TIL from de grasse armada video.

Discussion

so i re-watched part of the de grasse video and i heard something i overlooked the first time. seems WG is trying to tease another degrasse variant, the KM CV version. http://www.german-navy.de/kriegsmarine/zplan/carrier/degrasse/index.html . nothing is stopping WG though. i mean admrl makarov and nuremberg is a perfect example imo. but de grasse as a T6 CV, besides obvious CV mechanics issues, thoughts?

Posted Jun 20, 2017, 5:30 AM UTC

1123
TheBaneOfTheInternetAkagi > Kaga•

Sure it can join the other light carriers at tier VI, but there's not really much to say about it because it's the planes that make or break a carrier.

9
therebelghostWe FIght To The Last Shell•

The only choices for planes would be the modified stukas and stringbag tbs designed for Graf zeppelin. Unless they went totally off the rails and made planes up. I don't see how there is more then one prem German style carrier for all theirs.

Unless it and Graf zeppelin and clones in plane type and vary by number carried.

4
ShuggieHamsterWatching you from on high•

could a ju88 land on a carrier? kinda remember reading somewhere H-111 and Ju-88s dropped italian made torpedos

3
TLAMstrikeStudent of the Jeune École•

One of the few twin engine aircraft that could successfully land and take off on a carrier during the prewar era was the Potez 56. The US made a twin engine carrier fighter during the war, the F7F Tigercat which had a lower takeoff weight than a Ju-88.

The F7F proved far too difficult operate off a carrier and spent it time operating from shore. The F7F was over 3.5 times the weight of the Potez 56, and assuming the Potez 56 could carry a torpedo (it couldn't, but lets just have some fun with it) the weight of an aerial torpedo like the US MK 13 was 1000kg, which so happens to be just shy of the maximum weight of fuel and cargo a Potez 56 could carry.

It was hard to get a heavy twin engine aircraft that could operate off a carrier, in fact you'd have to look to the 1950s for that with the AJ Savage which technically was a three engine aircraft because it had a single turbojet in addition to its two piston engines (each of which were more powerful than the beasts they put in the TBF avenger.)

3
WikiTextBot•

Potez 56

The Potez 56 was a 1930s French executive transport monoplane built by Potez and later used as a military crew trainer and liaison aircraft.


Grumman F7F Tigercat

The Grumman F7F Tigercat is a heavy fighter aircraft that served with the United States Navy (USN) and United States Marine Corps (USMC) from late in World War II until 1954. It was the first twin-engined fighter to be deployed by the USN. While the Tigercat was delivered too late to see combat in World War II, it saw action as a night fighter and attack aircraft during the Korean War.

Designed initially for service on Midway-class aircraft carriers, early production F7Fs were land-based variants. The type was too large to operate from older and smaller carriers, and only a late variant (F7F-4N) was certified for carrier service.


North American AJ Savage

The North American AJ Savage (later A-2 Savage) was a carrier-based medium bomber built for the United States Navy by North American Aviation. The aircraft was designed shortly after World War II to carry atomic bombs and this meant that the bomber was the heaviest aircraft thus far designed to operate from an aircraft carrier. It was powered by two piston engines and a turbojet buried in the rear fuselage. The AJ-1 first became operational in 1950 and several were based in South Korea during 1953 as a deterrent against the Communists.


^[ ^PM ^| ^Exclude ^me ^| ^Exclude ^from ^subreddit ^| ^FAQ ^/ ^Information ^| ^Source ^] ^Downvote ^to ^remove ^| ^v0.22

4
NAmoftonRoyal Navy•

Interesting, never heard of the Savage before.

The de Haviland Sea Mosquito and Sea Hornet are worth a mention, though neither are pre-war. Empty the Mosquito is lighter than the Junkers, but at full load it's similar weight.

1
Skylinehead•

Similar size to a B-25 Mitchell which did fly off the Hornet in the Doolittle Raid but you'd never land it.

1
therebelghostWe FIght To The Last Shell•

They were working on a lighter variant of it specifically for use on Graf Zeppelin. Not sure the specifics, probably stripping everything off that wasn't totally essential.

1
beachedwhale1945Check the Data, then form your theory•

Wargaming would still have some flexibility if they intend to make a full line. For example, regarding fighters, there was the Bf 109T and Me 155. However, using purely historic aircraft this is limited, and as premiums tend to use historic loadouts this makes things difficult. However, as this conversion would only have 23 planes or so, it could work at tier 5 with historic aircraft.

However, they have faced this before with floatplanes, particularly floatplane fighters. Take the A6M2-N and N1K1. These aircraft could not be used on catapults: the fuselage was not modified to be lifted out of the water by a shipboard crane. However, they are used in game. Other ships used floatplane versions of aircraft that were never supposed to be floatplanes, like Des Moines XP-40Q. Wargaming can easily do something similar here if they plane to create a full German CV line (which is possible, but blueprint heavy).

They can also split multiple versions of the same based design into multiple tiers. For example, there are two versions of the F6F, F4U, TBF/M, AD, A6M, D3A, and B7A2, and there are three versions of the SBD, BTD-1/XSB2D. Several of these serve as dive bombers and torpedo bombers, often on the same carriers. This ignores real and imaginary floatplane versions of these aircraft. The Germans did this with the Ju 87, and we can expect similar things if Wargaming creates a full line.

2
NAmoftonRoyal Navy•

Your suggestion seems workable to me.

I don't understand the issue with faked-up aircraft for carriers when we have the faked-up Hindenburg, Roon and Henri V in the tree? Even for premiums the Ishizuchi, Nikolai and now DG show that built/historics isn't vital.

A premium German CV can't use a historic load out, because it never sailed, but DG never sailed as a 9x 152mm CL.

2
VicenteOlisipo•

People who own the current DeGrasse should get the CV for free (ja).

4
stardestroyer001Kidō Butai•

That's like saying people who own Iowa should get Missouri for free.

8
VicenteOlisipo•

Iowa is not a premium though.

1
pdboddyRoyal Navy•

Yeah, and Wargaming just gives away tier 6 premiums for free on a regular basis?

1
dreiak559The starch is strong in this potato (DrEiak@NA)•

Shinonome, Graf Spee.

1
VicenteOlisipo•

No, but they should!

(we all realize this is about a non-existent beyond-hypothetical premium, right?)

1
arstechnophiletechnophile_•

But only if they bought the Iowa premium camo. ;)

1
ShuggieHamsterWatching you from on high•

having never played but watched a lot of WoT contributers over the last couple of years ... WoTs has found itself in a bad place as it runs out of new tanks to bring into the game and its the new lines that bring people into the game its said.

Is WOWs now starting to run into the same problem and starting to create more paper ships to cover the glaring gaps like KM cvs, RU BBs and anything to face the yamato!?

1
pdboddyRoyal Navy•

No. There are still many, many ships, that were actually built, that Wargaming can use. But to build arbitrary "lines" of ships, unfinished/paper ships will be needed to fill some gaps. I don't know what Wargaming's issue is with having partial lines for some tech trees while they seem fine with it in others.

3
mastergenera1OPKriegsmarine•

im a WoT refugee and thats exactly what happened there, after they blew through all the major tanks powers and starting heading to nations with harder designs to balance ( japan) or clone trees (china,sweden) wows is long away from that because we dont even have the all the major naval powers fully in yet, and prolly wont for another year or two. after those trees roll out its up to WG what they do next.

1