of both games lead towards PvP encounters. Losing these encounters carries penalties in both games (loss of gear to other players, permadeath, ect), however with PUBG you can easily join a new game and get right back into the action. With Rust, you have to respawn at a bag/base and the encounter is over. If you aren't rich you need to grind components in order to remake the gear you lost, and it might be several hours before a new encounter.

Now, I think there is something of value in Rust's approach. The slow burn with high-intensity gunfights sets a pace that is unique only to Rust. Plus, an interesting community rife with politics tends to rise up on populated servers. However, there are drawbacks to this system (zergs, offline raiding, high learning curve) that make the game largely inaccessible to anyone who plays survival games for reasons beyond PvP. Anecdotally, I have tried to get several friends into the game - they all ragequit after their base invariably gets raided and ruined after a few days. Generally speaking, these friends are fans of the survival genre and enjoy the base-building in Rust but aren't huge on the PvP or the penalty death carries.

(Now, I know that seems like an oxymoron - as most survival games carry a death penalty. How can you be a fan of the survival genre yet criticize the death penalty in Rust? Well, dying in most survival games is the result of actions by the player. Rust is one of the only games where you can die through nearly no fault of your own - and when you are offline to boot. This feels unfair to many more casual players of the genre.)

I know this has been a long post, it seems to me that if we are playing Rust PURELY for PvP, then PUBG will be the natural progression for many players to jump to. It offers high intensity action and traditional survival mechanics without the commitment or penalties that come with playing through a server wipe in Rust.

I think overall, this viewpoint probably lends credence to the need for a progression and PvE system in Rust. The longer Facepunch keeps spending time fine-tuning PvP balance will make it harder to implement these systems in a balanced in nuanced way.

tl;dr: I am finding little reason to invest the absurd amount of time it takes into enjoying Rust when I can play a round of PUBG and get almost the same PvP experience. Rust doesn't have anything to offer except a PvP experience.

Posted May 15, 2017, 6:02 PM UTC

076
mtat51•

I don't think they way you compare the games is fair. I play both games but for vastly different reasons. PUBG is a fun, quick tactical battle royale. Rust is(was?) a survival game to be played with a group. The only thing I think you can compare is just how crisp guns in PUBG are. Noises/recoil/optics all feel so good in PUBG. In Rust not so much. I understand that's due to the post-apocalyptic nature of Rust but I still don't know why the guns have to feel like inaccurate RNG peashooters.

8
dalcoOP•

The fact that you say that "Rust is(was?) a survival game" is kind of my point though. If the survival systems are so dumbed down/non-existent then do you think players will continue to enjoy Rust when there are quicker routes to a similar experience?

5
mtat51•

Oh that's a perfectly good point. I think you're right about that. Why would I play Helk's "PVP" game with all of it's grind and nonsense for a shittier experience when I could just play PUBG. I love(d) Rust's PVP in the ages of crossbow/waterpipe when guns were scarce but powerful. But these days it just isn't fun to use a shitty pistol or clunky rifle on the first day of a wipe.

3
dalcoOP•

That's exactly what I am getting at. There are plenty of things that make Rust a unique experience that PUBG doesn't have - the tech progression, the art style, a persistent world.... But I feel like when you reduce the game to its intention, it's a game that only implements systems to fuel PvP encounters. And when looked at in that lens, why not just play PUBG?

I really do think that Rust enjoys a niche, which is why it has remained popular. Yet PUBG has 3x as many all-time players on Steam, and since its release Rust has experienced a steady drop in playercount.

http://steamcharts.com/cmp/252490,578080#All

1
anotherreaditRuigi•

when you reduce the game to your intention

FTFY

1
dustwetsuit•

Rust as a survival game is long gone. Last update killed it.

It's just a pvp fest. GJ

1
Jaywearspants•

how? They're completely different kind of games.

3
dalcoOP•

Did you read the post? The only differentiating factor between the two is base building. The survival aspects of Rust aren't nearly fleshed out enough to call it a survival game. Which is why people often refer to it as a "base building PvP game." They are both "gather gear and duke it out" games to me.

0
Jaywearspants•

rust is a survival crafting game, pubg is not. They're not even on the same continent unless that continent is called "early access."

3
dalcoOP•

There is no need to craft anything other than PvP gear in Rust. Calling it a survival game beyond the first 30 min is a bit silly. Play something like Don't Starve Together.

Either way, they are definitely "on the same continent" - it's the same gameplay system that H1Z1 had with their battlegrounds. Just with crafting and survival stripped out. My point is that these systems are so shallow in Rust they don't bring anything new to the table. It's just PvP encounters with a long burn in-between.

-1
Jaywearspants•

I have 700 hours in rust and maybe 10 of those were pvp relevant. There's more to rust than pvp.

2
wornoutwasd•

They aren't even in the same genre.

It's like saying rust is exactly like Cities Skylines because you build stuff.

Or Rust is exactly like World of Warcraft because you gather resources and craft things.

2
dalcoOP•

You can compare gameplay systems from multiple genres to have an intelligent discussion about a game. At the end of the day, both are PvP shooters.

1
wornoutwasd•

Pvp shooters.. So quake and rust are similar too? Rust isn't a mil sim. Rust isn't an arena shooter. Rust is closer to a mmofps with the number of players per server and pve elements.

1
AvgHeightForATree•

Is the 3rd person H1Z1 clone, that is nothing more than the latest garbage-tier cash grab with pre-order-bundles (that's right, literally an Alpha with pre-order deluxe skins and codes), doing 'Rust' better than Rust?

Yeah... definitely mate. So glad we can finally pre-order the Rust we've always dreamed of.

Jesus christ...

