Fundulopanchax Gardneri in community tank?

Help/Advice

Just wondering if an F. gardneri would do okay in a community setting. Tank is heavily planted, 15gal, with amano shrimp, several snails, an endler, a paradise gourami, and hopefully a school of Choprae danios. I realize the risk with the paradise gourami but it has proven itself very peaceful (for a paradise) and I don't even know if I will keep it or not, might replace with a honey. pH is around neutral and temp is currently 76 but could be changed. I'm looking at one male or a male and 2-3 females.

Posted Jun 14, 2017, 10:19 PM UTC · edited

214
DreamGirly_•

Your tank is a bit small for a paradise gourami and choprae danios. I think they would both prefer a little more horizontal swimming space, so I would recommend you to either not get the danios or get a 20 long at least. If you want to get different gouramis get sparkling ones, they will do fine in a 15g.

2
NeotenensOP•

I thought honeys would also be okay? And I figured as much on the paradise, I've had plans to go back already. Any thoughts on the killis, anyway?

1
DreamGirly_•

Have you looked them up on seriouslyfish? I dont know if the gardneri would do great in a community setting, seriouslyfish says: 'This is a robust killi that can be kept with other fishes but is not suitable for the general community.'. You would have to look into why that is and if it goes for your tankmates too. I don't know how active they are, if theyre very active 15g is not big enough, if theyre not so active it's fine.

Honey gouramis do have a recommended min tank size of 15g so that seems fine. Theyre also a lot smaller than paradise gourami. Note that you might need to pay attention to any tankmates' feeding habits as the honey gourami is apparently the opposite of an aggressive eater.

Also isn't your one endler a little lonely in there? I dont have any experience with any of these species btw, I recommend you to just do research on all the species. For example, you could have figured the gardneri and community setting out yourself, its just there in the seriously fish article.

2
NeotenensOP•

My endler had conspecifics, but they ended up dying off bit by bit. He seems fine and I'm not exactly interested in more, and they're fairly rare around me so if I tried to rehome him he likely would still be alone. I still enjoy having him, and I doubt he has much left in him anyway as he's about 2 now. As for the honey, it wouldn't be the first I had in the tank, so I assume it will be fine. I tend to get them used to hand feeding anyway. As far as the killis, the whole reason I asked here was that the seriouslyfish page was vague, I usually just trust them. It doesn't even give a tank size, which is odd. I've seen some communities with gardneri but I just wanted to see if anyone here had experience. As for the paradise, I suppose I'll grow him out a bit yet so his colours come in (he's barely 1 inch, just a baby forced upon me by a friend) and find him a new home. I may even have a 29 set up by then so we'll see.

2
jacktownspartan•

As luck would have it, I do have experience with this fish! I kept a pair of gardneri once. For a short period. I'm going to hit on some main things:

  1. UNDER ABSOLUTELY NO CIRCUMSTANCES CAN THE TANK BE UNCOVERED. People will tell you many species of fish are jumpers. Nothing jumps like these things. If you give them the smallest opening, they will find it. I have a cover with some small holes for equipment. The male managed to find it within a night. The female disappeared for a long period before I found her on the floor alive. She lasted another short period before she found a hole. Next time I keep them, and I do hope to again, I'm keeping them in a Fluval setup that is fully enclosed. If you want to keep these guys alive, you can not leave the slightest window for them to kill themselves.

  2. They aren't crazy active. 15 should be more than fine for the fish themselves. Lots of killifish keepers use densely planted 5s and 10s for individual pairs of many species.

  3. I can't attest much for their personalities, but I have seen a vast spectrum of opinions and personal accounts. I had them with Cardinal Tetras and had no issue in that short time. I've seen people who had no problems. I've seen other people who say they were monstrous predators that stalked up on and took chunks out of other fish, both larger and smaller.

2
bekindrewind•

I tried a pair in my 10 gallon and while they did not viciously attack the other small shoaling/schooling fish (they did try to take a bite out of some ramshorns) they scared them all into hiding especially at feeding time when they would become more aggressive. My sparkling gourami hid in a hole and it took him almost a month to come back out after I removed them. I have the killie pair in a 5.5 gallon planted tank by themselves now and they are very happy and breeding. IMO they do best in a species only tank and more of their fry survive that way but whatever you do tight lids are a must! The babies love frozen or live brine shrimp and are thriving on it.

2
NeotenensOP•

Hm, I'll have to see about that, I'm very attached to my snails and anything that bugs them will have to go.

1
bekindrewind•

Yeah it is a shame as I love mts and ramshorns in my tank since they are such good detrivores/cleanup crew. Their tank does get the ocassional ramshorn but they are always moved when I notice them. Snails will also snack on killie eggs so overall not a good combo for either species!

1
NeotenensOP•

I'm not overly concerned about breeding success right now, I could easily set up another tank for them if I felt like breeding them. My concern is for my gigantic nerite who's almost 5 years old. I'm quite attatched to her and anything that shows signs of harming her goes.

1