Room Mimic
I'm converting an AD&D module to 5e and wanted to use the room mimic it called for. This is my first homebrew that isn't just applying templates or flavor change. Any glaring errors or miscalculations? I know the Stealth bonus is wrong but its off for 5e's mimic too.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1j9uC5iPdzLST1IMw-wF1BfKRxjytwj7Y84v80dbU2Ek/edit?usp=sharing
Update: Made many of the changes suggested by u/HerpDerp1909. Room Mimic now has Amorphous Form and Killer Response from White Maw.
Note: CR is calculated with the 1.5x HP modifier; one of the party members uses a lot of acid-based spells, being a Black dragonborn sorcerer. This creature is not to punish that player, I swear. Just trying to recreate the spirit of the module.
Posted Jul 8, 2017, 12:58 AM UTC · edited
Going through these one at a time:
AC should either be 11 or 12 (natural armor). It is always 10 + Dex modifier, so if it doesn't have a higher AC than that there is no need to point out natural armor. If it is supposed to have an AC of 10 either give it a neutral Dex modifier and remove natural armor or give it a negative Dex modifier.
Are you sure you want to give it INT 10? That would make it as smart as the average human.
The MM Mimic's stealth isn't off. It has Expertise. That means it adds double it's proficiency bonus to that skill. For a CR 7 creature proficiency is +3 and Stealth, in this case, would be +7. Unless you change the Dex modifier because of its AC.
Damage Resistances, Damage Immunities and Condition Immunities are usually listed separately.
The Escape DC for the Adhesive trait is dependent on the Mimic's Strength modifier. It is 13 for the regular Mimic as it's 8 + prof (2) + Str (3) = 13. For your Mimic it would be 8 + 3 + 4 = 15.
If you have Tales of the Yawning Portal consider looking up the rules used in there for White Maw. It's an Ooze that takes the form of an entire room (covering the walls).
Average damage for its Pseudopod and Bite should be 17 not 7.
As it's a huge creature it's range for its Pseudopods should at least be 10ft. if not 15.
Damage is way too low for a CR 7 creature. 17 to 21 damage per round is fitting for CR 2-3 creatues. Consider giving it Multiattack with up to 3 Pseudopod attacks or two Pseudopod and one Bite attack. (Especially if this is supposed to be a solo-encounter with just your party against only the Mimic)
CR is also off. With the adjustments I suggested (and a very questionable x2 modifier on its HP because of its Acid immunity) its CR barely hits 7 (6.6)
Without the HP modifier for Acid immunity (because I don't think a lot of players will be using acid damage exclusively) it drops to a 6 (5.6)
The version you currently have is a CR 4 (3.6)
So not bad as a first try, but definitely still needs some work.
Don't worry though, it's something you learn by doing it.
Thanks. Missed a lot of stuff like the average damage and save DC since I was modifying the mimic's stats. For notes I keep immunities together since for my personal use they rarely add up enough to need separation.
Multiattack is appropriate. Thanks!
You're welcome, I also needed someone to look over my Homebrew Monsters when I started, heck I probably still do. xD
One last tip I can give you, is to always look for monsters that already have features like or atleast similar to what you are envisioning. Being able to take a feature from one official monster and to give it to another definitely streamlines the process. So if you have access to the Tales from the Yawning Portal definitely look up White Maw.