Probably more than you wanted to know about Urethane in Bourbon
Abstract Urethane is produced during the process of fermentation and as a result all fermented foods contain some amount of Urethane. We consume this molecule everyday in bread, yogurt, wine, beer and even Bourbon. Urethane is a known carcinogen, but the concentration of Urethane in Bourbon is too low to lead to increased risk of cancer when drinking in moderation. Fearful teetotalers in the 1980s brought attention to the fact that Bourbon contains Urethane. The resulting public concern lead to legal limits placed on Urethane in Bourbon and other fermented spirits. For anything distilled after 1988, there must be less than 125 ppb of Urethane in the Bourbon. Urethane taste cool and bitter, so its reduction in Bourbon may have altered the taste somewhat.
Introduction A while ago I had read that the decrease in Urethane levels in Bourbon may be a contributing factor to changes in taste or mouthfeel over the years, and being a chemist, I was naturally curious about what this molecule was and why its presence in Bourbon would be a concern. In more recent discussion I suggested I could analytically test for the presence of Urethane in Bourbon and that got me digging though past literature and history. It turns out we already know a lot about Urethane!
Urethane, aka Ethyl Carbamate, is a while crystalline powder at room temperature, dissolves pretty easily in water, and has nothing to do with the "polyurethane" that we coat our furniture with. It was historically used in the medical field, ironically to treat different types of cancer, until studies showed that it was carcinogenic to mice, and thereby probably carcinogenic to humans as well. Its medical use in humans was stopped in the 1940s, and in 2007 has been elevated to a "Group 2A" carcinogen.
Historical Perspective Flashback to the 1970s and pretty much no one cares about Urethane, yet the US Food and Drug Administration was quietly instituting regulations to limit the amount of Urethane in food and drink. However, a consumer food safety group, The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI), quickly brought attention to the issue in the mid 1980s, causing a mini panic, which solicited quick response from the US Food and Drug Administration as well as the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms. These governmental agencies proclaimed the outcry to be frightmongering, but public awareness had already surged. Studies were quickly performed on various food and drink and it was found that fermented beverages contained some of the highest ambient levels of Urethane (and yes that includes Bourbon). The CSPI published a book in 1987 titled Tainted Booze: The Consumer's Guide to Urethane in Alcoholic Beverages, detailing their findings.
In 1987-88 the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms conducted a wide ranging analysis of Urethane in alcoholic beverages to quell public concern and restore trust (note that the liquor industry was working with the FDA and the BATF to minimize Urethane levels by this time, a process that was greatly accelerated by the recent exposition). Specifically for Bourbon, 133 samples were analyzed with Urethane levels ranging from 0 to 1719 parts per billion (ppb), with an average content of 184 ppb. Just prior to this Canada had set its own limits on Urethane in Bourbon at 150 ppb, causing CSPI to request the removal of the offending alcoholic products from store shelves in the USA! Fortunately the FDA declined to do so, citing the low risk associated with moderate consumption of Urethane in alcohol. Reflexively, the CSPI requested the raw data from the FDA and the BATF, so that consumers could tell which brands contained the most Urethane, but this information was also not released under protection of the Freedom of Information Act. In the end, the legal limit of Urethane in Whiskey was set at 125 ppb in the USA.
Historical Quantification of Urethane While the FDA and BATF refused to release the bulk of the data on Urethane in alcoholic beverages, some of the information was obtained by the Washington Post which was published in their expose in 1987. They only appear to have published a part of the list of Bourbons that surpassed then Canadian limits on Urethane of 150 ppb. This list is reproduced below to provide a historical context. In modern times Bourbon is routinely checked for Urethane levels to comply with the FDA guidelines. I couldent find this data online at the FDA or BATF website, it is probably hidden to protect the confidentiality of Bourbon producers, however the levels should all be less than 125 ppb for Bourbon distilled after 1988. Note that the 125 ppb Urethane limit was not applied retroactively, and Bourbon that was already being aged at that time was allowed to go to sale at later dates with potentially higher Urethane content.
