Pyros + Spirit Echo

Discussion

Unfortunately I did not get a screenshot or anything for "proof" but wanted to share an interaction which happened to me just now:

I was playing control warrior, and my Un'goro pack gave me Pyros, Spirit Echo and a Mirage Caller. So naturally I drop Pyros, Mirage Caller it and then Spirit Echo the field.

First Pyros dies (the copy) - I get a 6/6 to my hand but no Spirit Echo Pyros.

Mirage Caller dies and returns to my hand.

Second Pyros dies (the original - I get a 6/6 to my hand but no Spirit Echo Pyros.

Is this an intentional interaction or a bug? I am assuming a bug?

TL;DR: Pyros doesn't return with Spirit Echo.

Posted Jul 10, 2017, 6:14 PM UTC

48
ShinRobotK•

Not a bug. Spirit Echo and Pyros' effect both do the same thing (return a minion to your hand when it dies), so when one resolves (in this case Pyros' deathrattle as it was in play earlier than the Spirit Echo deathrattle) there is no more minion on the battlefield to return. This is the same reason why double Spirit Echo still only returns one minion to your hand.

5
IGNashnuOP•

Ok, that makes sense, having never used Spirit Echo outside of Un'goro packs I was unfamiliar with it. Thanks for clarification.

1
FrankelHS•

Yeah had a guy play spirit echo twice on his minions earlier and he only got back one copy of each.

1
hongyu1230•

intentional, the original 6/6 return effect overrides the spirit echo effect, echo/pyros does not give you a copy of it.

1
DraconKing•

It's probably because of the "Return to your hand" mechanic. It's like if it had been sapped or shadowstep.

1
ToxicAdamm•

I don't understand why you don't get the 2/2 back in your hand. Seems like a bug/oversight to me.

If you use Pyros with Rivendare you (reportedly) get 2 6/6's back in your hand. Seems like the same sort of thing should happen here (but instead you would get a 2/2 and 6/6).

1
IGNashnuOP•

To my understanding from what has been said it is because Pyros returns to your hand from it's deathrattle meaning the deathrattle from Spirit Echo "fizzles" as it has no target anymore.

With that said, if it does work for Rivendare it should work for Spirit Echo XD

1
godfire556•

I most definitely SHOULD give you 2 in your hand, but hearthstone has notoriously inconsistent wording on its cards. When you play spiritsinger umbra and then play pyros, you get a 2/2 on board and a 6/6 in hand. When baron rivendare is in play and pyros dies, you get 2 2/2s. Spirit echo should bring the 2/2 back to your hand and you should additionally get a 6/6 in your hand from the deathrattle effect on the card.

EDIT: example here: https://www.reddit.com/r/hearthstone/comments/672j1p/spiritsinger_umbra_pyros_interaction/

EDIT 2: It seems like this was changed in a later patch, so maybe disregard my post: https://www.reddit.com/r/hearthstone/comments/6ex2mc/patch_change_to_spiritsinger_umbra_pyros/

1