r/ProjectFi•
kyt

Fi no longer working on unsupported devices?

While I'm on a temp phone (new pixel on the way) I got a message today that my service was paused and I'm not able to resume it. I've tried clearing the fi app and reactivating, but once you reactivate it will error out saying the device is not supported. Things on wifi work, but I'm not able to sms or use the phone. Is Google now killing fi accounts that aren't on official phones?

Posted May 22, 2017, 8:45 PM UTC

311
conepet•

Activation must be done on an approved device (Nexus or Pixel). I don't know why your service was paused, but it sounds like your later issues are related to you clearing the app data.

4
kytOP•

Activation must be done on an approved device (Nexus or Pixel)

You're right, I didn't really think of that before going through the steps. I'm just not sure if this service pausing was a deliberate thing by google or some kind of bug. I googled it and it seems like there was some other people who had this issue:

https://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/project-fi/8wamT8jVqb8

Sounds like it was solved for some people but not for everyone.

1
citypandaNexus 6P•

Try turning it back on from fi.google.com.

1
kytOP•

I did. It didn't work either.

1
Scanner7609•

First post in that thread was dated 11/23/15, but earlier this year I was using Fi on my LG G5 (Nexus 5X bootloop replacement) for over a month without issue. Maybe it doesn't affect all users of a non-supported phone.

1
_gst_•

I've tried clearing the fi app and reactivating, but once you reactivate it will error out saying the device is not supported.

Did you try to reactivate on a supported or a non-supported device?

1
wereunstumpable•

Yes, it's been discussed here a few times regardless what is claimed. This happened to me when i took sim out of my pixel to return it, and into an unsupported phone. I had to reactivate on my nexus 5x. I understand not supporting other phones, but actively pausing service is user hostile and a reason i've decided to move on for now.

0†
Burnaway420•

It's hard to say it's hostile when it was what you agreed to when you signed up for the service. It's in the terms of service that you can get your Google account terminated for not owning an eligible device. You removed the eligible device from your account of course you can't continue to use it without an eligible device activated on your account.

Other users bought a 5x activated fi and sold their 5x in the semi locked state preventing users from being able to use the phone on certain networks. That is also not ok.

If you want other devices and tmobile only there are better options out there than fi.

5
wereunstumpable•

I understand that - it's well within their rights as a company. But what about the users who have a failing device who cannot find a pixel, or worse, can't afford one? Should they be punted off the service without warning? I don't think it's out of line to call automated pausing of service 'user hostile'...but we may disagree on that meaning.

I like Fi. It's great for my needs even on tmobile only. The roaming alone is worth every penny.

3
kytOP•

. But what about the users who have a failing device who cannot find a pixel, or worse, can't afford one? Should they be punted off the service without warning?

This was my exact situation. Why go for round 2 on a Nexus 6p when by all accounts the issue STILL exists? I was actually looking for a pixel, but those have not been in stock for weeks. I thought I was fine limping along on a moto until the Pixel 2 came out but then I got paused without warning. If I would have known that would happen, I probably would have just bit the bullet on a PXL sooner.

I'm with you, I like fi. The service and support have been really good but this recent situation really irked me.

1
kytOP•

Yeah it's a bummer.

1