A theory about the entire plot to the series and a potential ending. [Spoilers]
The Fixed timeline theory
As the title suggest this post will have spoilers pertaining to the series finale. So if you do not want to know stop reading. This is also a mammoth of a post because I wanted to make sure I gave enough reasoning as to why this is a good theory, and why there is another possible ending. I have a TLDR on the bottom that sums it up, but hats off to anyone who wants to have a bit of a read.
Firstly let me start by saying I've loved season 5 and the series as a whole and the final episode left a lot of unanswered questions.
Now when it comes to time travel in fiction you need to figure out which rules the author is going to use. If it's multiverse theory, Ashi creates a split in time and there is the peaceful timeline and the Aku timeline. Or then there's the version where changing the past completely annihilates the future leaving thousands of unanswered questions and an unresolved paradox regarding why Jack was allowed to remain in his own timeline.
For this theory I'm going with a singular fixed timeline. It's a theory I always thought of as a potential ending to Samurai jack, and because of how the final episode played out I had decided to write this up knowing what we know in the final cannon. So let me go over some points in the theory before I elaborate.
-Jack already destroyed Aku, and Aku knew about it
-Aku returns at some point and defeats Jack
-Jack uses the guardians time portal to travel to the future, not the past
So keeping in mind that a fixed timeline has to follow rules. Basically Akus future is set in stone. All Prophecies come to pass and while certain key events can be left to speculation, they ultimately lead to the same place. There are no paradoxes, which is why I have another theory about why Ashi really died.
How could Aku survive?
Basically my theory on this one comes from the aftermath. Ashi very suddenly collapses after Aku is destroyed and says "I felt him leave me". This suggests that the part of Aku that created Ashi, and allowed Aku to control her escapes without either of them knowing.
This would also explain why Ashi actually died. When Ashi says "Without Aku, I would have never existed" Perhaps she is actually referring to Aku's magical essense, not the paradox trying to resolve itself.
This also explains why Jack does not vanish as well
(No really that needs to be addressed because if the cannon reason for Ashi dying is a time paradox, then that means Ashi never exists to help the Samurai return to the past, and his presence is a paradox that needs to be resolved as well. Which would mean they never returned to the past to destroy Aku, and Aku is able to create his future, which would put the Samurai in a paradoxical time loop that ultimately ends his own existence for all eternity. But that's boring to think about.)
It stands to reason that because this piece of Aku is from the future, it will have knowledge of everything that transpired up until Jack and Ashi travelled back in time. Basically it's a forced loop, and while in most stories the characters unknowingly close the loop, in this case Aku would be have to go through painstaking measures to make sure the loop closed.
What does Aku stand to gain from this?
Once the Samurai returns to the past, the one weapon that can destroy him in the future is gone, and Aku can finally rule unopposed. Heck this would even give better reasoning as to why Ashi suddenly gained control of her powers. Rather than some "Power of love" Deus Ex Machina stuff that gets down right cringy. Ashi would have been simply allowed to do this so that Aku could tie off the end of the time loop.
Additionally Aku has always been at a major disadvantage against the Samurai, and giving up his only sure way of achieving victory would be suicide.
How does Aku defeat the Samurai in the past?
If the piece of Aku that came back has a complete knowledge of thousands of years worth of events, it would know everything that Jack is gonna do before he does it. Aku would have all knowledge of their fights, and all the steps he is required to take to ensure he beats the Samurai in the past and then goes on to secure his final Victory in the future. Aku being as arrogant as he his would probably even tell the Samurai that he knows every move he is going to make before he makes it. In the end Jack would realize he cannot defeat Aku and perhaps even realize that the course of time was unable to be changed.
This also means that Aku did nothing but screw with Jack the entire time he was in the future. Aku would know where he needed to be to make sure Jack didn't get back. He would have had a set script he needed to follow, and ultimately it explains why Aku gave up so many chances to kill Samurai jack across the entire series.
Why is there no record of any of this?
As they say, History is written by the victors. Simply put, there is no record of anything that transpired after Jack was sent into the future. And if Aku ultimately defeats Jack in the past, he is free to erase all history pertaining to what actually happened.
Even when Jack discovers the ruins of his home in the future, there is no context as to what happened or when it happened and the entire episode was just about jack getting nostalgic.
Jack only becomes known in the future due to his exploits, and the only one to know anything of Jacks past is the Ancient monk (S03Ep10) who was only a child during the events of the past, and only says that Aku eventually came for them. He also assumed that Jack has lived for thousands of years through chi. This suggests that Jack never revealed he was sent to the future.
How can Jack defeat Aku?
Welp this is where that critical unresolved plot point that had us writhing for last 11 weeks (Or more accurately since April 26 2003 with the airing of S03EP06) comes in. The Guardians time portal. It was Prophecy that he would use it. He is seen as an older man and perhaps what the Guardian was looking at was the other side of the portal in the past, not the future.
This is backed up by the fact that Samurai Jack could not age in the future because of Akus magic, but no doubt would be able to age back in his own time.
Knowing full well Aku has the playbook for the next thousand years, it would make sense that the only time Jack could truly defeat Aku, would be in the future after Ashi and him went back.
This means Jack would have to have hid from Aku until that moment. Armed with the knowledge that Aku does not know the events from that point onward, he could defeat Aku once and for all without Aku having the precognition to escape. If Aku had any idea that Jack would go after him in the future, Jacks plan would not work.
There is also a 50 year time period unaccounted for and frankly anything could have happened. But the end result is that the portal was destroyed and the Guardian was unaccounted for aside from a broken pair of glasses.
