How would non-commodity producing jobs like elder care by compensated for?

I am asking this in the context of a socialist society which replaced money by labor vouchers. There does not seem to be an obvious solution for non-commodity producing jobs. At least I haven't found one.

Posted Jun 7, 2017, 1:26 PM UTC

211
aldo_novaM-L hasta siempre•

A socialist state holding the means of production can do things like adjust prices, set up strict wage payments based on pre-defined skill and hazard levels, etc. A central body can determine that factory work producing a commodity (boots) is skill level III and gets paid $basex3. The same body can determine that elder care workers are more highly skilled and socially necessary, so they are skill level IV, and as such should get paid $basex4.

The LTV is not a thing handed down from God that we have to try to rearrange our whole spheres of production around. Socialist states can intervene and set prices, set wages, set production targets, etc., according to democratically agreed-upon parameters. The WHOLE GOAL is to move away from the sort of slave-to-the-market micro- and macro-economics that you are low-key advocating for.

3

How does this avoid new class conflict between tiers of skill/pay?

2
aldo_novaM-L hasta siempre•

Because income doesn't determine class. That's something pushed by the bourgeoisie in capitalist countries to prevent working class unity. We have to realize that if you make $20 and I make $5, we are both being exploited and you may even be MORE exploited because you are probably getting that $20 because you're making $1,000 for the boss. Marx wrote about this specifically.

Skill-based pay systems, like the one developed by Che, were not exploitative and also had clear (meaning open and not hidden) tracks for people to advance up the skill ladder. It was a socialist system, so advancement to a higher skill level was encouraged and even financed in terms of the state paying for you to get training. This is possible because the whole society benefits from you becoming a highly-skilled worker. In capitalism, you advance yourself so you can out-compete another worker on the job market, by comparison. Your skills only benefit you and your employer, not society as a whole as under socialism.

3

I misused the term class in this context — what I mean to say is social hierarchy.

I want to agree with you that this system prevents the development of of a social hierarchy between tiers of workers compensated significantly more than others, but I don't see it working that way. I guess it's the janitor/doctor argument all over again. Still, if a person can benefit more from being say a scientist than a teacher while still benefiting society then it seems like more people would aim to be a scientist than a teacher, or a doctor than a janitor. I feel like this would create a divide between workers of different tiers based on their perceived worth of each other to society (as is the case today). Regardless of whether a capitalist or all of society is benefiting of your labour I still feel like significant differences in compensation would drive individuals to want higher paying jobs. I understand that general needs would be accommodated for by a socialist state however that doesn't change the fact that there would still be doctors and scientists about to afford more non-essentials and pleasures that teachers and janitors wouldn't.

I'm just not sure how a tiered labour compensation system about avoids the continuation of a social hierarchy based on significant pay gaps, but I want to understand.

1
aldo_novaM-L hasta siempre•

It avoids it because it has a clear route for progression up through the ranks, including social support to get the necessary training, etc.

Also, it is important to remember that in socialist societies like the Soviet Union, the highest paid or most skilled worker only make like 8 times the lowest paid worker. Also, money was not allowed to be used as capital or to exploit your fellow worker, and there was no housing market, so all you could really do with that money was maybe travel a little more or buy more useless consumer goods gadgets or shit for your kids.

That's another way that a socialist wage system prevents the development of antagonisms between high and low paid workers during the transition phase: it limits what you can do (legally) with a hoard of money. This is to prevent that stratification, and also serves to limit the effectiveness of using money as an incentive for work -- toward the eventual goal of removing money entirely as an incentive for work, to be replaced with a genuine interest in developing one's own skills and contributing to the collective. This was always the underlying and guiding principle of all of Che's economic policies, for example.

The dictatorship of the proletariat exists in part to make sure illegal exploitation and use of money as capital is stamped out.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
FkkizeOPSocialist in training•

The LTV states that the value of a commodity is determined by the socially necessary labor time it takes to produce that commodity. But how do we determine the value created by non-commodity producing work?

1
ksan•

Fist of all, services produced and sold in the market are also a commodity. Second, a socialist society is supposed to fight against the coercion of the law of value, not follow it blindly. In this case those taking care of the elderly would be public workers and their compensation would be a result of conscious planning by the ruling class, themselves.

3
FkkizeOPSocialist in training•

services produced and sold in the market are also a commodity

I am aware of that. With non-commodity producing I was referring to jobs that do not create a physical item at the end. It is fairly easy to evaluate the labor content of say a chair as opposed to a service like taking care of the elderly.

a socialist society is supposed to fight against the coercion of the law of value

That's debatable.

In this case those taking care of the elderly would be public workers and their compensation would be a result of conscious planning by the ruling class, themselves

That would mean service jobs do not create value if they have no exchange-value, does it not?

1
ksan•

I am aware of that. With non-commodity producing I was referring to jobs that do not create a physical item at the end. It is fairly easy to evaluate the labor content of say a chair as opposed to a service like taking care of the elderly.

Then you were using scientific terms incorrectly, because they are producing a commodity, which is the service sold, even if it's not a physical object. And no, I'm not completely sure I see how a physical object is easier to measure in value terms than a service. Value is hours of human social labor. Do you think we count atoms to measure the value of a chair?

That's debatable.

Not for Marxists. This is a Marxist forum.

That would mean service jobs do not create value if they have no exchange-value, does it not?

The compensation of miners would work in the same exact way. The fact that a socialist society would still have to deal with the law of value in some ways and for some time affects both miners and people working in elderly care. The only reason to think otherwise is to have a physicalist fetish about commodities, which I think is one of the issues here.

3
aldo_novaM-L hasta siempre•

Value in Marxist terms is separate from Exchange Value. You are using terms that have incredibly specific meaning in a willy-nilly way.

You are also mired in market ideology. Your whole question or claim boils down to how much something is worth in a chaotic market. Socialism strives to eliminate the market wherever possible and organize production (including services) based on need and social value. You are trying to find a "gotcha" by taking Marx's evaluation of capitalism and its categories (commodity, value, price, etc) and force them onto an entirely different relation of production, socialism.

1