A trend over the last five years or so has been to stain wood floors very dark (coffee / ebony color). The problem with dark floors is that they show EVERYTHING. You basically have to mop or vacuum daily because you see dust immediately. All scratches are extremely apparent. They are really high maintenance.

That being said, I would recommend a light stain or poly. A finisher should be able and willing to put down some samples for you. Also you'll need to consider what type of wood you have. Maple, for example, does not take stain very well/evenly.

4
CobardeOP•

Yea I'll admit; I was gonna be a statistic and go with a super dark color. Thanks for listing out some cons there!

I'm not sure on what type of wood I actually have on the floor, but I'll keep all that in mind. Thanks!

1

Another unintended effect of super dark floors is that they make rooms appear both darker and smaller! That combined with the daily sweeping/mopping -- don't do it!

1
FishnSurf•

The lighter the better, dark has been a trend like stated in the first comment. But if you go light this will always be in style, with dark it is hard to keep clean and it will eventually fade out, real wood look will always stay relevant.

You also could go Poly

2
CobardeOP•

Thanks for the help!

In that case I think I'm gonna keep something close to the normal color http://imgur.com/a/o3K1T and just get it cleaned up.

1
CobardeOP•

Just bought my first house and need some help with what color to stain the floor. Walls are painted a really light blue and the ceiling and trims white.

The floors are a mess and need to be sanded down and refinished; was trying to figure out if I should go with a lighter or darker shade for the floors.

1
Sporothrix•

Just have someone refinish them with poly... you want the natural color with wood. Don't use stain.

5