r/thinkpad•
ojolulu

[Replacing laptop screen] How to avoid brightness control issue?

I plan to replace my damaged T450s screen. The original screen model type is LP140WF3-SPD1 (LG brand, FHD IPS anti-glare non-touch). There is alternative AUO screen supported but I prefer the LG because the AUO tends to have backlight bleeding as some people said.

I heard about issue about brightness control doesn't work in Windows after replacing screen on lenovo laptops. I read it's because of there is whitelisting in the bios.

In order to avoid the brightness issue, should I order LP140WF3-SPD1 screen directly from lenovo? or can I just order from any sellers (like from ebay or aliexpress) as long as it is same LP140WF3-SPD1 model?

Update:

I heard there is a thing called lenovo FRU number for the machine parts, like for the LP140WF3-SPD1 screen on T450s, the FRU is 04X5916. So I wonder could that mean there are two type of LP140WF3-SPD1 out there?

  1. LP140WF3-SPD1 with lenovo FRU = 04X5916
  2. LP140WF3-SPD1 without lenovo FRU

So the one with lenovo FRU is the only one that is approved in the whitelist thus won't cause brightness control issue ? Am I right or wrong about this?

Posted May 31, 2017, 4:28 PM UTC · edited

40
ojoluluOP•

After some researches, I found out the bios whitelisting is based on the panel EDID, not the FRU. The FRU written on the panel sticker itself can't guarantee the panel is authentic lenovo panel as the sticker can be faked, as well as the EDID too, it can be modified in eeprom.

I ended up three times buying fake or non-authentic panel where the sellers claimed it's the LP140WF3-SPD1 panel, but when checked with hwinfo the panel id is not LP140WF3-SPD1.

I just about to give up until I tried the panel EDID overwrite with edid-rw script. The two panels I bought from china have its eeprom write-protected so the EDID can't be modified, but luckily the one I bought from UK is not write-protected.

I dumped the original panel's EDID into BIN file (you can do this with edid-rw or Monitor Asset Management), then I replaced the manufacturer data (byte 8-11 on the EDID BIN file) with the original panel's manufacturer data. I rewrited the replacement panel's EDID with the modified BIN using edid-rw, but the brightness control is still not working. Then I did full rewrite of the replacement panel's EDID with the original panel's EDID, and voila, the brightness control is working now. So it seems the bios whitelisting is based on the full EDID data (128 bytes) rather than some bytes of the EDID.

It's fortunate that I got a non write-protected panel but the experience still sucks, I wasted a lot of time and money dealing with this issue.

1
HugsNotDrugs_•

Thanks for this. I wondered if the EDID override now available through Intel graphics drivers was capable of getting past the brightness issue, but if the full EDID data is checked then perhaps not.

1
ojoluluOP•

I have tried some EDID override guides, but nothing works. Intel itself doesn't release any documentation at all, at best they only said it's possible but doesn't explain the how-to for plain users.

1