Why I am somewhat worried with 4.0 Summoner changes.
Hello!
I've seen plenty of talk about Summoner, and it's relative effectiveness, the changes, and what-have-you in 4.0. I'd like to start off by quickly saying I'm not going to mention potency, numbers, nerfs, buffs or anything of the sort - to me, those are numerical things and easily fixed. More importantly, I don't think I personally care - I play a class because it's fun. And this is where I will start off.
Simply put, I don't think 4.0 summoner looks fun. I'm going to split this into 2 general parts, pre-70 and at-70 summoner, and why I think both are lacking.
The easy start is pre-70 summoner - before we go on, I'm going to generally refer to things without quoting, I'm getting it all from u/haisquared 's piece, which I will link at the end. So, going in order, Bane is much weaker, one less DoT to maintain (Bio), no Bahamut, weaker Ruin III, less GCDs (Miasma II, Bio, Shadowflare, Blizzard II), no Spur. To me... That looks awful. It's just Ruin spam at Lv.50 occasionally just refreshing two DoTs and nothing else. No third DoT to maintain, useless AoE, pretty bad single target damage too. At Lv.60, it's not quite as bad - Dreadwyrm Trance is still a thing, but again, just mechanics removed for no real gain, less global cooldowns to use, so back to just... spamming ruin with no thought into it. Again - less interesting. Less fun. Nothing has been added to past content, just removed. Level 1-52 is going to be an utter snooze, 52-6X is going to be a lot less involved.
Why is past content important? Well, it's still a big part of the game, it's still going to need to be passed for new players - and super importantly - it's still there. If you ever want to revisit The Lost City of Amdapor just to remind yourself what it was like, you're going to need to play a Lv.50 class. Even if the new skills make up for the loss of earlier stuff, you get the new skills later - earlier stuff being simple happens earlier. Obviously. Making the class simpler makes the class simpler no other way to cut it. Even if the post 60 changes make up for the simplification of earlier things, even if the raids and mechanics at 70 are so much more complex that rotations need to be super simple, most of the game is not level 70.
Moving on, at-70 summoner. I'm not going to profess to know what it's going to be like exactly, no one can. But, just look at the example rotation given by Hai Hai:
0s Ruin 2 Tri-Disaster + Painflare 2.5s Ruin 2 Fester + Energy Drain 5s Ruin 2 Swiftcast + Aetherpact + Dreadwyrm Trance 7.5s Ruin 3 Enkindle 10s Ruin 3 12.5s Ruin 3 15s Ruin 3 17.5s Ruin 3 20s Ruin 2 Tri-Disaster + Deathflare 22.5s Ruin 2 Aetherflow + Painflare 25s Ruin 2 Energy Drain + Fester 27.5s Ruin 2 Dreadwyrm Trance 30s Ruin 3 32.5s Ruin 3 35s Ruin 3 37.5s Ruin 3 40s Ruin 3 42.5s Ruin 2 Deathflare + Summon Bahamut 50s Ruin 2 Enkindle Bahamut
For most of that... you're pressing two buttons. Is that... fun? Not to me. I think it looks mind bogglingly boring. Even Bahamut, the thing that we're to look forward to, just does his own thing, you summon him and keep casting Ruin and now the Ruins cause a secondary effect to just happen. The change to contagion, the new damage/heal buff, they're both now just used off cooldown without any real need to think - hardly something exciting to me. I don't believe the content will be harder to make up for the rotations being simpler, and it would be possible anyway. I think a lot of these changes just make the class less interesting to play overall.
Yes, we save GCDs by not recasting DoTs as much... instead we now just go back to spam-casting Ruin. I don't care if that's more or less potency - it's boring. It's mind numbingly boring. That's really the key to my problem - Summoner becomes a ruin spam class as you watch things just happen. Even the unique aspects that used to be here like Virus, Eye for an Eye and a DPS Resurrect are now no longer unique (Assuming Red Mage does get it's res). Same with the losses to DoTs, it's more interesting a mechanic to have to balance 3 DoTs for maximum potency between your casts and oGCDs - which has again been simplified by the ability to constantly have Tri-Disaster up. Again - not talking potency, or power, just that the new mechanics look boring. Easy. It's just pressing a button, then spamming Ruin.
To sum up, I'm not writing this because I hate Summoner or anything, the opposite, Summoner at 60 is my favourite class far and away - and I'm aware it's not a Summoner only problem. I'm worried that not only am I losing that playstyle for good - the new mechanics that are being introduced are not good either. It's losing my favourite for nothing. If there was some way to snapshot the game as it is right now, and the changes would only affect post-60 content, I wouldn't mind nearly as much, but it feels to me we're losing what Summoner is now to get a less-complex, less-interesting class in return, which only gets what little blossoming it can do post-60. I'd love to be wrong, I really hope come the expansion, it's all actually fine and I look like an idiot for writing all this - and in truth I'm not writing this for any reason in particular. I think a lot of people are focusing on potencies and viabilities and overlooking that some of these changes are beyond numbers. Numbers can be increased easily. Fun can not.
Hai Hai's piece that I so refered to: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1JgRBsdC4ru6LCSep6YhG7LQjCU1dfa1thqLy3yO2N9A
Posted Jun 2, 2017, 9:29 AM UTC