Why are there so many graduate students teaching in the math/CS faculty lately?

Why does the University rely so heavily on graduate students for teaching MATH/CS courses lately? In my opinion, the quality of the lectures is much lower on average than those taught by professors and I feel like I'm being cheated by paying for a real instructor and getting taught by a student. This semester, for all the UW courses taught by a grad student, I seem to get more out of just reading the course notes and slides than going to class.

Posted Jun 22, 2017, 3:05 PM UTC

613
taylorsmith2MMath (CS) '17•

Faculty members at Waterloo follow a 2/1/0 teaching system, so they teach two courses in one term, one course in another term, and zero courses in the remaining term. Many conferences and meetings are held during the warmer months, so many faculty members assign their "zero course" term to the spring term so that they can travel. This results in a lack of available instructors, so the departments hire sessional instructors like myself to run these courses for you. (Also, sessional instructors get paid less than faculty members, so if anything, you're saving money.)

Just because we're not faculty members doesn't mean we're not "real instructors". Personally, I put a lot of effort into my lectures, so I hope students don't think I'm one of the bad ones. But departments listen to feedback, so if you're having difficulty with a particular instructor, leave a comment on the course evaluation.

23
bzxzp•

Personally, I put a lot of effort into my lectures, so I hope students don't think I'm one of the bad ones

You're definitely one of the good ones, always appreciate your lectures

9
liljay14CS 2B•

Your lectures are amazing Taylor :) Btw you handled the whole midterm situation like a champ today.

4
uweabloo🦆 stupid sketches•

The goose + midterm piazza poll gave me a good chuckle

5
PPewtComplaining Science & Pure Masochism•

Many conferences and meetings are held during the warmer months, so many faculty members assign their "zero course" term to the spring term so that they can travel. This results in a lack of available instructors, so the departments hire sessional instructors like myself to run these courses for you. (Also, sessional instructors get paid less than faculty members, so if anything, you're saving money.)

The dept is still really understaffed. There were an estimated 100 sessionals in the past 12 months (I'm not sure of the actual numbers: these were the projected numbers from last spring).

Not saying that I have anything against sessionals categorically (although I think there are some problems with them in certain cases, especially postdocs) but the current situation isn't really healthy.

But departments listen to feedback, so if you're having difficulty with a particular instructor, leave a comment on the course evaluation.

AFAIK the faculty only looks at course evaluation numbers, and comments go straight to the instructor.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
BenjaminChurchOPBCS/BBA DD•

Very interesting, good to know about the 2/1/0 system! While I have never had you as an instructor, I think you seem to be very passionate and caring about what is going on.

Although I do have to say that while on aggregate, yes the university is saving money by hiring sessional, I am still paying the same tuition money in spring as people pay in winter and fall. This means that on average all of our tuitions are lower but my outcome is different than theirs and spring courses are inherently less than fall and winter ones.

1
PPewtComplaining Science & Pure Masochism•

I don't know about Math, but:

  • CS grew way too fast for hiring to be able to keep up with enrolment
  • It wasn't given any new positions by the administration (outside the faculty), so the number of faculty remained basically constant despite the student population doubling.

That being said, this has almost certainly been going on for longer than you've been here. It hasn't increased in the last year or anything: in fact, it's getting (very slightly) better.

13
sarah-bellumpsych grad•

Hiring new faculty members is time-consuming, difficult, and expensive. Hiring grad students to teach courses is easy and SUPER cheap relative to faculty. I imagine that's why.

I'm a grad student at a different Ontario university now and I just started teaching courses. It's really useful for me to get the teaching experience. But for the record, I also feel bad for my students that they got stuck with me instead of a real professor. I've tried really hard to be extra prepared and on top of things because I want them to feel like they're getting their money's worth.

8

I've had exactly the opposite experience from you.

6
jott44CS•

Ya, of all the lecturers I've had in CS, I can name 4 profs who absolutely should not be teaching. I can't name a single Grad student lecturer who hasn't been better than those 4 profs combined.

I've got a course this term with a grad student who genuinely cares about the students learning. I also have a course with a prof who spends the majority of the lecture talking about how great he (or his son) is and then skimming through hundreds of slides at a rapid pace.

I would gladly have a less-experienced Grad student who actually cares as a teacher than some of the profs we have in CS.

13
MattAmbsMMath, Applied Math•

Part of the requirements for completing a PhD in the math faculty is teaching a course.

edit: I should say that's at least true for the applied math department. It might vary between departments. Usually, AM PhD candidates will teach a 100/200 level math course.

6
johnlee3013MathematicalPhysics•

A lot of the profs in the summer term go off to do sabbatical, so the university have no choice but to use grad students/post-docs/sessionals to teach the courses.

In the fall/winter term there are much fewer non-actual-profs teaching courses.

4
Uthorr🗺BLENDER DADDY🗺 is here•

The faculty isn't paying enough to attract actual professors

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1