M4F - Paradise Lost - A Suburban Nightmare

Paradise Lost - A Suburban Nightmare

It was perfect. A large four bedroom, three and a half bath estate with an in ground pool and mother-inlaw suite in the back. The kind of house that reflected the promotion and raise that Caleb Johnson finally received for all his hard work at the firm. It was the kind of community that didn't list homes for sale, they just sold, quietly by word of mouth. You had to know somebody, and Caleb knew a lot of people.

"It's perfect for you and the family, no through traffic, quiet street, very exclusive, not to mention it sits on the 18th green!" His wife loved it, it wasn't a choice for Caleb, they had to get it, no matter the financial burden that would come along with it. "We have to do it!" She exclaimed, disregarding any concerns Caleb might have expressed.

The move went smoothly, the kids (optional) settled into their new schools, and the Johnsons seemed to take well to their neighbors and received a warm welcome. It had been a year or two since they made Hildebrand Heights their home, and everything seemed to be working out just as planned. Nobody ever mentioned the previous owners of the house, and the Johnsons never asked.

Gangsters, thugs, criminals, were all words used to describe the kind of people that occupied the home prior to the Johnsons. Nobody knows exactly what happened, whether they fled the country, got arrested, or just moved on to their next location. But everyone was glad when all the traffic stopped, the parties subsided, and the neighborhood felt safe once again.

Marcus and Jameson made their way through the 18th green and approached the house from the back. The gate surrounding it more for aesthetics than protection. "You sure this is the house? You sure this is the guy?" Jameson asks Marcus as they approach the back door "Yes! This is definitely the house, this is the guy that got Craig and them locked up and stole all that money! He just sent this to me from inside, he said it was Hildebrand Estates, on the 18th green and has a pool, this is the house!"

They had an alarm, but rarely if ever used it. Sure they would reset the codes and turn it on when leaving for days or weeks at a time, but it got annoying to set it and reset it everyday or get a phone call for a false alarm. They felt safe with their rent a cops patrolling the streets, and the quiet serenity of the golf course behind them.

It wasn't long before they found the master bedroom and were standing over Mr. and Mrs. Johnson. "This is the guy?" Jameson whispers to Marcus, unsure at this point, but not wanting to look dumb he nods an affirmative. Marcus grabbing him by the neck and dragging him from the bed, Caleb wakes up quickly and his eyes go wide, gasping for air unable to make a noise. Jameson grabbing Mrs. Johnson by the hair and dragging her from the bed. "Where is the money?" Marcus asks looking into Caleb's eyes as he shakes his head in confusion...

(Thanks for reading this far, and don't worry, it will get a lot more fun from this point forward. We can take this any number of ways, so I am open to hearing your interests and kinks if you would like to play the rest of this story out. You would obviously being playing Mrs. Johnson. I will allow you full control over her character and however she chooses to react to such a situation. Maybe it's dub-con, or non-con, or full on welcome-con haha. Obviously Mr. Johnson won't necessarily fair too well in the story, but this doesn't have to include violence, perhaps it ends up being a full on cuckolding type of situation? Again, looking for good partners to create the story with, it doesn't have to be this story specifically. Look forward to hearing from all you lady writers of reddit with imagination and creativity!)