On a side note, the studio developing this moist turd is none other than Blue Hole Studios - renowned for creating the most unoriginal copy-paste trash titles on the market. All glitter and no guts. Tera being the worst of them.

This game will draw in teens with their Mum's credit cards and will die when ADHD demands the next 3rd person spray festival with 450,000 skins and pre-order crates.

3
dalcoOP•

pre-order-bundles (that's right, literally an Alpha with pre-order deluxe skins and codes), doing 'Rust' better than Rust?

How is this any different than the Rust steam workshop? Rust is still in EA too. (Mind you, for what, 5 years now?) Also PUBG is only 3% behind Rust in reviews left behind players in the past 30 days.

I really don't have a horse in this race, I don't even play PUBG - I tried a friends copy for a bit. I have been playing Rust since legacy and am a fan. You didn't actually address any of my points. PUBG's success does not diminish that of Rust.

Here is my point: Are you playing Rust for PvP? And if not, what other reasons are you playing it for? All the other systems are so shallow that this seems like an apt comparison. Both games lean towards PvP encounters. Is the format of Rust as a survival game wrong? And if not, then why is the survival aspect so shallow?

1
c64person•

I am not playing Rust for purely PVP persay, neither are a lot of people.

I get to chose if I run into people, or actively avoid them. Maybe I just want a garden one week, maybe the next week I want to play a ninja and go sneak into people's bases.

I have that choice in Rust.

You dont in PUBG.

PUBG is just a carbon copy shitty 3rd person perspective shooter that wont even last to get out of alpha.

While I think Rust has a long ways to go, if you really are just looking for a PVP with guns experience, go back to CS:GO or COD. The guns play perfect each and every time.

1
dalcoOP•

So you think it's a coincidence that since PUBG released, Rust has lost 20% of its playerbase? I would say more people are playing Rust for PvP than for not. Look at the "lmao roleplayers" mentality on this subreddit.

http://steamcharts.com/cmp/252490,578080#All

2
c64person•

facepalm

Stop cherry picking. Every year Rust loses around 20% of its player base, as does any established game. Something something about finals, and vacations. Weird concept.

2
AvgHeightForATree•

Sigh. Okay, let's wrap this up easily for you as you seem to be struggling:

  • Tennis is PVP
  • Mario Kart is PVP
  • Pong on the Atari is PVP

Any game that sets one player against another is PVP. You don't need weapons for it to be PVP.

With that out of the way, I played Rust because it was fun. I don't play PUBG because it looks identical to H1Z1 and is made by a developer with a dreadful track record for player money gouging and never evolving their games. They just make a shell copy of better titles and crank it out for cash.

Why is pre-ordering different from Rust skins? You genuinely asking that mate? They're charging $40 for an infinite battle royale game mode and 5 skins, not to mention it's a pre-order that will almost definitely never be released, based on developer track record. You think that's the same as a huge skin market for a cheap Alpha game that gets updated every week? Wot?

Rust is probably in its worst state since XP and it's still doing 'Rust' better than this cash grab.

0†
dalcoOP•

Sigh. Okay, let's wrap this up easily for you as you seem to be struggling:

Annnnd I didn't read anything past that. No need to be a taint m8

3
AvgHeightForATree•

Annnnd I didn't read anything

Definitely struggling. Glad we got this all wrapped up for you.

1
Hanzo_Hanz•

Dude why, I was with you so for so long until you posted this chessy passive aggressive response. Please stay level headed I was actually enjoying my time reading through your debates. I like your reasons you've posted for PUBG! Been meaning to try it out

1
LiamColeE•

There is no PvP out there like rust, a fight in ping or any other fps doesn't provide nearly as much thrill, excitement or anger as a fight in rust, additionally, rust takes hundreds of hours to git gud at, where as pubg was fairly easy, skill carried over from other games do to the simple easy to control gun mechanics, no RNG bullcrap that makes rust so Rusty and perfect

Edit: another large factor in differentiating these games is return to battle, if I die, I can immediately run back out to restore my gear by killing whoever killed me, creating large rivalries, which creates an experience you will never get in a game by game system like pubg.

3
dalcoOP•

That's true, the community and relationships are a large part of what makes Rust its own game. I think Facepunch knows this, hence all the inclusion of things like vending machines and mailboxes lately. Do you think Rust needs any PvE content at all?

1
LiamColeE•

No, PVE is useless imo. People are good at killing people. I would like to see more event like the helicopter.

1
wornoutwasd•

Pve events are great catalyst for Pvp.

1
dalcoOP•

You are literally arguing with me in another thread about how the air drop is not a PvP event, yet you agree that PvE events like air drops spur PvP. Lmao dude get real

0
Pczilla•

they are two completely different games. pubg is pretty much a game mode you can play for a bit and that's it. Rust is a game that takes a lot of time and is much more exciting and has the fear of losing your shit in a raid and the stuff you worked for. Rust is much more exciting and rewarding.

2
Mcslapchop•

Not even the same type of game lol.

2
dustwetsuit•

yes

2
Morganstanley84•

i play both. i play rust to pvp. Id rather farm in rust than play pubg. rust is better in every single way in my mind

1
dalcoOP•

So is Rust the pinnacle of PvP to you?

2
Morganstanley84•

absolutely. best pvp in any game every made. i like the idea of pubg but the environment is garbage and the shotguns are a joke. plus 3rd person is trash

1
dalcoOP•

best pvp in any game every made.

Oh comeon.

3
Morganstanley84•

what better

0
dustwetsuit•

I think I dislocated a shoulder reading this

1
CvdZwan_NL•

I play both, enjoy them both.

I am also a solo player having lots of fun with the current state of rust. I probally lose interest in Rust if it becomes more casual... but that's just me...

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
dalcoOP•

Strong words

2