What's the big-block rush?
I don't understand the rush for big blocks. If one wants >1 MB blocks, wouldn't it be rational to activate Segwit, then watch Segwit-enabled blocks become full, THEN demand a hardfork to larger blocks? The most viable alternative to big-blocks will disappear when Segwit-enabled blocks fill, and big blockers wouldn't have to combat the leading argument against them. Why must it be a matter of Segwit vs Big Block? The latter argument is premature when we have an admittedly short-term and low-risk solution already at hand. Big blockers would be able to argue their case from a much more advantageous position once the opponents are starved of argument of Segwit. Remove the false dichotomy (by activating Segwit on 1mb blocks), and let the chips fall where they may.
Posted Jun 14, 2017, 11:30 PM UTC
It's not a matter of segwit vs. big block. People are for segwit. Some people aren't. Others are against segwit, and even more still don't care one way or the other. Who exactly are you talking to?