Bourbons that Contained Elevated Levels of Urethane in 1987-88 The number in parenthesis is the Urethane content in ppb.
- Rebel Yell (152)
- Jenkins Four-Year-Old Blended Whiskey (168)
- Ezra Brooks (2 samples, 161 and 169)
- Jack Daniel's Old No. 7 (15 samples, ranged from 118 to 180)
- McCormick Special Selection (169)
- Old Fitzgerald (175)
- Bourbon Supreme (188)
- Jim Beam (221)
- Old Charter (232)
- Glenmore Bulk (2 samples, 236 and 239)
- Georgia Moon (238)
- Old Taylor Six-Year-Old (4 samples, 246 to 283)
- Old Forester (4 samples, 246 to 310)
- Early Times Old Style (2 samples, 250 and 269)
- Clear Corn Kentucky Corn Whiskey (261)
- Jim Beam Straight Rye (265)
- Colonel's Pride (273)
- Colonel Lee (312)
- Evan Williams (2 samples, 206 and 321)
- Heaven Hill (321)
- Kentucky Gentleman (330)
- Hiram Walker Ten High (339)
- Virginia Gentleman (375)
- Beams Choice Old No. 8 (406)
- Albertson's (2 samples, 517 and 551)
- Kentucky Choice (543)
- Importer's Four-Year-Old (616)
Why is there Urethane in Bourbon? If you have read this far you may be wondering, why does Urethane appear in Bourbon and how the heck do you reduce it in the product? In 1987-88, whiskey producers didnt really know exactly why Urethane existed in Bourbon in such high quantities when compared to something like vodka or wine, but they figured it out pretty quick with pressure from CSPI and the media. Urethane is formed through a couple of different pathways, but the primary one occurs when ethanol (made by yeast) combines with urea (also made by yeast). The reaction of ethanol with urea is accelerated at higher temperature, so distilled products like Bourbon tend to contain more Urethane as opposed to wine, which should not be heated during production. In order to suppress the prevalence of Urethane in Bourbon (and other fermented products) the key strategy relies on suppressing urea production by the yeast/bacteria. Major techniques rely on creating yeast that produce low amounts of urea, or by limiting the precursors of urea from sources such as fertilizer. People actually still sit around and think about this (just like what I am doing right now), and they perform scientific studies and write papers on it. For the truly curious, here is a review on the current field of detecting Urethane in fermented beverages.
Urethane Risk Associated with Drinking Bourbon For those that like dusty or vintage bourbon, there is no need to be worried about consuming too much Urethane. The book Risks of Carcinogenesis from Urethane Exposure by A. G. Salmon and L. Zeise gives a nice summary of elevated cancer risk when consuming an ounce of Bourbon a day with average Urethane content, and the increased exposure is on the order of 10^-5, aka, tiny and nothing to worry about. If you are drinking enough whiskey to reach a risky intake of Urethane, you probably have much greater concerns over your ethanol intake and its immediate effect on your health.
Conclusions So, TLDR, there is less Urethane in Bourbon now than in the past. However, anything distilled before 1987-88 has the potential to have higher amounts of Urethane, legacy products werent prohibited for sale in the USA. The effect on taste or mouthfeel is tenuous though. Urethane has been described as having no odor and a cooling, saline, bitter taste. This actually sounds a bit pickle like, or perhaps menthol or camphor. To really tell we would need to do a SBS tasting of similar bourbons with both high and low Urethane levels. It is interesting to note that some fruit liquors contain greatly elevated levels of Urethane (some reaching 4000 ppb), I personally want to try some just to see if its possible to "taste" the Urethane. As for other types of alcohol, wine has pretty low levels (average 7 to 93 ppb), while beer and distilled spirits like vodka, gin and rum contain none or only trace amounts.
References
Posted Jun 12, 2017, 7:22 AM UTC · edited