r/truegaming•
dalco

Will survival games like Rust eventually be replaced with games like PUBG?

Cross posted this from r/playrust - where it is not going over too well, haha. I got to spend some time with PlayerUnknown Battleground's recently and it got me thinking about Rust and it's development path.

PUBG is the arena shooter developed by Brendan Greene, the same mind behind the ARMA game mode and H1Z1's use of battleground. And I think that by looking at what PUBG does right, we can see where Rust has gone off the rails (in my opinion) in its development.

There are a lot of similarities in Rust and PUBG (in my opinion), but for conversation's sake I want to focus on a major differentiating factor between the two games: Base building.

In typical survival games like Rust, base building facilitate's survival by granting protection from the elements, a place to gather resources, and a haven to "tech up." PUBG eliminates this system altogether and focuses specifically on PvP. Rust subverts this system by allowing other players to raid your base and implementing sleepers, which ultimately means that a base = / = safety. The end result of both these approaches is that mechanics of both games lead towards PvP encounters.

Losing these encounters carries penalties in both games (loss of gear to other players, permadeath, ect), however with PUBG you can easily join a new game and get right back into the action. With Rust, you have to respawn at a bag/base and the encounter is over. If you aren't rich you need to grind components in order to remake the gear you lost, and it might be several hours before a new encounter.

Now, I think there is something of value in Rust's approach. The slow burn with high-intensity gunfights sets a pace that is unique only to Rust. Plus, an interesting community rife with politics tends to rise up on populated servers. However, there are drawbacks to this system (zergs, offline raiding, high learning curve) that make the game largely inaccessible to anyone who plays survival games for reasons beyond PvP. Anecdotally, I have tried to get several friends into the game - they all ragequit after their base invariably gets raided and ruined after a few days. Generally speaking, these friends are fans of the survival genre and enjoy the base-building in Rust but aren't huge on the PvP or the penalty death carries.

(Now, I know that seems like an oxymoron - as most survival games carry a death penalty. How can you be a fan of the survival genre yet criticize the death penalty in Rust? Well, dying in most survival games is the result of actions by the player. Rust is one of the only games where you can die through nearly no fault of your own - and when you are offline to boot. This feels unfair to many more casual players of the genre.)

I know this has been a long post, it seems to me that if we are playing Rust/DayZ/H1Z1 PURELY for PvP, then PUBG will be the natural progression for many players to jump to. It offers high intensity action and traditional survival mechanics without the commitment or penalties that come with playing through a server wipe in Rust. I think we saw a similar phenomenon with H1Z1, its battlegrounds mode is more popular than the actual game, AFAIK. It cuts out all of the fat and puts players in the action.

So, my question to r/truegaming: Is the survival base-building PvP genre (games like DayZ, H1Z1, Rust) stand at risk of dying and being replaced by round-based PvP with survival elements? And if not, why do you think so? Please note I did not include ARK in this discussion due to the game's robust PvE system.

Posted May 15, 2017, 6:33 PM UTC

18760
Loading comments…