Would love some feedback and thoughts on my story

Self Promotion

I've been reading Naruto fanfic for a while now and it seemed that it was time I wrote my own. Seeing that other people get amazing feedback I thought it would be cool to get some too from seasoned writers and readers.

linkffn(12424068)

Posted May 16, 2017, 5:15 PM UTC · edited

66
Shredjeep5•

You could shorten down the summary. For instance, saying "the ninja village of the Land of Water, Kirigakure," is kinda redundant.

You could shorten the first sentence to say, "Kiri has fought against the allied forces of Suna and Konoha for months."

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
zuemanOPSage is a great fic•

Thanks! I also thought the summary had too many words in it. Didn't know how to fix it without sounding to vague but I think its better now.

Kirigakure has fought against Konohagakure and their ally Suna. After a devastating attack against Kiri forces The Second Mizukage made a desperate attempt. He assembled a task force that had the elite of the elite. Team Shintaro is part of such task force and these are the trials the team faced at the front lines.

1
ikacer•

Four points:

  1. Some sentences are disordered. For example "An arm broke while the kick connected to his chest" should begin with the kick connecting before saying the arm broke. See here in the section titled "Dammit, Jim, I'm A Writer, Not A Logistician". Also many sentences can be shortened, e.g. "It was clear that whoever was in the dome had got reinforcements" cut out the "it was clear that", and "The sound of metal against metal broke through the trees and reached Taiga's ears" cut out "and reached Taiga's ears."

  2. You drift between third person limited and third person omniscient. Stick with third person limited. This means sentences like "The sound of bone on bone was heard throughout the forest" should be changed because Taiga doesn't experience it being heard throughout the forest. Make it something like "The sound of bone on bone rang through the forest." Everything should be what Taiga (the viewpoint character) experiences or an expression of Taiga's understanding of the situation. Also, only switch between viewpoint characters on scene breaks, never within a single scene (you waffle between Taiga and Akita at one point in chapter two).

  3. Remember to always use the active voice and to "show, don't tell." You generally do this OK, but at some points drift into telling instead of showing, e.g. "The boy for his part was in what could only be described as hell..." and "Another groan was emitted."

  4. More variation in paragraph length can help control pacing and give emphasis. Take a look at any very well written story and just observe the paragraph length. For example here. Notice there is far more variation. Short paragraphs can emphasize something important. Longer paragraphs slow things down.

3
zuemanOPSage is a great fic•

Thanks a bunch, this is really helpful. I see what you mean with your first and third point. Thanks for the link in the first point, it really helped. Although to be honest showing is so much harder than I thought at first, I'll try to better that aspect of my writing.

Your fourth point was also very helpful. I never noticed how the paragraph length could affect how the story flowed. What I always thought was that the paragraph consisted of similar ideas put together in a coherent manner, it didn't matter how long or short it was, moderately speaking of course. I'll try to mind my paragraph length from now on.

As for your second point, I understand what you are saying but it'll take me some time to get it right. I guess practice makes perfect. Although, I do have a question concerning what you said about changing view point. A scene break makes sense, at least to me, when the characters are very far apart or experiencing something different. If you could tell me why you thought introducing Taiga in that manner was wrong? I'm assuming that you are talking when she blocked the kunai meant for Akita. To me it seemed to flow smoothly so I did not think to introduce a scene break.

Again thanks for the feedback and thanks for reading my fic.

1
ikacer•

The post by Jim Butcher that I linked talks of mental speedbumps. It also says:

When you head into a third person story, you have to be sure to be extra careful about establishing characters and their goals, in order to help the reader keep the various POVs straight in his head. Often writers also have trouble keeping the current viewpoint clear to the reader--and some of them even jump back and forth to various viewpoints within the same scene, chapter, or page, a guaranteed mental speedbump for the reader as he tries to puzzle out whose head the story is in right now.

Your second chapter goes from Taiga to Akita then back to Taiga all in one scene. It knocked me out of the story while I was reading.

It isn't so much the effort on the reader's part of reorienting on the new viewpoint character that does the harm (though that does take some effort on the reader's part). Note that even with scene breaks there the reader would still have to reorient. Instead it is the knowledge that unexpected POV changes can occur that harms the reading experience. After the first POV change I spent effort on every paragraph after that evaluating whose head I was in instead of just experiencing the story.

This is why one POV per scene is the way to go.


As a semi-related issue that I didn't mention in my first post, if you haven't already, you should probably put some thought into whose POV the story should be told in.

Most likely your story should have just one primary POV (the hero), with (optionally) only the occasional aside into someone else's POV in order to show reaction to events involving the protagonist.

Multiple primary POVs can work, but only for certain types of stories. Generally only for when the story is about an event and not about the hero.

For example a love story might be about how a couple falls in love and could have two primary POVs.

A heist story (like Ocean's Eleven) is about the heist itself and will have many primary POVs showing how all the parts fit together. Because the story is about the event and not about a hero.

In Naruto fanfiction a common failing is to have way too many POV characters instead of sticking to just one. This makes the reader lose interest.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
FanfictionBotBLEEP BLOOP•

Team Shintaro by Zueman

The ninja village of the Land of Water, Kirigakure, has fought against Konohagakure and their ally Sunagakure for months. After a devastating attack against Kirigakure forces The Second Mizukage made a desperate attempt. He assembled a task force that had the elite of the elite. Team Shintaro is part of such task force and these are the trials the team faced at the front lines.

^(Site: [fanfiction.net][140478279304248:site] | Category: Naruto | Rated: Fiction T | Chapters: 3 | Words: 6,749 | Reviews: 1 | Favs: 1 | Follows: 2 | Updated: 23h | Published: 3/28 | id: 12424068 | Language: English | Genre: Adventure/Drama | Characters: OC | Download: [EPUB][140478279304248:epub] or [MOBI][140478279304248:mobi]) [140478279304248:site]: http://www.fanfiction.net/ [140478279304248:epub]: http://www.ff2ebook.com/old/ffn-bot/index.php?id=12424068&source=ff&filetype=epub [140478279304248:mobi]: http://www.ff2ebook.com/old/ffn-bot/index.php?id=12424068&source=ff&filetype=mobi


FanfictionBot^(1.4.0) | [[Usage][1]] | [[Changelog][2]] | [[Issues][3]] | [[GitHub][4]] | [[Contact][5]] [1]: https://github.com/tusing/reddit-ffn-bot/wiki/Usage "How to use the bot" [2]: https://github.com/tusing/reddit-ffn-bot/wiki/Changelog "What changed until now" [3]: https://github.com/tusing/reddit-ffn-bot/issues/ "Bugs? Suggestions? Enter them here!" [4]: https://github.com/tusing/reddit-ffn-bot/ "Fork me on GitHub" [5]: https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=tusing "The maintainer"

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ffnbot!ignore

^(New in this version: Slim recommendations using ffnbot!slim! Thread recommendations using linksub(thread_id)^)!

1