r/AsianBeauty•
vanityrex

[Review] of Matsuyama Cleansing Gel + a Few Other Polyethylene-Free 1st Cleansers

Review

I know there are a few of you out here who are concerned with the environmental impact of polyethylene/microplastics (see this post for more info), which are included in 90% of cleansing balm type products, so I wanted to discuss a few 1st cleansers that do not contain them that may be of interest for people who dislike the drippiness and/or oiliness of traditional oil cleansers.

Full post here.

The tl;dr:

  • Matsuyama Cleansing Gel - My favorite of the bunch mentioned here. This is a gel-to-oil first cleanser - out of the tube it has a gel texture (resembling vaseline). After applying, the heat of my skin melts/softens the gel and it develops a texture resembling an oil. It takes off my makeup and sunscreen with little effort, does not dry, strip, or irritate my skin, does not cause eye stinging, and is 95% fragrance free (there's a very, very faint sticky-rice type fragrance if I really stick my nose in it). It also emulsifies beautifully and rinses off easily, which is a hugely important factor for me. Not the most exciting product, but if you're in the market for a simple and ultra functional 1st cleanser, this is a really good option

  • Cremorlab TEN Gel Oil Cleanser - This is a beautifully rose scented cleanser with the texture of a fluid gel. When I first got this, I quickly fell in love with the texture and fragrance, but after a few months of use there were two gripes I had with it. The first is this cleanser doesn't have a ton of slip so I have to use a lot of product (3-4 pumps) relative to my other 1st cleansers. The second is this struggles with eye makeup. I prefer not to use standalone eye makeup removers, whenever possible, so that really limits this cleanser's functionality for me.

  • Muji Gel Cleansing - This is an orange scented gel. I've actually been using this primarily as a second cleanser (it's gentle and low pH) but per the product description actually seems to be a first cleanser. It's the most similar product I've found to the Glossier milky jelly cleanser in texture (non-foaming gel) and function (can be used as a first or second cleanser), but has more malleability and produces less tug on my skin. Not my favorite 1st cleanser because the cleansing power is a bit lacking compared to traditional oil cleansers, but it works well enough to have earned a permanent spot in my gym bag.

  • The post also includes reviews of a few other Non-AB Cleansers (Jordan Samuel Plie and Milk Makeup Urban Defense Mask) but I won't dwell on those here.

After having used these, I can say that I'm a huge fan of the gel-to-oil type first cleansers and find it a little difficult going back to using oil cleansers. Have you guys come across any non-oil, non-balm first cleansers that you like?

edit: formatting

Posted Jul 5, 2017, 4:47 PM UTC

6810
spiritswithout•

Muji looks like it would be nice as a morning cleanser for me, but it's a bit expensive after shipping. Do you know if they have a free shipping tier or run coupons? I can't tell from browsing the site.

1
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

They don't. Their online website is really terrible overall, which is really unfortunate. The larger sizes (120 ml and 200 ml) are a lot cheaper by ML if that helps, and there are also a couple of listings for the gel cleanser on ebay with free shipping.

2
jaderabbit22•

Thanks.nice to hear abt review on Matsuyama products. I can hardly find it in here. Thank you.😊

1
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

Such an awesome brand, especially for people looking for stuff without a lot frills but that WORKS

1
YT-Rei•

NIce review - ty!

I was looking at Muji's cleansers last week, I've heard so many good things about them; perhaps I should come back and pick it up... I'm using Calmia Herb Cleansing Oil Gel that I got a while ago from Memebox, but I'm almost out of it, so I was thinking about finding a replacement. Do you think Muji's cleanser will do as 1st cleanser for days when I'm not using any makeup, only sunscreen? That's how I'm using Calmia atm

1
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

I think so! I have to go over eye liners a few times to lift them from my skin but it handles base makeup pretty quickly so it should similarly take off sunscreen!

1
YT-Rei•

thank you!

1
PomegranateTea•

You're the absolute best for doing this!

1
PomegranateTea•

Have you happened to try Innisfree's Jeju Bija gel? I think it was meant to be a first cleanser, but people tend to use it more as a 2nd or even a single step.

If so, would you say the Muji cleanser is similar?

1
vanityrexOPBlogger | vanityrex•

I haven't used the Innisfree cleanser but based off that description, it does sound similar! The only other non-foaming gel cleanser I've used is the Glossier Milky Jelly cleanser, which is another 1st or 2nd cleanser that (IMO) works better as a second cleanser. Compared to that, Muji has more slip and tugs less at my skin, but is otherwise pretty similar as well!

1