Fan's Choice?

I just had a pop-up window in the app ask me to vote between Galen Erso, Krennic, and Cassian (with either Jyn or K-2SO) as the next Fan's Choice insert.....

Posted Jul 7, 2017, 2:01 PM UTC

216
SnTrooper•

Fouled up and lost the pop up and can't get it back to vote. There goes my streak of voting in every FC vote since I signed up (115).

Hate how there are no images. It is going to make it impossible to know what you are voting for when they use a character that has multiple cards with the same name. And the lack of a free card is disappointing too even if it was just a white base. And that also means no way to figure out who is winning by looking at the count to see which one has moved up the most.

So, extremely disappointed in the new vote system. No redeeming qualities to it at all.

1:10 odds? Hopefully that means a return to 1k packs because anything more than 3k will mean a price increase from the last series and make this the most expensive standard FC yet. Unfortunately I'm expecting it to be 5k.

Pay only variant? Eh. They already ruined it with the meld variant last time so why not dig the hole deeper and ruin it for even more people.

4
SnTrooper•

And the fact that this vote is a complete repeat of the S4 week 8 vote with just a different Jyn card in place of the one that won doesn't help either.

1
Jacobs_Cracker•

It could be that the worst character from the 3 may have the only new image and we have blown it by picking the one we like. That's if they don't just continue down the S4 path as they did last time.

1
riborsRIBORS•

Transmission just popped up. Seems similar to last time around in the sense that there are two variants, though no surprise the lower cc variant is a pay bundle 1:5 option instead of a melding option - don't care either way, as the standard option is fine by me. Standard has 1:10 odds...last time it was 1:5 for the first pull, then 1:10; pack cost still needs to be disclosed, though I'm guessing 5K. Design won't be revealed until the winner is announced I guess, but I'll chase no matter what since I have all the other standard FC sets.

2
dsigal•

I don't mind the bundle option, because it's something I can ignore and just chase the normal variant. However, it's clearer and clearer that this is just a place holder for the diamond pack. I think going forward it will just be the new normal that for everything in the app, they will offer both a F2P/credit option and a P2P/diamond option (well not for everything, i'm sure there will be plenty of P2P only elite level cards). For some sets there will just be one card and the different packs will be different odds/costs or released at different times, and for some sets there will be different variants, and some of those variants will be diamond only.

2
8bit_Yoda•

Don't object to the paid version as basic card works for me but feel for those people who have every FC, including s4 melds and saw FC as their jam.

2
riborsRIBORS•

In the eyes of some people, they've been messing up FC ever since S1 ended and went away from Mace Windu packs. Let's take a look:

FC S1 100cc Gold Ackbar & Dexter non-marathon cards. First chink in the FC armor.

FC S2 were "free" but you had to be in the right place at the right time and they completely botched the first couple of weeks leaving people bitter from the very start. Listen to old Card Trader Illuminerdy episodes to see how these "free" cards weren't always so easy to obtain even throughout the length of the marathon. Overall they were cheap ("Free"), though Wicket remained a tough card to acquire for a long time.

FC S3 - suddenly people were outraged that they now had to pay for FC even though it was just 15K per card and you got the Nacho Doritos variety as a bonus. Picking the winners wasn't too hard, except when they briefly got rid of cc. In retrospect so much clutter with all those ugly cards all over the place. They botched the first wave award initially too and took forever to put some of the Nacho winners in the award section. I only collected the Blue Winners and was fine with those. Wave 1 was also the last time we saw shelf awards for FC.

FC S4 - introduction of the meld option limits the amount of people who could say they have "one of every FC". Some liked it as an additional challenge, but I had no interest. Not sure if people were outraged or not, didn't really pay attention. Regular award was fine by me.

FC S5 - introduction of pay bundle variant. Details still to be revealed, but honestly these may wind up higher cc and easier to acquire than the meld options of last time, especially if they are cheap packs (I wouldn't be surprised if they were $1 or $2) and/or have some other incentive in the packs. I'll collect the standard again this time without ever opening a pack. I get it that some people are upset, but it's just the latest in a long line of complaints about FC...I can't get too excited about any of them...I'll save my outrage for a whole lot of other things, LOL :)

If you twist my arm, I'd have to agree that the S1 mechanic was the best, but good luck finding Mace Windu packs in the store ever again.

2
LEFEYETTELEFEYETTE•

Haha yep, everyone goes crazy every new series of FC because they changed the mechanic. Honestly it's the most angry I see people get in the app for some reason. I don't understand how a set as insignificant as FC can cause so much aggression.

2
thidumThidum•

I would speculate it would have something to do with FC being the everyman Marathon, minus snafus. FC has always been F2P, and rarely cost more than one days worth of credits at odds. In addition the method of choosing your pick has given you at least a card, now it is like the sports apps in that respect.

Personally I could care less about the pay variant, but to those who want it, best of luck.

1
LEFEYETTELEFEYETTE•

But that's my point, it has always been easy for F2P yet people have still always complained about it, for not very good reason really. It's never been difficult any Series. Same as this one I expect.

And surely people can't be that upset about not getting 1 white base card now.

Yes the Pay variant changes things this time but people can still chase the normal variant. Fans Choice isn't going to be unobtainable now. I've seen the same people complain this time that complained about the last series, and complained about the Series before that and so on.

But getting angry isn't going to change it, quicker people forget the pay element the quicker they get back to finding something fun to do in app.

1
8bit_Yoda•

Very well put.

Loved FC1, great design, no real pressure to collect and even the odd double dip.

FC2 was really stressful - inconsistent voting times and then the,drop time moving all over the place. Managed to be fun and hell at the same time.

Completely lost interest in FC3 - 15,000 with 4 or 5 (think there was even 6 one week) was just too rich. S3 cards, imo, look horrible and they somehow managed to make the FC design even worse.

FC4 was cool by me - loved the design, simple mechanic and with no interest in the meld it worked a treat for me.

1:10 odds for FC5 is same rate as FC1...I await the pack price, hopefully 2,500 if it's 10,000 I'll be upset.

1
KeithyT1999KEITHYT1999•

Ok I voted using the pop-up message. That's it right? Now we wait for the packs which will contain the winner. No free base card this time is the only difference?

1
BOSSK_lunch•

I'm in the habit of closing dumb pop-up adverts on my iPad, so I closed the voting window without casting a vote. Now, I'm unable to vote. At least it's full screen on an iPhone (not sure if it's the same for Android phones/tablets).

The Pack Wrap looks godawful (not that the previous one was all that pretty).

Regardless, it seems kinda lame to not get a free base card after making a FC vote. It's like this build gets worse and worse as you peel back the layers of wallpaper.

1
atomic_ringNUNODEOLIVEIRAMIRANDA•

I have to ask: people keep saying that it should be free, etc. Were the packs for the previous sets free? Or are they complaining that they don't get the free whites from the voting? EDIT: And u/ribors just answered above. Thx!

1
atomic_ringNUNODEOLIVEIRAMIRANDA•

After reading the transmission, I have this to add: Topps, leave the office right now and go buy a grammar. Do it now.

1