r/discgolf•
JSCMI

Question about arm speed, disc speed, and throw type

I am curious if most players have one upper limit for arm/disc speed for standstill throws vs a different upper limit they can get distance out of stepping up to their drive. My thought is that pretty much everyone is developing and has an upper limit, and I assume everyone is more accurate from a standstill and therefore will prefer to throw it when a shot is inside of that range.

I'm wondering if most players keep track of separate upper limits for standstill throws vs x-step drives. Do you have a go-to disc for standstill drives to maximize accuracy? And then faster discs you go to when you're stepping up?

Or once someone can throw a certain speed disc then will a slower disc always get less distance, and the step-up affects distance/accuracy independent of their upper limit?

Posted Jul 10, 2017, 7:36 PM UTC

17
PMacLCA•

I'm probably atypical but I prefer to do a small xstep for anything outside of 'fan grip' range, which for me is about 125'. But sometimes the course prevents a walk up and a standstill is the only option, it just doesn't feel as natural without the walk up.

2
jfb3Wind? What wind? | Tag #1657•

I carry lighter/flippier versions of my main throwers.

I use these for standstill, uphill, turnovers, downwind, or lower powered shots that need to hit a small gap/tunnel.

A couple of different distance drivers, a control driver, and a fairway.

2
JSCMIOP•

Hmm... didn't expect these references. Am I over-developing my standstill shots? Currently throwing 275' or so with a Teebird at the field, or a faster disc might be either side of 300 feet. My thinking has been that I don't want to add the variables of the x-step until I have my weight shift and pull pretty good.

2
SidearmAustinDenver RHFH/RHBH•

You're fine working on stand still. There's less motions, and there are plenty of players that will opt for stand stills for anything up to 300'.

You can watch Heavy Disc/Loopghost standstill throw putters 275', and his advice is to work on stand still or one steps until you can incorporate the x-step. I think stand still Teebird throws may be tad overkill, but it isn't going to hurt your form. As far as practical application if someone is reaching for a Teebird they probably aren't going to stand still. For example I only standstill putters - anything else is an X-step

2
seabas22•

I will use an x-step at 60 or 70%, rather than a standstill at 80%+. High effort standstills will spray more left/right because there is higher rotation to linear ratio so while the distance may be spot on - the left/right spray increases, vs an x-step that gives a higher linear to rotational ratio that will presumably help keep the disc on a specific line and not spray left/right, but may spray more short/long distance wise and give better odds for hitting the basket.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mpp7ZFLHK90

2
M0b1u5NZDG. Always one step sideways.•

Not quite. At least, not for me. A standstill shot is something I do when I don't have an option to use a small and slow x-step.

The x-step is what provides the timing and rhythm of a throwing motion, and so for many people, using a small x-step means better timing, and hence more accurate throws.

However, developing a 90-metre stand-still throw is something that all players can achieve, and should achieve, if they follow what Jason's on about over here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pleUjYKwf0g

There are plenty of times when you won't be able to x-step, and having a straight-up 300-foot shot from a standstill is a very powerful weapon in your disc golf arsenal.

2
brofuBFJ•

I would say it kind of boils down to having less moving parts in your throws if you want more accuracy.

A refined stand still should be very accurate but it's hard to get a lot of distance versus an x-step that isn't in the rough.

My standstill limit is probably around 125 feet. I like to use a destroyer and throw it on a flex for forehands. I like to use a buzz for backhands.

My preference would be to x-step up to every throw over 100 feet since my standstills hurt my hips (i have sciatica and the weight shift isn't good for it).

A slower speed disc is sometimes the right option. It does come down to comfort and preference.

1