r/thinkpad•
ojolulu

Trackpoint's click lock issue on disabled touchpad in T450s linux

As a trackpoint user, I always disable the touchpad on my thinkpad. In Thinkpad T450s, there is a bios setting to disable touchpad/trackpad, however it only works for Windows OS. In linux, the bios setting is ignored (I wonder why). So I have to disable the touchpad from the linux os itself.

In linux mint cinnamon/mate v18, I have disabled the touchpad through the mouse setting. It seems working at glance, but then I found strange behavior where if I click the left trackpoint button, it sometimes register the left click as "holding the left button" (the behavior is also known as "Click Lock" in Windows). If you move the pointer afterwards, it will perform a drag movement.

I found out what triggered the click lock is the touchpad. It's because my palm is touching the touchpad and it somehow triggers the click lock.

After some testing, I found out how to make the issue occurs frequently:

(make sure the touchpad has been disabled first)

  1. Place your two fingers on the touchpad (it doesn't matter whether your fingers are tapping or clicking the clickpad)

  2. Open a terminal window (or any windows you want as long as it has title bar)

  3. Hover the cursor on the title bar, click trackpoint's left button once (don't hold it), then move the trackpoint's pointer. You have to do this while your another two fingers are on the touchpad as described in the step #1.

If the click lock get triggered on the left button click, you would see a drag movement on the terminal window. If it doesn't happen, repeat again the left click.

I think the touchpad is still generating some signals when touched even when it's been disabled.

So anyone ever meet this issue too? In windows OS, I can confirm the problem doesn't occur. I have tried other linux distro like ubuntu, fedora, opensuse, manjaro, gentoo, puppy linux with other DE (like kde, xfce), I still get same issue. In older thinkpad like T430 or X230, it doesn't have this issue. The issue might happen on same generation models like X250 or T450, and probably the newer generation too as they use same design of the clickpad.

With the click lock behaviour issue, I can't really use the trackpoint properly on linux. Anyone know a solution for this?

Posted May 28, 2017, 3:23 PM UTC · edited

12
enbits•

I can confirm this is happening same configuration as yours. I'll let you know if I find a solution.

2
ojoluluOP•

I found out it's a kernel issue. Upgrading to kernel v4.12 would solve the issue.

2
jlward4th•

Upgrading to kernel 4.12 rc6 did not solve this for me. Where did you find it is a kernel issue?

1
ojoluluOP•

I found it from here: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1313939

It did work on fedora as I tried. Maybe the fix is specific to fedora/RH only.

1