What else supports this theory
-The transition between Akus dialog line in S1Ep1 and what he says after Jack and Ashi return in S5Ep10 is seamless. Despite being reanimated, it gives weight to the idea that this is a fixed timeline.
-The first fight Aku has with the Samurai is completely one sided, and the fight Aku has with Jacks father while epic also results in a similar defeat. This version of Aku has no knowledge of the future and was unable to escape defeat.
-Despite countless fights in the future, Aku escapes every time, no matter what happens.
-Aku refuses to kill Samurai Jack in the future to ensure the timeline stays accurate. There are many prominent examples of this.
S1Ep06 (Jack and the warrior woman): Aku under the guise of Ikra, saves Jacks from quicksand. (This example is especially relevant)
S1Ep09 (Jack under the sea): He gives the Triceraquin more than enough time to save Jack by trying to just slowly drown him.
S1Ep12 (Jack and the Gangsters): Jack is knocked unconscious in front of Aku. And then only told what happened no visual. (I like to think the mobsters were given the jewel as payment for keeping Aku's secret)
S2Ep09 (Jack vs the 5 hunters) : Jack is defeated by the hunters and despite being dumped in the same city, does not pursue him.
S3Ep04 (Jack and the zombies) : Jacks sword is stolen yet Aku insists on using it to try and kill him despite it not working.
S3Ep08 (Jack and the swamp Wizard) : Disguised once again Aku does not take advantage of the many chances he has to kill Jack.
S4Ep09 (Jack vs Aku): Despite having numerous chances to go back on the agreementl and use his full powers he fights jack without his sword and does not choose to simply kill him.
S501-07: Jack does not have the sword for 50 years, Aku never once pursues him or even bothers to check up on him.
S509 : Stops Ashi from killing Jack.
S510: Stalls on killing Jack once again giving people time to save him.
-Aku only ever intervenes when Jack finds a path back to the past he can easily use and does not when something else will prevent Jack. Once again examples.
S1ep04 (Jack and the warrior woman): Disguises himself to make sure he has a chance to destroy the jewel of the oasis. Even goes as far as to defeat the guardian of the jewel himself.
S1Ep07 (Jack and the 3 blind archers): Does not intervene despite the fact Jack has the chance to use the magical well while accepting the consequences.
S2Ep01 (Jack learns to jump good): Appears just in time to stop Jack using a time portal, and even leaves the portal active only to presumably destroy it later after Jack learns to jump good.
S2Ep02(Jack tales): Jack finds a magical wish granting fairy and does not use her wish to return to the past. Despite it being another close call Aku does not intervene.
S2Ep07(Jack and the monks): Once again another time portal that gets destroyed by Aku just before he has a chance to use it.
S3Ep06(Jack and the travelling creatures): Despite finding the Guardians time portal, Aku does not intervene and instead lets Jack get defeated by the guardian.
S3Ep10(Jack, the monks, and the Ancient masters son): Once again Jack gets inches from a time portal but does not take it because he wants to save his friends. Aku does not intervene.
S3Ep13(Jack and the labyrinth): Jack breaks into one of Akus secure vaults and gets his hands on a mystical jewel with the potential to return him to the past. The jewel is destroyed and once again Aku is nowhere to be found.
S4Ep04 (The Aku infection): Jack finds a portal but is plagued by an illness set upon by Aku. Jack himself destroys the portal, Aku is nowhere in sight but slightly prominent in this case.
S5Ep07: Jack finds the last remaining time portal, is halfway through it before being dragged back by Aku.
Note: Realistically all these examples I've given can be summarized as
"If jack dies or makes it back to the past the series would end and obviously the creators had no intention of doing that. Duh"
But for the sake the fun I'm having with this theory we're going to ignore reality and pretend it's all connected.
The Possible ending
After Jack and Ashi return to the past. Aku says "Oh no" But then adds "Now who will stop me".
He basically looks to destroy the Samurai's allies, but before he can, he is attacked by an unknown figure with a sword.
The figure is Jack, who has aged substantially since we last saw him. Having used the Guardians time Portal to travel to the future, he had been lying in wait for his moment to defeat Aku once and for all. After having used the portal the guardian destroys it using explosives, the explosion knocks his glasses off and the Guardian leaves, never to be seen again.
A very one sided fight with Aku occurs much like the first time they fought, given Aku has no idea what the Samurai is going to do and cannot counter him.
Jack destroys Aku once and for all, saving the future from Akus wrath and fully wrapping up the story in a nice neat bundle with a bittersweet ending.
Cue montage of all Jacks Allies going on to live happily ever after with the final frame being a statue of his grave in the future.
Ashi remains dead but is also given a memorial.
TLDR: This theory suggests that the essence which is used to create Ashi allows Aku to resurrect in the past with full comprehensive knowledge of thousands of years of events. Armed with this knowledge he defeats the Samurai in the past and claims dominion over the world.
Aku proceeds to perform the longest written play over thousands of years making sure Jack survives in the future and stays in the future long enough to make sure his essence is sent back with Ashi and the loop is closed, allowing him to achieve victory in the past as well.
After beating Jack in the past he does the typical evil thing of gloating about how he did it, forcing jack to abandon the past and use the Guardians portal to travel to the future instead. Resolving the prophecy of how Jack used the portal.
Disclaimer:
Feel free to rip into this theory. But remember not to take this too seriously. Theories are just that, Theories.
Also if there are any content creators out there who may enjoy this theory enough to use it as a base for something artistic feel free to do so, I ask for no credit when it comes to posting a last ditch effort to keep my childhood alive before it dies forever fun take on the Series's plot.
Posted May 22, 2017, 4:48 AM UTC
If that is true, Aku is truly the Master of Masters.